• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Aristotle wrote in Poetics that tragedy should contain incidents arousing pity and fear and thus prove cathartic for an audience. To what extent does the plot of Arthur Millers play, All My Sons

Extracts from this document...


Aristotle wrote in 'Poetics' that tragedy should contain '...incidents arousing pity and fear...' and thus prove cathartic for an audience. To what extent does the plot of Arthur Miller's play, 'All My Sons' allow for this? Arthur Miller (1915-2005) in 'All My Sons' (1947), journeys the key concept of catharsis through the intricate character of Joe Keller; our tragic hero and his hubris flaw, the concept of Hamartia, the generating of pathos through language and most importantly the formula of tragedy, described by Aristotle, bringing about catharsis. 'All My Sons' starts at the end of summer in suburban America, after World War Two. The events of the play, described by Miller, occur on a single set, the backyard of the Keller home, a 'secluded atmosphere', considerably the American Dream. Furthermore there stands the stump of an apple tree, as its 'trunk and branches lie toppled beside it'1. Miller here, emotionally engages us into the play with the use of pathetic fallacy, increasing our emotions by building tension and giving opportunity to the futures of tragedy. The audience no longer feel safe behind the American Dream but instead are presented with a fa�ade of respect, somewhere much sinister , preparing the audience for the upcoming tragedy. Miller uses this same technique again when Joe Keller, our protagonist, notifies: "Gonna rain tonight."2 Miller builds fear in the audience, suggesting something unpleasant about to happen. Nevertheless as the audience learn more about Joe Keller, we see that he is an ego-centric man, whose mental attitude does not go beyond his own sphere. ...read more.


Miller has made this is evident through the stage directions, exemplifying the fear: "(frightened, but angry): Yes, I'm sure."8 The fear left with the audience to experience at the end of Act One becomes pivotal in the role of experiencing catharsis. Miller has instantaneously given us the opportunity to empathise with the characters and in turn fear for them thus we are given a sense of foreboding, vital for ultimately experiencing catharsis in any tragedy. In the opening stage directions of Act Two Miller, again, uses pathetic fallacy to suggest the progression in the plot and perhaps the catastrophe still to come suggested metaphorically by Miller: "...leaving stump standing alone..."9 Though as the play progresses a growing sense of anxiety is created in the audience by Miller. We can see this through Sue Bayliss a character chosen by Miller to represent the wider community. This lets the audience fear even more for Joe Keller as a character because it becomes apparent that not everybody overlooks his guilt: "There's not a person on the block who doesn't know the truth."10 In Act Two Miller finally decides to present a rush of emotions which soon psychologically engage the audience as well as the characters Chris, Ann and George. Miller's use of short, forceful sentences build tension and anxiety in the audience that we soon become eager to reach some sort of resolution, where inner peace can be found. ...read more.


What does the letter enclose and how can this change the lives of all the characters, is what we the audience fear for. After the truth has been exposed we finally feel a sense of relief, but then the plot takes a sudden turn: "A shot is heard in the house. They stand frozen for a brief second."19 In conclusion: having explored the issues within the plot that allow for catharsis, Arthur Miller in 'All My Sons' does not let the audience reach the long awaited cathartic ending. Our hope for resolution and the purging of valuable emotions is waived through the ultimate act of cowardice by Joe Keller: his suicide. The hope we have for Chris, Ann and Kate to live freer lives is now the only hope that exists. Instead of relief, a whole new consortium of anxieties is revealed. We can evaluate upon the fact of whether or not all the characters had a further responsibility. Should have Chris vowed to prove that his fathers alibi was the truth? At the time when Steve Deever called Keller for help and Kate answered, should she have taken responsibility? And finally, should we, as the audience, be so harsh upon Kate Keller, is her only fault to love her family more than ever, thus pitying her state. Miller has indeed purged our emotions till the very end of the play, but whether or not we have reached a cathartic ending can only be identified from one's own experience. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Plays section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Plays essays

  1. The character of Kate Keller, created by Arthur Miller and presented to us in ...

    "What's she going to say? Maybe we ought to tell her before she sees it?" "She saw it" "How could she see it? I was the first one up. She was still in bed." "She was out here when it broke."

  2. "At the conclusion of " 'Tis Pity She's a Whore" do you condemn or ...

    The audience of the time however would see incest in a more economic light, as if you were not marrying outside your family, it would be impossible to gain higher status or a larger state etc. and so disapproval may be a more likely reaction as the family name and estate would suffer as a result.

  1. Westside story, plot and sub plot

    West Side story was designed for the audience to feel sorry for both Tony and Maria, because of the fact that they cannot share their love for each other because of the hatred between both the rival gangs. There are many points throughout this play that keep the audience interested.

  2. Aristotle described the need for the audience to experience pity and fear while watching ...

    By this he has cleverly developed the ideas to exploit Othello to the world in turn increasing the audience's emotions of fear for what will happen to Othello as well as pity for the character who considers Iago a loyal friend.

  1. Bouncers Plot adn Sub Plot

    They then all hop on the bus to meet each other and head down to the pub. * The Lads are now at 'the Taverners'. They are at the bar starting to slip in a few pints before they head down to the club.

  2. Free essay

    To what extent does Lysistrata depend for its success on the activities of a ...

    She talks of the hardship that both men and women have to suffer and how it's hard for both sides to cope during times of war. She mentions how war destroys the male population, while women are left at home, alone to fend for themselves and that when their husbands

  1. The stimulus we were given to look at was the play 'Too Much Punch ...

    I think we could have improved on our ideas by flowing from one flashback to another with ease; there was a sort of stop and start as we ended one flashback and moved onto another. Our group worked very well together on this task, we sat down and discussed our ideas and then got to work developing them straight away.

  2. How does Miller present Joe Keller as a tragic hero in All My Sons?

    Although this shows Keller's irresponsibility towards society it also shows Keller's devotion to his family. Keller obviously believes that family is the most important thing in the world. This little speech of Keller's is also very ironic because at the end of the play Keller does actually put a bullet

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work