• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Comparing Herodotus and Thucydides

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Greek Historians essay In this essay I will be looking at the key contrasts and comparatives of Thucydides and Herodotus and how they are trying to present their material. Firstly, Thucydides has written his work on the Peloponnesian war and also the build up and aftermath; on the other hand Herodotus has written his work on several things, but in particular the Persian invasions. Because they both have written about different things we can guess that the way they are trying to present their material differently. Firstly, the main comparative between both Herodotus and Thucydides is the amount of detail they include within the text to show the information which they want to tell you. For example in Herodotus the level of detail he goes into about Xerxes troops is very substantial, he may have done this so that we get a very clear picture and that we understand of what is going on. This is the same in Thucydides as he goes into a lot of detail about the Athenian naval fleet; this again is used so that we get a clearer view of what is going on. ...read more.

Middle

Although this is important in the context of the part of his book, it offers very little relevance and information for us. This could show that Thucydides likes expressing people's opinions, although he doesn't have to agree with them. This brings me on to my next point; it is clear in both pieces of writing that Herodotus and Thucydides don't usually include rumours in their writing although they have different approaches. Thucydides includes other peoples opinions about the subject but doesn't usually doesn't agree with them and usually just stick with the absolute facts. Such as the dispute of Epidamnus he sticks purely to the facts he has learnt. Herodotus seems to stay away from the rumours and opinions but believes in things such as omens and oracles to help what he is saying. An example of Herodotus using omens is when Xerxes is on his way towards Greece; Herodotus says that a deer giving birth is a bad omen and therefore we could say that Herodotus cares less about the proper facts but reckons the facts lie in oracles advice and also omens. ...read more.

Conclusion

On the other hand, in Herodotus' writing he includes as much detail as he possibly can so he can really show you the point he is trying to make. A good example of this is when he is describing what Xerxes has in his force; he lists loads and loads of different kinds of people. Next, in both bits of writing a usual feature of their writing is how biased or how unbiased they are towards people and events. Thucydides is definitely unbiased in much of his writing, even though he is Athenian. On the other hand there is a few examples when he is biased and is one sided, such as when he is summing up Themistocles character he is very biased saying how he is in awe of his genius. Herodotus on the other hand, seems to be truly unbiased in all of his writing although their a few exceptions such as his view on Xerxes. In conclusion, I think it is clear from the points above how both Herodotus and Thucydides have similar writing styles but also how they differ in several ways. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Classics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Classics essays

  1. In what way if at all does Herodotus overemphasize the role of individuals in ...

    Herodotus presents Xerxes as being easily influenced to undertake an invasion against the Greek states, pressured by the Pisistratids and the Aleuadae and persuaded by Mardonius who saw himself as the future governor of Greece. Herodotus gives the impression that if it was Darius instead of him that led the

  2. Discuss the causes and origins of the Peloponnesian War.

    Athens also wanted possession of the ships of the Corcyrian navy, which was the third largest in Greece. Athens and Corinth clashed again over the Corinthian colony of Potidaea in 432BC. Potidaea had ties with Corinth but it had been an ally of Athens.

  1. Arden vs. Freddy - Creative writing.

    Lebron hasn't been denied all game and he wasn't going to let down just yet. Arden tried again, nothing, infuriated by Freddy's defense Arden called a time out. As the Lebron like Arden, came to the bench, his genius coach descendent of Einstein Bill Nye had a plan to score on Freddy and the Giants.

  2. Cinderella - play script

    Yes, Your Majesty. King: Clearly he's smitten with you. I must say, it is though you've appeared here by magic. Prince: What's he saying to her? Queen: What difference does it make? You said you weren't going to find the girl of your dreams tonight. (Privately to Cinderella) Do we know your mother and father, dear?

  1. 'The Genius' by Frank O'Connor

    In fact, the writer gently mocks the boy's very elevated opinion of himself by repeatedly referring to him as a 'genius'. Thus, if the story is autobiographical, he is laughing at the serious and pretentious child he used to be.

  2. In what ways and to what extent Does Herodotus overemphasize individuals in the conflict ...

    mention? as relatively unreliable Diodorus Siculus tells us and furthermore to avenge the Burning of Sardis something that influenced his motives greatly and even to an extent he prayed ?Grant O God,that I may punish the Athenians? and commanded one of his servants to repeat him the words ?Master remember the Athenians? whenever he sat down for dinner.

  1. To what extent was the battle of Salamis a turning point in Xerxes' campaign ...

    In the end, the Battle's value as a turning point in Xerxes? invasion lay not in land gained or lost or in men killed or captured, but in inspiration. The Spartans and Thespians had taught Greece and the world an enduring lesson about courage in the face of impossible odds.

  2. Is Herodotus the father of History or the father of lies?

    subject to neighborhood gossip, whatever source had told him the story must have been extremely well informed to know the specific details on what happened in exclusive parts of society. Thucydides who relied mainly only factual evidence and criticized Herodotus for just this greatly and for his aimless storytelling and insertion of fables in his narratives.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work