• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Peut etre sur scene ce theatre est-il aux trois quartsmort Barthes. Is this fair to Racine? Refer to any three plays indetail.

Extracts from this document...


Daniel Nivern Dr.Hawcroft " Peut etre sur scene ce theatre est-il aux trois quarts mort " Barthes. Is this fair to Racine? Refer to any three plays in detail. An initial reaction towards this quote by Barthes, would lead the reader to consider the importance of death in Racine's tragedies, and its impact upon the audience. However, this quote must be considered in context, and therefore it is essential to recognize that Barthes is writing critically in response to a play that he saw in the 1980's, which he disliked and found theatrically unacceptable. According to Barthes, it is difficult, perhaps even impossible to stage a modern production of Racine without boring the audience, influencing them in a way that would not be representative of Racine, or unjustly changing the stage setting. This implies that it would simply be pointless or at least dramatically displeasing to see a modern performance of a Racine play, and that a reading of the play would be a more rewarding literary experience. Other critics, however, dispute this standpoint, believing that there is enough evidence, both contemporary second-hand as well as textual, for a modern director to successfully stage a Racine play, according to the playwright's desires. This essay will seek to examine, by analysing three separate plays, whether or not this evidence is sufficient for a play to be put on stage in a way that would correspond, to some extent, to the dramatic intentions of the playwright, and whether a visual theatrical experience of Racine is preferable to reading Racine from a book. ...read more.


She also demonstrates her shameful passion by her uncontrollable blushing, which she explains to Oenone is a way of hiding her face, "Oenone, la rougeur me couvre le visage." When she thinks about her passion for Hipployte, she also has a physical reaction, "Je le vis, je rougis, je p�lis � sa vue," These examples of blushing, as a visual way of representing emotions of passion and shame, contrast with a presumable example of Ph�dre going pale when she actually sees Hippolyte, "Le voici. Vers mon Coeur tout mon sang se retire." Perhaps the most dramatic of these physical actions, which one can interpret from the text, is the way in which Ph�dre points her chest as she powerfully demands that Hippolyte stab her. "Voil� mon coeur: c'est l� que ta main doit frapper," Upon the word "l�" one can envisage a visually dramatic moment, as Ph�dre angrily and desperately points to her heart, begging the man she loves to end her torment. A significant feature in modern theatre productions is the use of lighting, which can be symbolic of the action on the stage. The visual aspect of lighting could also heavily influence 17th Century French productions, with the use of candles to add extra or less light to the stage. As was touched upon earlier with Ph�dre's line "Mes yeux sont �blouis du jour que je revoi," the notions of light and darkness in Ph�dre are extremely important. Ph�dre is suffering from melancholy, coming from the Greek melankholia, and which is a disease, in which a character becomes gloomy and depressed as a result of too much black bile. ...read more.


This ensures richness of dramatic action, including suspense and a potential for both pity and fear. Will Junie be caught making secret signs to Britannicus? If so, will he understand such signals and how will he react? What would therefore be the consequences? Only the spectator can see whether or not she makes these expressions and indeed if she is trying to deliberately not make such expressions, and this adds extra suspense to Racine on stage, contrasting sharply with Barthes negative view of modern Racinian productions. There is a strong emphasis on a visual reading of the play and the word "yeux" is repeated as evidence. Junie, referring to the hidden presence of N�ro, explains to Britannicus that "Vous �tes en des lieux tout pleins de sa puissance. Ces murs m�mes, Seigneur, peuvent avoir des yeux, Et jamais l'empereur n'est absent de ces lieux." In response to this, a few lines later, Britannicus replies that Junie has now learnt to control her facial expressions, which is possibly a subtle Racinian allusion to the ability of the actor to change his facial expressions to convey different a change of emotion. He states, "Quoi! M�me vos regards ont appris � se taire? Que vois-je? Vous craignez de rencontrer mes yeux? demonstrating the ruthless, expressionless way in which she is responding to his conversation. This would be tense and emotional when seen on stage. In the play Iphig�nie, Racine and Michel Laurent specify the setting of the stage and the scenery, thus allowing a modern director to have a strong idea of how it should be presented. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Plays section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Plays essays

  1. Analysis of a physical theatre performance - Under the Influence

    The themes of the play were very subtly introduced. They were about, love, life, sex and relationships. There was also an element of peer pressure and also a stereotype reversal and promiscuity. The stereotype reversal came in when a woman was very pushy and forced a man to have sex

  2. What kinds of humour does Aristophanes use in his plays? To what extent would ...

    Take this, and go". In addition, Aristophanes includes what is regarded as a comic catalogue for comic effect. The ability to put together related words makes him a commendable playwright because this is feature is known to very respectable playwrights in Nigeria.

  1. How Successful is Brecht's 'The Good Person of Szechwan' as an example of Epic ...

    This was a custom that was widely used in Chinese theatre. The character of Shen Teh is made to use a mask to take on the persona of her 'Ruthless' cousin Shui Ta. "In terms of Brechtian 'alienation', the mask device in Boesing's play functions much as it does in The Good Person of Szechwan.

  2. The stimulus we were given to look at was the play 'Too Much Punch ...

    Judy are in the bar being chatted up by Bob and Nob. This showed the contrast from that scene to the crash scene - how a good night out can lead to disaster. Another convention we used was symbolism. To represent something symbolically is to show it non-naturalistically.

  1. An analysis of the significance and the dramatic impact of the "restaurant scene" (P79-87) ...

    constantly haunted by the hollowness of everything he put his faith in..." And so if Biff had not confirmed what Willy had always known all along then maybe Willy might either still be alive or dies happily. However this point is very controversial.

  2. How would you direct the exchanges between Phedre and Oenone in two sequences from ...

    She can also hyperventilate and shake. Phedre at this point is starting to get paranoid, accusing Oenone of knowing of Hippolytus' forbidden love for Aricia. She is very angry at Oenone and shows this by getting very close and delivering her lines directly into her face while at the same time waving her hands at Oenone.

  1. “All My Sons”: Examine the Dramatic Power of Act 3.

    Kate is similar to Joe in that neither of them are prepared to face up to reality, they would rather keep the truth hidden and pretend to be the typical, happy American Dream family. The mystery of Larry is another point up for debate at the end of Act 2,

  2. Six Characters in Search of an Author by Luigi Pirandello, Act One, Scene One, ...

    Julie spends hers making demands ? such as ? Jean ?drink my health now? and ?kiss my shoe.? When he hesitates she teases him with the rhetoric question ?are you shy?? She knows full well why he hesitated, as fraternising with his better is dangerous, but she wishes for him to feel uncomfortable.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work