• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Is Northumberland as portrayed in Act one scene one, a sympathetic character or not?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Is Northumberland as portrayed in Act one scene one, a sympathetic character or not? Act one, scene one takes place in the Duke of Northumberland's Warkworth castle, and he is the father of Harry Monmouth who, as Rumour informs the audience during the prologue, is dead. As shown in this quotation: "My office is To noise abroad that Harry Monmouth fell Under the wrath of noble Hotspur's sword" Rumours only proof of this death is from hearsay, and the fact that this allegorical figure is the embodiment of (as his name gives connotations of) all the rumours that the people of England have heard and spread during the battle between anarchists and royalty, shows that he may in fact be a very unreliable source. During Act one scene one the rumour of Harry Monmouth's death is confirmed after quite a lot of banter between Lord Bardolph, Northumberland and Travers. During their discussion it becomes uncertain of whether Harry has actually fallen during the Battle of Shrewsbury because Lord Bardolph tells the rebel Northumberland that his son is alive and has fought courageously and successfully through the war, but just moment's later Travers enters the scene only to confuse him by contradicting this and exclaiming that Harry Monmouth is in fact dead. ...read more.

Middle

On the other hand, Northumberland wants everything to be destroyed by nature, it suggests that he wants all other to suffer just has he is, and this shows that he isn't a sympathetic character because after feeling the pain himself he now wants to force it on to others, which a sympathetic would tend not to do. However, the part where he says that Order must die could be perceived another way as he is already an anarchist and so this is what he wanted before Harry's death and so may not be a product of his grief but he is using his son's death as another motive to aim at his goals. Northumberland objected to Richard II and helped to overthrow him, but now he wants to rebel against Bolingbrook (Henry IV), who he once supported, but now believes him to be too devious, and this shows how involved he is in his anarchist behaviour, as well as how unpredictable his actions tend to be and so this gives support to the latter idea that his grief serves as a positive to his ambitions. Also, his son was very well liked in the kingdom as he was very charismatic and energetic, which are traits many would have been fond of. ...read more.

Conclusion

situation or whether his service believe he is lying and so know that he is competent to do the wait upon himself. This introduction and the reality of Northumberland's situation, being at home with his service makes him seem a very unsympathetic character; he has waged war on the monarchy and then leaves it up to others to do his duty. Also, in order to continue this point the idea that someone is too sick to go to war but still able to walk around by himself may make those watching the play feel even more strongly that he is in fact a liar. The setting is too cosy for anyone to feel much sympathy for the rebel. In conclusion, any sympathy that is drawn from Northumberland's loss is destroyed when his reasons are analysed, and his illness is proposed to be fake it is quite clear that he is mostly not a sympathetic character. However, it is impossible to prove this because it is only a rumour that he is playing 'crafty sick', he may really be unwell but he did send his family to be killed when he is in a homely environment and this may make the audience believe him to definitely be an unsympathetic character. ?? ?? ?? ?? A2 English literature Joanne Murch Henry IV part II essay ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Plays section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Plays essays

  1. An English Essay on why the character of Jimmy Porter is so Fascinating to ...

    From the Latin pusillus, very little, and animus, the mind. That's my wife!" This quote from act 1 shows that Jimmy shows no remorse when he verbally attacks his wife. It seems so unreal, how a married couple can survive together when the husband treats the wife as his enemy.

  2. A dolls house act one summary

    Nora says she will never disobey Helmer - however, she has already gone against his wishes by eating macaroons when he specifically told her not to, so this shows that even though she says she won't disobey him with the macaroons, she still did it.

  1. This is where we got the idea for our first pre-wedding scene, to look ...

    We chose to freeze here and tell the audience what was running through our minds as we felt that this was the most significant part in our play. A picture was also taken to show our facial expressions and how we were place on stage.

  2. With close reference to one or more

    I feel I used the Brechtian technique of alienation very successfully in these parts of the play. As the governor I also used the Brechtian technique of minimal props on stage. In the first scene, I used a scarf as the baby.

  1. Performance at Farnham Castle.

    hiding it for example moving from one scene to another just simply walking in front of the audience. All my research was from the internet because I find the internet easy and quick to use however after I learned the facts I went on to further my research in the local library.

  2. My Extended Essay discusses if the themes of violence, treachery and greed are effectively ...

    Chicago is an unconventional musical because it doesn't slap crime it celebrates it and this intrigues audiences to enjoy it because they always like something new. Dance is an enormous element in this musical because it derives the emotions and themes effectively throughout the entire musical.

  1. Choose a modern day situation (e.g. at school, a party, a mealtime etc.) and ...

    My research is displayed over the next few pages of my notebook. The information I collected was very interesting to read, and I accumulated enough to give us a really good idea of how people in the 1960s dressed and more importantly, how they behaved.

  2. Six Characters in Search of an Author by Luigi Pirandello, Act One, Scene One, ...

    shooting out in front of me. This tableau created a subtext that portrayed how misunderstood the Father is: perhaps translates into a foretelling by Pirandello of the initial reaction to his absurdist Meta-theatrical play. At the same time, however, the body language created via the physicality of ignoring the Producer,

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work