• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare and Contrast the Characters of Agamemnon and Jason. Which Do You Think is More Deserving of Their Fate?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Compare and Contrast the Characters of Agamemnon and Jason. Which Do You Think is More Deserving of Their Fate? Both Agamemnon and Jason share intrinsic similarities in that they are both the tragic heroes of their plays: Aeschylus' 'Agamemnon' and Euripides' 'Medea' respectively. However, they do not share the same fate. Agamemnon is killed for what he has done, whereas those close to Jason emotionally and politically are killed to spite Jason. Both characters are detested by their wives, but for different reasons. Agamemnon has sacrificed his daughter and Jason has left his wife to marry entirely for personal gain. Agamemnon's motives were that he had to fulfil his oath to help the husband of Helen should she ever leave/be taken. His motives were better than Jason's, who left his wife for his own gain. Medea had two sons so he could not justify leaving her because of childlessness. However, Jason has not killed anyone, which Agamemnon has. Also, leaving a wife would not have been uncommon, and so it is not as significant as it would be had the events taken place today. Both characters thank the gods for their successes. When Agamemnon first arrives on stage he thanks the gods for his victory and safe return home. ...read more.

Middle

The sympathies of the chorus change in both plays. In Medea, the chorus of Corinthian women strongly supports Medea at the beginning of the play, sympathising with her. However, they begin to pity Jason and no longer support Medea when Medea says she is going to kill her own children to spite Jason. In Agamemnon, the chorus is made up of old men who are too old to fight in Troy. They, if grudgingly, admire Clytemnestra. They respect her plan with the beacons so she would know when Troy had fallen, saying after she told them it was her that it was "spoken like a man". However, they lose this respect when they find out that Clytemnestra has killed Agamemnon, their king who they admire for destroying Troy. Because of the action of Jason and Agamemnon, many innocent people are killed. In 'Agamemnon', Cassandra is killed by Clytemnestra, despite the fact that Cassandra is a captive and had nothing to do with the death of Iphigenia. In 'Medea', Glauce, Creon and Jason and Medea's sons are killed by Medea. These innocent victims in both plays are certainly not deserving of what happens to them. Because of what Jason and Agamemnon have done to hurt their wives, five people have been needlessly killed. ...read more.

Conclusion

make one of them sacrifice a daughter) and also as leader it may have been his responsibility to ensure the gods were appeased, and so it was no different here. Jason has apparently re-married to provide prosperity for his sons, himself and Medea. According to Medea it is only for personal gain and to maintain an even more famous name. Jason already has sons to pass his name on and also has a famous name for his achievements with the Argonauts. As we remember him for that it is obvious his marriage is more out of greed than for the motives he claims. Overall I believe Jason was more deserving of his fate. Agamemnon had not only sworn the oath but also had the responsibilities of being in charge of the Greek forces attacking Troy. The sacrifice of Iphigenia was practically unavoidable. Jason, however, re-marries for personal gain and greed. Despite his achievements on the Argo, he wants his name to be even more famous and also does not want it tarnished by being married to a foreigner. He already has sons and so his re-marriage can only be motivated by a want to move him into a higher social circle. In the end it turns out that his name was not tarnished by being married to a foreigner, but by what he did to that foreigner. Callum Davis ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Classics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Classics essays

  1. Peer reviewed

    Who was the real tragic hero of the Agamemnon?

    3 star(s)

    To the Greeks, being caught in that kind of trap was something that would happen to an animal, not a human. However, the only reason that he is not a tragic hero is because he has no recognition of what he did or "anagnorisis".

  2. Compare and contrast the portrayal of the Gods in Virgil's Aeneid and Ovid's metamorphoses.

    Aeneas to remind him to leave Carthage and sail for Italy: 'The man should sail: that is the whole point. Let this be what you tell him, as from me.'16 Jupiter has a sense of responsibility to fulfil fate, this is highlighted further, when he intervenes in the battle between

  1. How far does the Agamemnon reflect the Perfect Tragedy?

    He is true to life as a character, he strives to do what he thinks is right, even though he is not always right. He is consistent throughout the play and he does not have an anagnorisis before he is murdered.

  2. In Euripides Play, how important is it that Medea is a foreigner, not a ...

    She is a murderess and she is not deeply regarded for this as Jason thinks of her as a "sick murderess". The Greeks feel that the murder of an innocent is against the will of Zeus. Medea treats the situation not as a woman, but as a man.

  1. Overall how good is the movie troy?

    In the movie adaptation 'Troy', the gods are all but absent. Things happen or don't and are credited to the gods, but they are simply not real characters in that story. (The Iliad of Homer pg.184) Without the direct interplay of the gods it's as if half of the plot

  2. Was Julius Caesar an effective leader?

    So it is more important to take into account his military service over his political career. It is important to compare Caesar's achievements to that of Pompey Magnus. Tom Holland cites Caesar as the first man in Rome, but Pompey, Caesar's senior by six years had equalled if not surpassed Caesar's accomplishments.

  1. Medea betrayed her father to help Jason capture the Golden Fleece. Doing so was ...

    Medea: I agree, of course, that a foreigner should conform, adapt to his society (31) Medea recognizes her status as an outsider and concedes that she ought to act more Greek. Of course, her extreme grief and need for revenge doesn't seem particularly un-Greek to us.

  2. Odysseus has no real feelings for the female characters he encounters on his travels. ...

    showing how he does indeed respect what she has done for him, and is grateful towards her. After Odysseus leaves Nausicaa in the town, Homer does not mention her anymore but for their goodbyes, despite the fact they are staying under the same roof.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work