A case study comparing two business organisations, investigating the extent to which each has developed an effective customer service programme, and evaluating the effect of those programmes on customer satisfaction.

Authors Avatar
Task: You need to produce a case study comparing two business organisations, investigating the extent to which each has developed an effective customer service programme, and evaluating the effect of those programmes on customer satisfaction.

The organisations that I am comparing are Marks & Spencer Plc and Tesco.

Marks & Spencer Plc

(a)

Customer service

Their Vision

'Leading standards wherever we trade epitomises the Marks & Spencer approach to both the way we serve our customers and the way we run our business.

As one of the UK's leading retailers, we have annual sales in excess of £8 billion. We employ more than 60,000 people worldwide, operate more than 400 stores in 28 countries, and serve tens of millions of customers every week.

Whether we're working at home or abroad, within our own stores or in partnership with our franchisees, our Vision, Mission and Values remain the same. Ensuring we meet our customers' needs with appealing, superior quality products at attractive prices.'

People are the lifeblood of our stores' success

They launched their Foundations For Success programme to set out new ways of working in stores, and new levels of customer service to aim for. The initiative focuses attention on 'power hours', the key time of day when each different store is at its busiest, and everyone available helps on the sales floor. The programme also ensures regular team briefings and a concentration on all the little efficiencies and 'shop keeping' tasks that add up to making it really easy and enjoyable for their customers to shop.

Above all, it has encouraged colleagues to become accountable for the performance of their store. This, along with a new bonus scheme based on store sales targets where colleagues can earn a bonus above their salary, and the general recovery in sales, has seen a major leap in the motivation of the people within Marks & Spencer, which they believe now shows in the service they provide. They hope that by building on the Foundations For Success they can progress to the point where Marks & Spencer is recognised as the clear market leader for service standards.

Training also plays a major role in improved customer service, and they have decked out a 'model' store of 30,000 sq ft at White City for just that purpose. Colleagues visit to improve their sales and service techniques and learn about visual display principles. They have also implemented a training module for all their lingerie sales teams to help them advise customers on the most appropriate underwear. Similarly, 500 colleagues working in their new Home service centres can take advantage of a customer service training package. Uniquely on the high street, both these training courses can lead to a BTEC qualification.

Changing the way they work also applies to all the central administration and support roles, and work to create an inspirational and efficient business environment is well under way. They are calling this the Grand Union Programme, and one major part is the relocation of activities from Baker Street to purpose-built premises at Paddington Basin. This is scheduled for completion by March 2004, and gives them the opportunity to release the financial asset they have in Baker Street.

In describing their performance over the year it is also important to recognise the efforts of the many able managers they have added to their teams, from outside the Group as well as from within. In fact, it has become generally easier to recruit talented staff, as more and more

people are attracted by the opportunity of being part of the growing number of successes at Marks & Spencer.

'My job begins the moment the customer walks through the door. I manage a team of 56 people whose job it is to take care of our customers' needs and, to me it's one of the most important jobs in the store. I believe the whole shopping experience should be perfect, which means keeping the tills working, the queues moving and every member of staff is motivated and knows their role. It's a bit like managing a football team - filling gaps, making sure every angle is covered and supporting and encouraging the team when it's busy. We all want our customers to enjoy shopping with us, especially with the recent Per Una launch and store renewal programme.' Mr P S Walters (Manager).

(b)

What is customer service?

The provision of a high standard of customer service is an important part in the overall performance of an organisation. Many organisations would not be able to maintain a satisfactory level of sales, or be able to maintain a competitive edge in the modern business environment without effective customer service. You need to be aware that customer service involves:

* Presenting an image of the organisation

* Making sure that the needs of the customer are met by the product or service offered

* Providing information

* Giving advice

* Taking and relaying messages

* Keeping records

* Providing assistance

* Dealing with problems

* Handling complaints

The importance of customer service

An organisations level of sales is greatly influenced by the standard of customer service that it encourages in its staff. A high standard of customer service is important for an organisation in order to achieve the following objectives:

* Increase sales

* Gain a competitive advantage

* Maintain customer loyalty

* Attract new customers

* Gain customer satisfaction

* Encourage a motivated and efficient workforce

* Enhance the organisations image

Customer Service in Marks & Spencer operates to ensure that all the objectives are continually monitored received and changes made are appropriate.

The three main considerations of how the functions operate are as follows:

Efficiency and Response

Marks & Spencer value the need to be immediately responsive to customer requirements. This may be achieved in many ways, e.g. answering the telephone quickly, having sufficient products always in stock, e.g. 95% target and being able to repair products at relatively short notice.

Sales Service

Throughout their contact with customers Marks & Spencer try to ensure total customer satisfaction. Well-trained staff and efficient and effective systems are important to make sure that all is being done to achieve this goal.

After Sales Service

Marks & Spencer's responsibility comes as far as the customers concern, it does not cease when the product or service has been sold. It is an increasingly important feature for the business that they have enhanced and developed their after sales service. For Marks & Spencer it means having systems in place to cope with complaints, queries and returns of damaged or faulty goods.

Customer service in Marks & Spencer involves the following:

Presenting an image of the organisation

Marks & Spencer work within the community. Marks & Spencer is partnering Crime Concern in running a national awards scheme, to find the best crime prevention and community safety projects across Britain and to reward crime reduction volunteers working for safer communities. The scheme will recognise and reward winning projects by offering capacity building training and access to all Crime Concern's seminars and conferences; certificates and trophies will also be presented at Crime Concern's Annual conference.

Recycling

Product Packaging

Packaging Marks & Spencer's goods is vital, both to reduce waste by protecting products from damage and to communicate important information to their customers. They are committed to using recycled material, and helping us to recycle, wherever possible.

Using recycled materials

Along with other retailers, they use recycled metal and glass packaging as a matter of course. But where recycled material isn't the norm, such as in cardboard product packaging, they try hard to make sure that all Marks & Spencer packaging which can contain recycled material, does.

"Over 90% of Marks & Spencer product packaging is recyclable in most parts of the country. To promote this fact, and to help you identify different materials, we use symbols (which you can find in How can I help) on a number of our products."

Coat hangers

Every year they also collect and return over 60 million coat hangers, raising money for local environmental projects chosen by staff. By doing this they have saved over 2000 tonnes of waste plastic every year. All of their stores return unwanted coat hangers in special 'recycling boxes' which are sorted, cleaned and re-packaged for re-use by their clothing suppliers. Even damaged or obsolete items are collected, as these can be recycled into new hangers."

"Everytime you decline to keep a coat hanger we donate 0.5p to charities."

The community

Marks & Spencer is set to reinforce its commitment to the community with the nationwide launch of an initiative to help the homeless find jobs.

To minimize the impact of simply 'dumping' unsold food on landfill sites they give managed food donations to various local charities, all of which are chosen by local store staff.

"Our employees willingly give up their spare time to raise cash and volunteer for a wide range of charities and local organisations. We are committed to giving them financial support, and provide schemes to help them become actively involved in their communities."

They launched "Our Foundations For Success" programme to set out new ways of working in stores, and new levels of customer service to aim for. The initiative focuses attention on 'power hours', the key times of day when each different store is at its busiest, and everyone available helps on the sales floor. The programme also ensures regular team briefings and a concentration on all the little efficiencies and 'shop keeping' tasks that add up to making it really easy and enjoyable for their customers to shop.

All of the above is very important for Marks & Spencer as it enhances their image.

Making sure that the needs of the customer are met by the product or service offered

Marks & Spencer identified a number of major issues to address during the year as part of their recovery strategy for Clothing -product appeal, quality and fit, availability, pricing and segmentation, or in other words, making sure they have something for everyone. Their aim was to produce higher quality goods, deliver them more quickly, and to do so at better prices. But strictly in that order of priority - better, faster, lower cost.

Marks & Spencer took the Quality Food & Drink Awards by storm in November 2002, winning 11 awards at the food retail industry's prestigious event, including the coveted Gold Q Award.

The Q Awards, launched in 1979, are one of the food industry's premier events rewarding excellence to innovative, quality products available through supermarkets and major food retailers. The panel of judges ranged from food industry experts to writers and chefs, including Pat Chapman of The Curry Club, food writer Roz Denny and nutritionist Fiona Hunter.

Winning these awards is testament to the passion, enthusiasm and hard work of Marks &

Spencer's team of food experts. They only use the very best quality ingredients to create the most exciting and innovative products. "We are delighted that we won ten Silver Q awards as well as the prestigious Gold Q Award" - which the judges give to the product, that in their opinion, has that something extra special.

An example of a service that Marks & Spencer provide is:

* Flower Ordering - To ensure your flowers are received in peak condition, they have been carefully grown, picked and protected at every stage. For optimum life and freshness, some flowers may arrive in bud.

* Shopping Online - You are able to shop online at www.marksandspencer.com, this would increase sales and attract new customers as those who are older or maybe disabled may not be able to get out to shop, therefore satisfying the needs to their customers.

* Bilingual Staff Available

* Cake Ordering

* Carry To Car

* Cash Point Machine

* Cashback

* Collect By Car

* Customer Ordering Online

* Customer Seating

* Customer Service Desk

* Hearing Loop Tills

* Reservations

* Sandwich Platter Ordering

* Special Needs Pack
Join now!


* VAT back service

* Wine advisor

Marks and Spencer provide a lot of services to satisfy and meet the needs of their customers.

All of the above is also very important to for Marks & Spencer as they increase customer satisfaction so therefore increase their sales.

Providing Information

Marks & Spencer offer customers a lot of information. Customers are able to phone Marks & Spencer and listen to the opening hours. The customer has the option to either connect with an operator or just listen to the opening times. Again this ...

This is a preview of the whole essay