• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

"If human nature does alter, it will be because we begin to look at ourselves in a new way." In what ways, and by what means, do the works of writers you have studied make us "look at ourselves in a new way"?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

"If human nature does alter, it will be because we begin to look at ourselves in a new way." In what ways, and by what means, do the works of writers you have studied make us "look at ourselves in a new way"? What is human nature? According to an interesting article I have read, humanity can be interpreted in three ways: mechanistic, mysterian and materialist views of humanity. A mechanistic view sees human beings largely as objects through which nature acts. A mysterian view suggests that there are aspects of human existence not knowable to mere mortals. A materialist view sees humans as exceptional because humans, unlike any other beings, possess consciousness and agency. In Judaism, human nature is the ability to make our own choice and we will all be held responsible for our actions. From a scientific perspective, human nature is the behavior of human being physically, socially and mentally. There are many different interpretations of human nature and it will never have a specific definition. From my point of view, human nature is how human beings interpret themselves as. Therefore, human nature does alter when we begin to look at ourselves in a new way. In this essay, I have chosen one play from "The Three Theban Plays" by Sophocles; "Oedipus the King" and "Death and the Maiden" by Ariel Dorfman. Looking at the two tragedies, I am going to illustrate how the writers make us "look at ourselves in a new way". ...read more.

Middle

This emphasizes the idea of humans are often blind to themselves, the others and also the truth behind things. When they seek to search for the truth, the outcome can be catastrophic: "Messenger: He rips off her brooches, the long gold pins holding her robes - ......he digs them down the sockets of his eyes," (Pg.237 L1402-1405) "Messenger: And there we saw the woman hanging by the neck, ......spinning, swinging back and forth." (Pg. 237 L1395-1397) In the exodus of the play, the ending is a disaster, Jocasta hanged herself and Oedipus blinded himself. Truth can be harmful sometimes, therefore it is better to stay the same and be ignorant. At least we could be better off and happier because truth sometimes doesn't give us any satisfaction at all. This made us to have a whole new perception about the exploration of truth. After studying the play, I would be more objective about my actions and be humble to the others' advice, to prevent anything destructive happening. But on the other hand, Oedipus is a man of great quality, he had the courage to seek for the truth even though people persuaded him not to because the truth was dangerous. If we are satisfy about the current state and choose to be "blind" to many truths on the world, there would be no improvement and development at all. There is certainly no an ultimate answer to the question whether or not we should seek for the truth. ...read more.

Conclusion

Perhaps Miranda is guilty, the truth is so thrilling that even me as an audience wanted to know it so badly. In the end, nobody knows if justice has been achieved by Paulina's outrageous actions. The play also exemplify the idea of too much truth may be dangerous. On the way of searching the truth, Paulina didn't realize that she is destroying many things, their relationships, and Gerardo's trust to her etc. Gerardo had already warned her not to continue her pursuit of truth: "Gerardo: People can die from an excessive dose of the truth, you know." (Pg. 36) Gerardo could foresee the disastrous outcome of the whole event and tried to stop Paulina continue to look for the truth. It is because Gerardo sensed that too much truth won't do good to all of them. The idea of too much truth is dangerous in "Death and the Maiden" links back to the idea of the catastrophic consequences of obtaining the truth from "Oedipus the King". Paulina and Oedipus are very similar, they strife for the truth which they don't know is destructive. Paulina destroyed the relationship between Gerardo and herself; whereas Oedipus devastated his kingdom, his family and most significantly, he blinded himself. Both tragedies raised our caution to the pursuit of truth, acknowledge us that truth is double-edged, it can favour but also destroy someone. Human can't be too ignorant and also can't know too much truth. "It is better to settle for half." as Alfieri puts it in the play "A View from the Bridge". ?? ?? ?? ?? ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Classics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Classics essays

  1. In what ways does The Simpsons portray American family and social values?

    Also, at some point in the show, Bart and Milhouse will go out on an adventure together. Their experience of getting high on syrup was especially funny, as was their rivalry when Milhouse got his first girlfriend. Homer's day often involves him being called up by Mr.

  2. "Virgil invites us to see in Aeneas a new Odysseus often in similar situations ...

    The third reason was that Juno's husband, Jupiter, favoured Ganymede, a Trojan boy, and this made her jealous. Juno's only reason for disliking Aeneas is because he is a Trojan, and he is destined to be successful and therefore her dislike totally unjustified.

  1. Jason behaves so badly that it is impossible for us to sympathise with his ...

    being lied to and that Medea knows 'What pain the future hides' for them whereas Jason is entirely clueless. On the other hand, in some aspects his gullibility could reduce the sympathy for him seeing as he should have been at least the slightest bit suspicious of Medea's behaviour, especially

  2. How far was Plato's perception of rhetoric a consistent one?

    fiction portraying terrible things such as the 'sufferings of Niobe, or the house of Pelops, or the Trojan War, or any similar topic'15. He would also forbid the gods to be portrayed as behaving badly, as this will plant the wrong ideas in the young, as the gods should be a perfect moral example.

  1. Cinderella - play script

    Now I should go through the menus with you... where's he going? King: Could it have been something we said? Queen: Lionel? Lionel! (enters) Lionel: Yes your majesty. Queen: "Proclamation from the prince...." Lionel: Excuse me, your majesty, I couldn't help over hearing and I don't think the prince sounded too...

  2. Abandoned and Redeemed: Comparing the works of Ibsen and Sophocles

    Oedipus had unknowingly and inadvertently killed his father Laius in self-defense, and eventually married his mother, whom he did not know he had any kind of relation to. He had fulfilled the prophecy, even after being abandoned and forgotten. This illustrates the inevitable aspect of fate and destiny, which all ties into the idea of abandonment and redemption.

  1. Oedipus the King VS. "An Occurrence at Owl Creek Bridge" "An Occurrence at Owl ...

    Despite the vivid nature of the fantasy, as real as the escape seems, Farquhar's death inevitably must occur. The strong blends of reality and fiction create a grand story. In Part Three, the narrative takes over from the end of Part One.

  2. Examine the use made by writers of innocence and/or ignorance, comparing the presentation of ...

    Ignorance has been presented to readers at the exposition of the Greek tragedy 'Oedipus Rex.' It has also provided the play with the central conflict. Oedipus murdered Lias at the intersection where 'three roads meet.' The setting is highly symbolic as the father and son may have taken an alternative path.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work