Peut etre sur scene ce theatre est-il aux trois quartsmort Barthes. Is this fair to Racine? Refer to any three plays indetail.

Authors Avatar

Daniel Nivern                                                                Dr.Hawcroft

« Peut etre sur scene ce theatre est-il aux trois quarts mort » Barthes. Is this fair to Racine? Refer to any three plays in detail.

An initial reaction towards this quote by Barthes, would lead the reader to consider the importance of death in Racine’s tragedies, and its impact upon the audience. However, this quote must be considered in context, and therefore it is essential to recognize that Barthes is writing critically in response to a play that he saw in the 1980’s, which he disliked and found theatrically unacceptable. According to Barthes, it is difficult, perhaps even impossible to stage a modern production of Racine without boring the audience, influencing them in a way that would not be representative of Racine, or unjustly changing the stage setting. This implies that it would simply be pointless or at least dramatically displeasing to see a modern performance of a Racine play, and that a reading of the play would be a more rewarding literary experience. Other critics, however, dispute this standpoint, believing that there is enough evidence, both contemporary second-hand as well as textual, for a modern director to successfully stage a Racine play, according to the playwright’s desires. This essay will seek to examine, by analysing three separate plays, whether or not this evidence is sufficient for a play to be put on stage in a way that would correspond, to some extent, to the dramatic intentions of the playwright, and whether a visual theatrical experience of Racine is preferable to reading Racine from a book.

Examining three Racine plays, Phèdre, Britannicus and Iphigénie, certain aspects of the production have to be addressed, including the stage settings, physical actions, costumes and props, and lighting and sound effects, in order to clarify the effectiveness of a modern Racinian performance. Phèdre is potentially a very good starting point, as there is a richness of physical action and facial expressions, which are alluded to in the text. Phèdre’s dramatic entrance onto the stage is the first example of this, and her physical description is described immediately,

« Je ne me soutiens plus; ma force m’abandonne./Mes yeux sont éblouis du jour que je revoi/Et mes genoux tremblants se dérobent sous moi./Helas ! »  

Join now!

I believe it likely that a visual demonstration of Phèdre’s weakened physical state would be more emphatic than reading it on the written page. This scene, in which most play directors would probably add dramatic theatricality by showing Oenone physically supporting her mistress, would also add a visual support to Oenone’s verbal explanation in the previous scene regarding her mistress,

        “Elle meurt dans mes bras d’un mal qu’elle me cache.”

as Oenone will no doubt be looking at her arms as she despairingly expresses herself. This idea is repeated when Oenone again refers to her arms in an emotional ...

This is a preview of the whole essay