• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

National Diploma, Business, year 2 / Contracts and Legislation

Extracts from this document...


Contracts and Legislation Assignment 2 Guy Habgood Scenario P2, M1 Adam runs Eden Garden Centre near to Winchester and was included in assignment 1. He is seeking advice about his business contracts and related topics and describes several situations he has encountered recently. You are required to write a short report to Adam. 1. Explain to Adam how the Implied terms within the Sale of Goods Act 1979 (as amended) sections 12-15, relate to the following instances. In each case explain how the consumer legislation may protect the consumer. A.)Regarding case A, the sack of grass seed sold to the football grounds man is different to that which was described by Adam. Therefore due to the seeds germinating a different variety of turf Adam is in breach of contract. Adam may have breached the contract under s13 Sale of Goods Act, through the form of the description (description may be given through word of mouth or by written notice put in place by the seller) or through sales by sample and description (where the sale is by sample as well as by description, the seller will be in breach of s13 because even if the goods match the sample if they do not match the description the seller is liable). Relevant Case Law (s13 Beale v Taylor, 1967) This case I believe is relevant to Adams situation regarding case A as it was a major breakthrough case during the 1960's where by a car was described in good faith by the seller but turned out later to be two halves of two different cars welded together. This relates to the sack of grass seed described by Adam which later turned out to be different to what was previously stated. B.)As to case B, due to the sales assistants lack of knowledge unfortunately Adam would be liable as the staff at Eden Garden Centre are his own personal responsibility. ...read more.


* s15 the goods must correspond with their samples * Unfair contract terms act 1977 (4 correspond to any sample which has been provided.) Below I have gone into more detail regarding these pieces of statutory legislation. S13 Sales by Sample and Description Under s13 Bobby Smith may have grounds to sue as sample and description he chose did not turn out to be the sample he received. The seller, in this case Eden Nurseries will be in breach of s13. This is because even though the trees matched the sample they did not match the description which stated that they where a "rare apple tree" on these grounds Eden Nurseries is in breach of contract and Bobby would have grounds to sue. S13 the Relationship of Description to Quality In the case of Bobby Smith the relationship of the description compared to the quality is of a poor standard. The description given is incorrect as the trees are later found not to be as rare as described and the trees are diseased indicating a low quality. It is the obligation of Eden Nurseries to supply an acceptable standard of quality to its consumers as well as to correctly state the description of the trees. Unfortunately there has been a failure to do so and Eden Nurseries are therefore in breach of contract under s13 The Relationship of Description to Quality act. Beale v Taylor (1967) Bobby Smith's situation is greatly reflected in the case of Beale v Taylor (1967). Where by a car was described in good faith by the seller as a 1961 Triumph Herald convertible, but turned out later to be two halves of two different cars welded together. This is similar to Bobby's situation as at the time of purchase the sample (whether it was a sample tree or in the case of Beale v Taylor most likely a test drive) ...read more.


which it is also not. Consumer Protection Act, 1987 The Consumer Protection Act is the most important line of defence for Bill Weeks when building his claim as it covers injuries caused to consumers through defective goods. The Consumer Protection act is used when businesses can not be relied upon to regulate themselves. This includes the businesses activities when dealing with employees, other firms and in this case Bill Weeks. Even if Eden Nurseries expressly excluded liability for damages howsoever caused Bill weeks could use the Consumer Protection Act to remove their clause. This would be possible as under the act it clearly states that a firm supplying defective goods would be liable for any injuries caused when using the equipment. Heart v Brendling Kitchen-Wares, 1984 A relevant case to back this up would be that of Heart v Brendling Kitchen-Wares, 1984. Within this case the consumer purchased a toaster which was deemed to be of the highest quality by the shop clerk. Subsequently the toaster was found to faulty and resulted in the consumer being electrocuted. The argument was that Brendling Kitchen-Wares had no responsibility over the product as they had clauses in place stating that Brendling Kitchen-Wares where not liable for any damages. However the clause was deleted as Brendling Kitchen-Wares where told they were responsible for all products sold within the shop. It was irrelevant whether they had control over the manufacture or design of their products. In conclusion along with the relevant case law I believe Bill Weeks has relevant grounds to overthrow Eden Nurseries clause as it does not abide by consumer protection legislation. Eden Nurseries are in breach of contract under a number of Consumer Protection Acts by which Bill Weeks could claim compensation. By using the relevant information I have provided above Bill Weeks may be able to build a strong case. However he should consider taking advice from the Office of Fair Trading in order to come to a firm conclusion on whether to seek compensation, ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Case Studies and Analysis section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Case Studies and Analysis essays

  1. PEST is a planning tool which is used by a business to evaluate and ...

    This will affect Ginsters as their sales will decrease, this means they will have less profits in the business. This PEST factors could also be significant to Ginsters as it could directly affect their ability to achieve the aim / objective of maximising profit, this is because the product that

  2. SWOT and Pestel analysis for Carlton Forum leisure centre

    it has so much potential to be one of the best facilitates as the location, size and space are perfect. 2.1 External analysis 2.2 Pestle analysis The impact that the wider environment has on firms and industries can be significant, which is why it is important that we understand And

  1. Fiscal and monetary policies

    on the other hand the consumer may save their money helping prevent inflation increase. The bank uses the interest rate to limit spending my the increase in which they will borrowing to the consumer on a 5% base rate more people will take loans but if it increase to 25%

  2. Unit 4 P1 explain different types of business information, their sources and purposes

    verbally is through face to face communication and pre-recorded information over the phone. Verbal information can be taken place in many different circumstances such as speaking to customers or within the Tesco PLC organisation Updating knowledge: Tesco PLC managers may update the knowledge of their staff if there is going

  1. Assignment 1 - Understand the legal requirements for a valid contract

    The postal rule could have been avoided if the oferor had specified within his initial telegram that he will accept the answer for the offer only by a telegram and not by post , it would have prevented the current case.

  2. Stakeholders in Sainsburys and the National Trust

    Employees want to know that their job is secure, good working conditions, benefits, the rate of pay deserved of the job, a chance of promotion, treated fairly and with respect and a safe and healthy working environment.

  1. Unit 32 M1 Explain how health, safety and hygiene legislation has impacted on food ...

    EU which means that every business in the UK whether they are big or small will also have to abide by the European law on food retailing. Tesco are influenced as they have to guarantee that the workplace is a safer, healthier and more productive place to work as the European Agency are also committed into achieving this.

  2. I will be identifying the legal criteria for offer and acceptance in a valid ...

    Executory Consideration: An executory consideration is when parties exchange promises to perform acts in the near future. Most of the contracts usually begin that way, a good example is this is when a seller promises to deliver the goods to a buyer due to the buyer?s promise to buy the goods at the price agreed.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work