• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Is artificial intelligence possible?

Extracts from this document...


IS A.I. POSSIBLE? In the science fiction film, The Terminator directed by James Cameron, the computers in the movie "get smart" and rise up against their human masters. In other words, the computers in the movie were able to become independent of their programmers and developed a kind of artificial intelligence (A.I.). This essay will prove that in real life, computers will never realize artificial intelligence, and also even though functionalism is based on an analogy between humans and computers, it is an effective way to describe the interaction between the mind and body. Two essays will be evaluated in this essay. The first essay was called; "Can Computers Think?" by John Searle which rejects the theory of A.I. The second essay was called; "Escaping from the Chinese Room" by Margret Boden, which supports A.I. A functionalist view of the mind is one that draws an analogy between the functioning of the human brain and the functioning of the digital computer. The strongest view says that the mind and the brain are just digital computers. This is called strong A.I., which is a term coined by John Searle. American Hilary Putnam was one of the first to make the analogy between the brain and the computer Putnam said it made no more sense to compare the mind and the brain then to compare the software with the hardware of a computer. He also made the point that psychologists were like programmers and electrical engineers were like physicians. ...read more.


Searle has a list of instructions which say, if this squiggle1 comes in, then push squiggle2 out under the door. Searle has no understanding of the squiggle and ad he is just following the instructions. By, analogy, the computer, which uses a similar type of logic also, has no understanding of what the meanings of the inputs are. Therefore, the computer is not thinking. Computers simulate mental ability; the computer is not intelligent, even though it may appear to be doing intelligent things. One example of this was the defeat of the chess grand master Gary Kasparov by the computer, Deep Blue. For human beings, chess requires a high level of thought. The person has to visualize and remember patterns that are occurring through conscious thought and even use psychology to try and figure out their opponent's strategy. The computer plays chess in a totally different way. The computer computes a board position "tree" for the white and black pieces about 20 moves into the future, this means the computer's tree holds about 3 million possible moves. Then the computer uses an algorithm based on simple logic to compare the "goodness" of each move. The computer then makes its moves base on this algorithm. Therefore, just like in the Chinese room, the computer is comparing specific inputs (moves) with logical conditions. The second argument Searle makes in his essay is that only biological entities can produce mental states capable of understanding or intentionality. ...read more.


Boden's point is that the brain of the robot (Searle) cannot be credited with the understanding of the robot; "computationalists do not ascribe intentionality to the brain." Boden tries to show that these intentional states are the product of the robot as a whole, including all its solenoids, photo diodes etc. This is shown when Boden writes "...intentional states such as these are products of people not brains." She tries to demonstrate that the robot and the human brain are the same, in that they are both made up of small very stupid parts which build into a collective brain that is capable of understanding; "The fact that a certain light sensitive cell can respond to intensity gradients and that one neuron can inhibit the firing of another" Problem with this explanation is that now instead of input from a keyboard, the robot now receives its information from its sensors. The input will still be processed programming in the CPU of the robot. Boden did not disprove Searle's point that the syntax of a program is not sufficient for understanding of a digital computer system. Boden could not show that non-biological entity did have understanding, but she did show that Searle's argument on this point was a little weak because it relied on in tuition. The functionalism theory was shown to be an attractive theory a long as it was not taken too literally. Consequently it was shown in this essay that due to syntactical nature of computer programs and the computers lack of causal powers needed for a machine to have mental states. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Computer Science section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Computer Science essays

  1. Control Unit, Memory Unit, and Arithmetic Logic Unit. The CPU or Central Processing ...

    Because of this it can be used for storing confidential files. Add to this the fact that all computers can be relied on to have a floppy disk drive and it becomes a sensible way of transferring information from one machine to another.

  2. Signal Theory

    basically runs at the physical layer of an OSI model, so it is not aware of the frame formats and upper layer protocols. Repeater basically is used to expand a LAN network over large distance regenerating a signal. When using a repeater remember the 5-4-3 rule which means that a

  1. Smart Card System

    Information is giving back to the server's application Relation Description Form Name: Request of Information Description: This data flow carries the latest information request from server application Source: Lab assistance entity Destination: Lab user master record Type of Data Flow: [ ] File [ ] Screen [ ] Report [

  2. With diagrams compare and contrast the relative advantages and disadvantages of digital transmission over ...

    Transmission Media Transmission media refers to the type of cable or wireless system that is used to connect network devices. Media options should be carefully considered when implementing a new LAN this is because it can make a significant impact on the cost, speed, and connectivity of the network.

  1. Signalling Theory

    The benefits of digital signals can be quite extensive so it's interesting to look at a couple. Digital is the new up and coming form of communications, especially when it comes to television. It appears to be the new thing and whilst analogue appears to take a back seat the digital era continues to grow.

  2. Artificial Intelligence

    As I said before these machines don't have brains of their own, there has to be someone controlling these machines. MIS & DSS System 4) MIS - Management Information System are information that is computer based, which is used within the organization.

  1. CP3 - Proposed Solution to a Realistic Problem - Apartment Administration software

    The customers contact details will be recorded consisting of name, address, telephone number and preferred invoice method, either email or letter. These details will then be recorded on to paper and stored in a file. 4. A deposit will be requested from the customer using their preferred invoice method. 5.

  2. Introduction to Robotic Algorithms Final Project: Interaction with the MagellanPro Robot

    Run 'makeimg' using the data generated by 'getdata' as input 5. Convert the output of 'makeimg' to a 2^n x 2^n, 24/32-bit uncompressed TGA (see README.ERRATA) 6. Run 'map_edit' using the TGA output of 'makeimg' as input, and create a polygonal map (save this to a file)

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work