• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

"Failure of the Australian legal system to provide true justice have been blamed on its use of the adversarial method and on its relative in accessibility to many ordinary people. Discuss."

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

"Failure of the Australian legal system to provide true justice have been blamed on its use of the adversarial method and on its relative in accessibility to many ordinary people. Discuss." The Australian legal system uses the adversary system in solving legal disputes. The adversary system is a judicial process where an independent and impartial judge administers justice in courts and two opposing parties present allegations and counter allegations regarding a legal dispute placed before the court by one or both parties. (B.Bash, 2001, Legal Studies Essentials, pg.164) The adversary system has many basic features and are elaborated in the following. First and foremost, the disputes take place before an independent and impartial judge or judge and jury. (Brown & Bailey, 1997, Legal Studies, pg.173, para 8) The judge in the adversary system has a passive role, meaning that they are independent from the executive body and cannot simultaneously perform functions of the Judicial and Executive or Legislative body. This is also an enforcement of the Doctrine of Separation of Power. The judge is also a person who has no personal interest in the outcome of the case. Other than that, the judge also has the role of determining the admissibility of evidence at a voir dire, oversee the empanelment of jury, act as an adviser to the jury, and protecting the rights of the witnesses, accused, and victims. ...read more.

Middle

In the inquisitorial system, the use of legal representatives or lawyers are not necessary. The parties usually just represent themselves because in the inquisitorial system, truth is believed to be discovered through enquiry and not powerful argument like in the adversary system and hence, the parties need not have too much legal background and would not have to waste the money in hiring a lawyer. Next, the presumption of innocence until proven guilty also applies in the system. However, it differs from the adversary system in the sense that the case would not commence unless there is strong evidence against the accused and hence, the assumption of guilt once the trial begins is heavy. In the adversary system, the defendants have the right to remain silent and hence can choose not to reveal certain things and this makes it harder for the case to be resolved. However, in the inquisitorial system, no such right exists and the defendants and witnesses must answer all the questions put to them. Another feature that differs in comparison with the adversary system is that there is an extra type of verdict available in the inquisitorial system, being the intermediate verdict. An intermediate verdict is a verdict that says that the accuse is neither innocent nor guilty but has to be further proven to decide. ...read more.

Conclusion

Confidentiality is also another plus point of the ADRs. This is because the disputes are not heard openly in the courts. (B.Bash, 2001, Legal Studies Essentials, pg.163) The Australian legal system has slowly been accepting alternative methods to resolving disputes other than the adversarial system. Various use of the Alternative Dispute Resolution methods have already been put to use as shown above. Other than that, the advantages of the inquisitorial system has also been reviewed and it has slowly, but only to a certain extent made its way into the Australian legal system. Aspects of the inquisitorial system have been incorporated into the courts and tribunals in the country. (Brown & Bailey, 1997, Legal Studies, pg.202, para 5) The Equal Opportunity Tribunal for example, has an inquisitorial method. Besides that, the Coroner's Court in which is located in Adelaide has the features of the inquisitorial system as well. The power is vested in the coroner by the Coroner's Act. (Brown & Bailey, 1997, Legal Studies, pg.202, para 5) All in all, the adversarial method used by the Australian legal system has shown its flaws, and the advantages of other methods of resolving disputes have been reviewed. It can be seen that the Australian legal system is slowly adopting these other methods of resolving disputes such as Tribunals, Alternative Dispute Resolutions, and also the Inquisitorial system to a certain extent. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level ICT in Business section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level ICT in Business essays

  1. AN UNDERSTANDING OF THE NERVOUS SYSTEM

    Keep in mind that motor skills are controlled by the opposite half of the brain, thus a left-brain stroke would cause paralysis on the right side of the body.

  2. Apple Incorporation - Case Analysis

    Return on equity is the income earned on the shareholder's investment in the company. Apple performed well from 1998 through 2000 but went negative in 2001 with only a modest improvement in 2002 and 2003. The pattern here is the same as with return on assets.

  1. An I.T. System for Estate Agents

    If this is not entered the computer will automatically tell you that you have made an error and it will not let you continue until it has been corrected. When using validation rules you have to make sure that you write in validation text as well so that if a

  2. Business options

    26th of February 2009 Plan what security software I will be researching Yes 6th March 2009 Develop the different types of ideas for how I will present my research Yes 18th of March 2009 Interview with professional and have my work proof read.

  1. There are many ways in which business can be organized

    This is known as the divorce of ownership and control. The PLC has to publish its annual accounts (known as disclosure of accounts) and therefore is extremely vulnerable to investors' and bankers' perceptions about its progress and success. Following on from this, a PLC is also at risk from a

  2. The Entourage System: A Feasibility Study

    In order to get the most out of the interfaces, there are certain guidelines we will follow in the design. * Pages should allow excellent picture quality to be displayed whilst paying attention to maintain fast response rates in uploading and downloading.

  1. Reform of the Justice System

    Over the years, tribunal costs and usage has increased a vast amount. For example, Employment tribunals have risen by 50 percent in the last 2 years. Legal, management and recruitment expenses alone rose for the UK business from �426 million in 1999 to �633 million in 2001.

  2. Compare and discuss contrast between Staples.com & Boo.com

    Metrics aren't the only encouraging signs. The Staples site also recently won a prestigious award for best business-to-business site from MIMC, the Massachusetts Interactive Media Council (www.boston.internet.com/news/article.php/494001). D. What could Staples.com have done differently that might made it a failure?

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work