• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Analyze the opening sequences of David Lean and Alfonso Cuaron's film version of 'Great Expectations' commenting in detail on the similarities and differences in their techniques and impact both have upon the audience.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

In this media assignment I shall be analyzing and comparing the similarities and differences of two famous directors' film versions of 'Great Expectations'. The two directors are David Lean and Alfonso Cuaron. David Lean's version was more popular and well known than Alfonso Cuaron's because Lean was the first director to actually direct 'Great Expectations'. This made it more difficult for Alfonso Cuaron because he had to bring the film up to date by making the film more modern and there have also been 10 other films based on the novel 'Great Expectations'. David Lean had directed his version of 'Great Expectations' in 1946 and Alfonso had directed his version in 1998. Both film versions of 'Great Expectations' begin with the opening credits which let the audience know the producers, executive producers etc... the opening credits of both movies have some similarities and differences. In Alfonso Cuaron's version of 'Great Expectations' the credits are shown in a rippled effect, which gives the audience hints that the opening scene might be set in a beach or a place with water surrounding it, such as a port or harbur. In the background of the credits there are sketches of people and fishes, there is also a dark green background, which is symbolic of envy. ...read more.

Middle

This technique in which Lean has used here is effective because it builds up tension as the frames go by which suggests to the audience that there is something bad going to happen to Pip. Both film versions use many different camera shots, which involve the audience emotionally, and also create a visual image in their mind towards the particular scene. Alfonso Cuaron first uses Extreme Long Shot (ELS), which is also known as the establishing shot. This lets the audience know what the scene is bound to contain and also sets the opening frame or scene. There is also one particular frame when there is an Extreme Close Up (ECU) on the boy's face, which signifies to the audience that there is some faithfulness to the text because David Lean also uses this technique and he is faithful to the text. The impact of this is that the audience is involved in the film because the ECU provides a Point Of View (POV) angle expression on the boys face. David Lean also uses similar camera angles but involves the audience in a different way. The main focus point of David Leans POV angle is when Pip is looking up at the creaking tree, which looks like a person or a person, stood behind the tree. ...read more.

Conclusion

But David Lean uses many different sounds such as the hauling, creaking tree, and owl shrieking and whistling. This creates an up-tempo atmosphere, which also builds up tension. The technique of both versions is good because the music of Cuaron's film calms the audience but Lean's film builds up an up-tempo atmosphere and tension. Finally the dislodge in my eyes is different and similar because they have the same effect on both boys in the films but Alfonso Cuaron's is much more aggressive because the modern audience like aggression and violence. There is also a great deal of bad language in his film. Lean's version is also slightly aggressive but nowhere as near as much, and there was no strong language in the dialogue because the audience in them day's were much more civilized and strict. In my opinion I think that I would still prefer to watch Alfonso Cuaron's version because as a modern audience I am used to the aggression and violence of modern films and novels. The language in the original film versions is more true to the novel, but is therefore more difficult to understand, as it is old-fashioned. ?? ?? ?? ?? Mohson Qayyum 10G Page 1 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Plays section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Plays essays

  1. How do Peter Benchley and Steven Spielberg build up tension and suspense in the ...

    The peaceful music stops and starts and the calm sound of rippling waves can be heard in the background. This relieves some of the tension caused by the shark and keeps a little hope alive that Chrissie might still survive.

  2. What expectations do you have of the first scene of a play? In light ...

    "It is fitting for a soldier arise to be a Prince, but not necessary a Prince descend to be a Prince" The characters in the play come from various different social background and for us to fully understand the play, we need to understand these socials backgrounds and how they affect actions of characters.

  1. Comparison of the opening sequences of two different versions of 'Romeo & Juilet' - ...

    This drops a hint to the audience that this is going to be a fast-paced, action packed film - the speed increases adrenaline and can change the audiences' thoughts and feelings on a film. Following that, a man reads the prologue again, except, this time, the camera focuses on different parts of the busy city during him speaking.

  2. Spring and Port Wine.

    He tends to show no emotions. He is a religious man and he tries to get the rest of the family to get into religion. He likes to try and get the family to sing together on a night while he plays the piano. He has a couple of weekly traditions.

  1. Chicken run - During this essay I am going to analyse how the film ...

    seen to be rolling around on the floor because they have ate too much seed. This makes us feel sorry for the chickens and it also makes us understand their plight. Ginger is nervous around Rocky because when she is on the roof with him after escaping from Mrs Tweedy

  2. Evaluation of our play version of Antigone.

    This was effective in a play based on humour as it got the audience thinking about society and from this, they could relate the celebrity relationships to those we were about to show on stage, either the similarities or the differences.

  1. How does the Director encourage the audience to feel sympathy for Derek and his ...

    Appleby who was hung for inciting his accomplice to kill a policeman by shouting "Let him have it, he is all alone". Did the police believe what had hung Appleby would hang Bentley? These statements point out yet more bias acts to swing the trial in favour of the police.

  2. What techniques does Luhrmann use to make the prologue and opening fight scene of ...

    It was so important that Luhrmann was able to show how important religion was and how it fitted into the story so he showed a lot of emphasis on it. The first scene was set in a gas station because it is a meeting place for the boys with there cars.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work