• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Standing Female Nude

Extracts from this document...


Standing Female Nude Within the framework of recent critiques by women art historians of traditionalist male theorizing about the female body, this essay explores the way that Carol Ann Duffy's "Standing Female Nude" can be read as a similar challenging of the gender biases that inform Robert Browning's defense of a Renaissance painter of nudes in his poem, "With Francis Furini." My purpose in the following essay, therefore, is to explore the way that these two poems constitute a kind of intertextual equivalent of the debate about the female nude currently conducted by art historians. I will thus begin by briefly outlining the major features of Nead's critique of Clark's study, and then go on to show how Browning's poem invokes tradition, arguing in favor of the artist. Turning then to Duffy's poem, I will show how she encodes and deconstructs the ideology informing such arguments, whereby her poem functions as a defense of the model. In contrast to Browning's "defense of the artist" stance, Carol Ann Duffy's "Standing Female Nude" focuses attention on the subject of art, the model. Whereas Browning attempts to expunge gender and class difficulties, Duffy's poem moves through what Linda Kinnahan calls a "process of self-deconstruction" (2), to reveal the model as situated within or mediated by social discourses. ...read more.


In a final turn of sorts, she then assumes authority by telling Georges that ultimately he is poorer than she, reminding us that both she and the artist depend on her modeling for survival, be it aesthetic or economic. Museums, of course, are a prime site of aesthetic commercialization and gender politics, even if they pretend otherwise - a point made by Carol Duncan in her study of the way that the Metropolitan Museum of Art has become masculinized because of the art forms it houses: while museums are supposed to be "public spaces dedicated to the spiritual enhancement of all who visit them," in practice "they are prestigious and powerful engines of ideology" (348). Although Browning's poem does draw attention to aesthetic politics, Duffy does so with a specific view toward historicizing the way that museums have been dangerous to the women being represented in them: Belly nipple arse in the window light I shall be represented analytically and hung in great museums. He is concerned with volume, space. It does not look like me. (2-28) In her discussion of the poem, Thomas has identified Georges as a Modernist painter, pointing out that his name seems to be evocative of the Cubist artist Georges Braque. In addition, we might note not only his concern with the analytics of "volume, space" but also the way that he seems to focus in Picasso fashion on "Belly nipple arse." ...read more.


Of course, there is a risk involved; you might not end up telling a fairy-tale with a happy ending, but at least you are the narrator and are in control of the means of narration" (82). Such verbal control, of course, is also the bottom line of "With Francis Furini," which enlists painting ultimately for the purpose of demonstrating the poet's power. In doing so, however, Browning also perpetuates the standard gender hierarchy: in essence he feminizes both painting and painter and presents the naked female body as something formless that most be given shape by the male artist, be it painter or poet. In contrast, "Standing Female Nude" negotiates a variety of seeming polarities: Cubist art and the formalities of a nude art tradition, "Art" and various "arts," the artist as powerful male and the model as powerless female. Similarly, by simultaneously working within and deconstructing traditional notions about the female nude, Duffy's poem creates a space where the model need not be locked into an unchanging and objectifying signification. Finally, by using an internal dramatic monologue, a mode often associated with Browning, Duffy reshapes that verbal form into a strategic platform from which the transgressive female body speaks about the violations done against it in the name of a High Art tradition, be it visual or literary. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Art & Design section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Art & Design essays

  1. Personal study for art

    If most American cities are about the consumption of culture, Los Angeles and New York are about the production of culture - not only national culture but global culture. It's good to keep in mind that prominence is always a mix of hard work, eloquence in your practice, good timing and fortuitous social relations.

  2. Standing Female Nude by Carol Ann Duffy

    "He drains the colour from me," suggests that the artist is taking away her vitality and interest, and she is left sitting bored and lack-lustre whilst he paints her. In the second paragraph we learn that the relationship between the artist and his model is very distant since he is only concerned with "volume, and space."

  1. The Metropolitan Museum of Art Case Study.

    MET shops in different states, restaurant, caf´┐Ż, bar and the parking garage. They also have benefit events where some galas are attended and they provide travel programs hosted by MET. Donation from Corporate Sponsorships - The Met makes great effort to match the 30 annual special exhibits to corporations' activities to entice them to fund the exhibits.

  2. Personal Study - Journeys.

    The wrecked ship, part of William Parry's expedition to the Arctic in 1819-20, seen on the right, is tiny in comparison to the ice - therefore demonstrating the dominance of nature over man. Friedrich was a major figure in the Romantic Movement, which sought to depict emotions such as loneliness and desolation.

  1. A Commentary on “Standing Female Nude”

    Through this lack of punctuation it is as though the narrator knows that those are the things which the painter has desired, as though he does not care that she is a person, but merely an object for his to paint.

  2. Personal Study on artist Mark Demsteader

    Richard Young Richard Young is a British artist, born in Yorkshire in 1961, and now based in North Devon, UK where he has an office and studio. Though he usually worked with pencil and chalk to produce his work drawing, he began oil painting around the age of 12.

  1. "Art upsets, science reassures" (Braque). Analyze and evaluate this claim.

    But I cannot think of someone that would not feel upset by the tragedy seen in Blood Wedding. It is possible though that there be an appreciation for the style of the play- which can be reassuring in some way.

  2. An Examination of the Pre 20th Century Female Nude Painted by Men

    The same fluid curves which define fertility to me, could suggest attraction to the artist and were in fact erotic. Furthermore, viewing the work now in the twenty first century compels me to have an opinion which would most probably be very different to the people viewing it when Botticelli created his portrayal of the female form.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work