• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Should auditors be the only ones liable for business collapses?

Extracts from this document...


Should auditors be the only ones liable for business collapses? Introduction In most simplistic terms, an audit is the means by which one person is assured by another of the quality, condition or status of a subject matte, which the auditor has examined, which has to be genuinely fair of a and true view. The profession of the audit world is constantly changing, but the main purpose always remains the same - an audit which reports on a company's accounts in accordance with the Company's Act 1985. In the UK economy and indeed the global economy, shareholders confidence in financial information can impact heavily across all areas of the market with an immediate force which can as seen in the Enron and Barings case, wipe off billions off the stock market or increase the value of the company and this is felt throughout the whole global economy. The Problem For an audit to be effective it must be perceived to be credible. A loss in confidence, reputation, or trust can have serious implications. Ultimately for an auditor to provide audit reports that are of a quality service to shareholders, "the reports have to be independent, reliable and supported by adequate evidence" (ICAEW, 2003). ...read more.


In the case of the auditing firm Pricewaterhousecoopers, who were the auditors for Barings Bank - whereby they falsified the banks account from 1993 to 1994, the auditors were held liable but to what extent, solely or jointly liable for the bank collapse. At the time of the collapse of the bank auditors had signed off four separate sets of accounts each ones as being certified as being "genuinely true and fair". The accounts showed the bank had made a profit of over �78m at December 1994, when infact it had made a huge loss of �174m. When this case was being investigated by the KPMG, the blame initially went solely to the auditors, but further evidence showed that a director and a rogue trader Nick Leeson had been liable for the business collapse hence liability being shared equally. The Barings case study shows of the agency theory - whereby the audit sees the rules to gain the desired result. One piece of evidence will always remain; Enron had overstated its income for more than four years before its collapse. The question is whether this was of negligence or intent to defraud. The agency theory can once again be applied to the audit in this case. ...read more.


Certainly, from the above evidence auditors can be perceived to be liable but their independence can be compromised based upon management, director's trust and ill judgement hence being auditors being declared non responsible if a business collapse was to occur. A Detailed Look - Andersen V's Enron As touched upon earlier in this report, the collapse of Enron was the biggest bankruptcy in U.S history. The company had dramatically re-stated its value, and the after effect was the loss of 4000 jobs of its employees. $70 billion of shareholders investments and employees pension funds were wiped away in an instance, but surprisingly Andersen the auditor of 16 years was not liable for the collapse (with an ongoing investigation) but the Enron demise was blamed on the top executives who gained themselves by securing their "long term financial status" (BBC UK Enron Auditors quizzed, 2002) The main argument that arised in this case was "Anderson also responsible?" Evidence suggests that he may have been perceived to be more at risk and therefore would benefit most from a rigorous audit are simply being refused by audit firms. The danger is that, ultimately the objective of an audit - that of serving the public interest and supporting the running of the economy will no longer be achieved. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level ICT in Business section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level ICT in Business essays

  1. For my business report I am investigating the Co-op erative society supermarket.

    The aim of the production process is to 'add value' to the goods being supplied to customers so that they can be sold at a reasonable price in order to gain returns (revenue). One of the prime concerns of Co-op s production functions aim is to convert inputs into outputs to satisfy the needs of consumers.

  2. E-commerce in Business Companies of Bangladesh.

    The marketing system draws power from the Web site. The Web site draws credibility and traffic from the brands. Fulfillment Is the Acid Test Fulfillment, the nuts and bolts of getting the right order to the right customer on time, is the acid test of e-commerce.

  1. In this coursework I need to produce a detailed business report on one medium-sized ...

    of formality * convenience * the complexity and amount of detail to be conveyed * the type of information to be communicated * the need to keep a record of the communication.

  2. Tele-working case study

    This is much in smaller size compare to the olden days because of the microchips or integrated circuits (ICs). These chips are small as finger nails. These chips contain a sliver of silicon with thousands or millions of transistors attached on its surface.

  1. Apple Incorporation - Case Analysis

    It will do this through it innovative hardware, software, peripherals and Internet offerings, including Mac(tm) and the iTunes(r) Music Store(tm). Apple believes that personal computing has entered a new era. It seeks to provide a pathway for linking digital devices so that the consumer can add value through the interconnectivity.

  2. The history behind the Boots.

    owner would wish to also loose the rest of their life's belongings to cover debts the business cannot cover. The other main benefit it that it raises capital that the business may need in order to greatly expands on its situation so that it can be a lot better and productive.

  1. Stakeholders vs. Shareholders.

    The company is a for-profit; 2. The company is publicly traded via stock markets; and 3. The company's output is supported by various stakeholders, such as employees, suppliers, customers, investors, communities, labor unions, complementors, competitors,etc. Business and Values Chart Share holders View * If companies exist to maximize shareholder value, then all stakeholders will focus on maximizing shareholder value.

  2. International Auditing.

    These will need to be fully resolved before organizations have the confidence to shift to electronic trading on the net. It is because Internet originally developed as an opening system sharing information all over the world. However, company and organization carry trading through Internet face potential exposure in a number of areas.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work