• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

A Comparison between the Trevor Nunn and Roman Polanski Macbeth films.

Extracts from this document...


A Comparison between the Trevor Nunn and Roman Polanski Macbeth films Trevor Nunn and Roman Polanski are two famous directors with very different styles and influences. Both have produced versions of Macbeth, one for television and one cinema. In this assignment, I will analyse the key dramatic techniques and effects they use, which differentiates them from each other. Polanski's version of Macbeth starts right off, before the credits roll. The whole scene is in silence, giving the audience no indication or warning that the film is starting, making the unfolding scenes all the more shocking. Like the play, the film begins with the witches. However, Polanski sets the scene on a beach rather than the "blasted heath" it is set on in the play. We see, instead, the beach at sunrise, with the wet sand glowing a strange pink. This was done intentionally to weaken the atmosphere and make the shot more calming. However, set to counteract this pleasant background are the witches burying a very realistic severed arm in the sand. This would be even more shocking for the audience, as half of them would not even have sat down, and the credits had not rolled. ...read more.


Her costume is figure hugging black, and it also blends with the backdrops, removing all the femininity from her figure, and her hair is swept back with a black head piece so she is nearly all black making her an incredibly effective Lady Macbeth. Polanski forfeits some of the eerie atmosphere by using very rich, colourful scenery throughout his film, but despite the loss of atmosphere, the film becomes far more cinematically interesting to watch. Polanski uses a lot of panoramic, long view shots, and shoots many scenes outdoors. There are very few scenes in darkness, bar the killing of Duncan, and even the opening scenes, which are perhaps the most shocking, are shot in daylight. A lot of the landscape is shot to show off the rugged, untouched beauty that the Scottish countryside has to offer. Colour filters are used to enhance the colour in some scenes. The green of the trees and the blue of the sky and most of the richest colours in the film are all enhanced. With the idyllic settings, this makes it very pleasing and easy to watch. ...read more.


He saved up his profits from the numerous "adult" movies he had produced and put them all into one project that he hoped would bring him commercial success. To ensure this, he chose how to spend his money very carefully. He chose less experienced actors, but many more visual effects and tricks that make the play a lot easier and exciting for the general public watch. He did not have enough money left over for advertising, and instead submitted it to the BBFC knowing it would cause uproar, and that he would score free publicity. He also "leaked" a few explicit stills to the press, who happily published them in the knowledge it would boost their sales, and at the same time give Polanski the coverage he needed. As a result of all his careful manipulation of the press, the film became a huge success, and Polanski gained critical acclaim and also made back the money he put in. Though Polanski used a lot of quite needless, titillating scenes to distract the audience from the fact it didn't really have very high production values, it is a much more enjoyable piece of cinema to watch then Nunn's version, and I feel that although both have their merits, it is Polanski's version that tops Nunn's for sheer entertainment and fun. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Plays section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Plays essays

  1. A Comparison between 'The Godmother' and My Self-devised Performance

    The time difference in which these performances are set creates a large difference between the plays as the style and contexts of the play are affected by the era. The main similarity between the two performances is that both our performance and The Godmother have direct address to the audience

  2. Examine the Techniques, Which the Directors of the Public Information Films Use To Convey ...

    Glenda Jackson plays the role of an everyday person who is reluctant to give blood. She represents the audience's attitude that this PIF is aimed at. This is a good technique because the audience can relate to her. Glenda at first is reluctant to give blood and is terrified and anxious.

  1. How does the inclusion of witches in Macbeth heighten the dramatic impact of the ...

    The witches are also very ugly in the play, they are old and have grey hair. They also wear dark clothes. All this is to show that they aren't good characters. You can also tell they aren't good when hearing what others say to them.

  2. Musical films, Bride and Predjudice and Grease

    The target audience are able to relate, as the dark colour and the leather material symbolise college students who are hip, trendy and enjoying the moment. Black also symbolises sexual passion between Danny and Sandy and shows both characters state of mind, where they are wearing similar fitted outfits.

  1. Log of Film production.

    The voice used in the narration of this warning connotated danger, by the steady but serious delivery of the voice, that furthermore directed the audience into a state of discomfort. Yet it was also conventional, even a parody and this double ness of seriousness and comedy adds to the edgy quality we were after .


    Some members of my group wore a red top and others wore a red belt or scurf around their waist. The red symbolized violence, passion, love, blood and death. The red symbolized every emotional or physical feeling that is within the play.

  1. With close examination of one of the ending of the films, analyse the way ...

    food, while her sister is having fun like the rest of her family. The camera too is also on Jules (her friend at the football club) and Jo at the football match. From their faces you can see that they are frustrated because Jess is not there and because they

  2. How are Bollywood films similar to high concept American films?

    Hindi films have so far failed to appeal to mainstream white British audiences. This is partly due to the nature of the films' conventions: their length, high melodrama, the frequent use of song sequences and meaningless narratives which don't interest white audiences.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work