Jack the Ripper - Source based questions.

Authors Avatar

1)

Looking at the source A, I can see that the murders of Polly Nicholls and Martha Tabram were linked. The source tells us that the two women were ‘of the poorest of the poor’. Both women were prostitutes. The source suggests that the murders were committed by a ‘demented being’; this was because of the ‘extraordinary violence’. This would be committed by the same person. But know other sources believe that that these two murders may have been committed by two different people. You cannot rely on this source too much because it is a newspaper article that means the information has probably been changed, they are not 100%, because it is only interested in news, about sales. This newspaper leaves out many bits of information on the murders, like where they took place (George Yard and Bucks Row) and when it happened.

2)

Source C is a report by Doctor on the body of Elizabeth Stride. Source B is a coroners report on the death of Polly Nicholls. Source A is an article from the newspaper describing the murders of Martha Tabram and Polly Nicholls.

Source C supports the evidence in source B, they both describe the how the ripper had ‘anatomical skill and knowledge’ and how much skill had been put into the murders. Source C talks about cutting the windpipe ‘completely in two’ which shows that this was a planned it didn’t just happen like the one described in source A. Source B says there are ‘no Meaningless cuts’ and ‘no mere slaughter of animals could have carried out these operations’ which suggests that the murderer was a doctor. Source B and C are official reports written by professionals.

Source A is different to the other sources e.g. describing the murderer as ‘demented’, this was said because the source was only interested in the news sales and it wanted to sell.  B and C are both written in professionally describing every detail. Source A is written to shock and it doesn’t really have that much detail. Source C supports source B and they both disagree with source A.

Source C supports source B and they both disagree with source A.

Join now!

3)

Source D is a description of the Ripper by Elizabeth Long, it says the Ripper had a ‘dark complexion’; it says that he ‘a dark coat’, deerstalker hat’ and was a ‘foreigner’. Source E is newspaper article after the murders of Polly Nicholls and Annie Chapman. It says that the police were told they needed more police officers on the streets, because they do not do enough about the murders

The problem with source D and most of the description of the Ripper is not clear, she often says ‘I think’ and ‘I cannot be sure’ this shows ...

This is a preview of the whole essay