• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

An Argument on Restriction of Trade Should India be Easing Trade Restriction by force from the developed nations?

Free essay example:

An Argument on Restriction of Trade –

Should India be Easing Trade Restriction by force from the developed nations?


Name of the faculty: Mr. Vishwas Vallabh

Subject: Managerial Economics

Submitted by:

Arvind Mohan

An Argument on Restriction of Trade –

Should India be Easing Trade Restriction by force from the developed nations?


Recently, the United States attacked India's trade policy criticizing its barriers to agricultural imports and retail sector investment and warned that India may not have shaken off the red tape and trade restrictions that have long plagued foreign business.        

Trade barriers by other Countries

In the wake of the strong hypothetical case that has evolved for free international trade, almost all the country in the world has put up at least some barriers to trade. Trade restrictions are typically embarked on in an effort to protect companies and workers in the home economy from competition by foreign firms. Aprotectionist policyis one in which a country restricts the importation of goods and services produced in foreign countries.

 The meltdown in the U.S. economy in 2007 and in 2008 had shaped a new round of protectionist sentiment The United States, for example, used protectionist policies to limit the quantity of some foreign-produced goods coming into the United States. The effect of this policy was to reduce the supply of the good in the U.S. market and increase the price of the good.

The Impact of Protectionist Policies


Protectionist policies reduce the quantities of foreign good and services supplied to the country that imposes the restriction. As a result, such policies shift the supply curve to the left for the good or service whose imports are restricted. In the above figure, the supply curve shifts toS2, the equilibrium price rises toP2, and the equilibrium quantity falls toQ2. In general, this policy imposed for a particular good always reduce its supply, raise its price, and reduce the equilibrium quantity, Protection often takes the form of an import tax or a limit on the amount that can be imported, but it can also come in the form of voluntary export restrictions and other barriers.

Needless to say, India on the other hand, desires to ease trade restrictions. The Government also understands the imperative of trade liberalization India needs no preaching on the imperative of eliminating trade restrictions, but this exercise has to be undertaken on the basis of proportional reciprocity.

        Developed countries like the US who tend to champion the cause of free trade but their own trade policies have been turning highly protectionist over the past decade. If American companies import something more from India, it is because that they find it cheaper to import from India. Otherwise, they can source the item from somewhere else. If this leads to a trade surplus for India, it is no reason to change the country’s trade policies.

Besides, the US argument on trade liberalization lacks conviction, given its own recent actions — antidumping duties on steel and legislations banning business process outsourcing. While tutoring the virtues of free trade and multilateralism to developing countries, they themselves are creating strong regional trading blocs bound by common external tariffs and strong rules of origin such as the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) and now Free Trade Area of the Americas (FTAA).

Accounting for more than 60 per cent of world trade carried out on a preferential basis now, these trade blocs are diverting trade and investments away from the developing countries. In general, the average tariffs and other trade barriers are low in industrialized countries. However, their tariffs and trade barriers remain much higher on many products exported by developing countries. A startling example is the fact that tariffs collected by the US on $ 2 billion worth of imports from Bangladesh are higher than those imposed on imports worth $ 30 billon from France.

In order to facilitate free flow of goods and in the interest of fair trade, easing trade restrictions should be seen as a multilateral responsibility to be shared by all and the developed countries have to take the lead. In fact, developed economies maintain far greater trade restrictions compared to developing economies such as India. The latter cannot even afford to meet the costs that are usually associated with trade restrictions.

The fact is, India is going about removing trade restrictions in a unilateral and systematic way. It is important that developed economies like the United States and the European Union commit themselves to greater liberalization by eliminating all trade restrictions against products from developing economies, especially in the way of trade in agricultural commodities and services.

Trade Freedom by Year


United StatesWorld AverageIndia        image04.pngimage05.pngimage03.png

Of course, India needs to reduce its tariff barriers, but before it does that, It need to be assured that the US and the EU should also open up their markets to a substantial degree to enable other developing countries to access them particularly about market access for agricultural commodities, where developed economies have erected huge walls to protect their own markets.

On the lines of the services sector, developed economies have barely removed any restriction that could assist greater access to their markets. On the contrary, more barriers are being mounted in the name of protecting jobs, security concerns and public interest.

While developed economies maintain peak tariffs on products from developing countries, India does not maintain any such discrimination. In any case, our government has been consistently reducing tariff barriers, irrespective of whether the industry can bear it or not.

India does not maintain any major Non tariff Barriers(NTBs).whereas the developed economies are benefiting most from the existing World Trade Organization (WTO) agreements relating to NTBs and trade defense measures such as subsidies and countervailing measures, safeguard duties and so on. Although the Doha agenda has mandated negotiation for elimination of NTBs and India is actively participating in the negotiation and commit itself to implement the results of the negotiation

Developing economies cannot be oblivious to the needs of the vulnerable sections of their populace and their development. Just as the US, the EU and Japan are not ready to expose their farming community to open competition from outside; India need not expose millions of its small and marginal farmers to cheaper imports from other countries.

The current stalemate in negotiations on agriculture is on this issue. India need not bend over and ease trade restrictions just because the Cancun impasse has to be resolved.

India’s trade policy should be determined by domestic compulsions and should be driven solely by national interest and not by what the US, the EU or the developed countries wants.  

It is also not incumbent on India to sign a blank cheque for the sake of multilateralism.


This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level UK, European & Global Economics section.

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Related AS and A Level Economics Skills and Knowledge Essays

See our best essays

Related AS and A Level UK, European & Global Economics essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    ESSAY: Fair trade or free trade?

    5 star(s)

    When considering these facts, Ricardo's theory seems to be right, openness and trade sustain countries' growth while protectionism let the other falling further and further. This is a good example of how useful the GATT would be. But most of the work done was only on tariffs, and after the 8th round, the WTO was established.

  2. Where does the World Trade Organisation fit in the overall scheme of international public ...

    Malloch Brown's arguments do not display a high degree of economic literacy, but are representative of a certain style of thinking in international policy circles, especially on development issues. It would nevertheless be a caricature to reduce Globalisation and Social Democracy to the statements of senior international civil servants.

  1. North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA)

    Perhaps the most troubling aspect is the fact that corporations have exploited Chapter 11 in many of their cases as they had nothing to do with expropriation, but rather their desire to obtain a dominating position in the marketplace. A prime example of this is the UPS case against Canada Post.

  2. This investigation will try to test the level of external debt and measure its ...

    2.2 The information used in this investigation was obtained from visits made to the central bank of Ecuador, Ministry of Finance, University Library, public brochures and statistics, personal interviews with government officials. After carrying out a critical analysis on the information compiled, and paying close attention to levels, structure and

  1. Critically evaluate Brazil's International Trade Policy in terms of key trade issues and primary ...

    * Over 15% of Brazilian exports go to European Union (EU) countries such as Holland, Germany, and Italy. * Argentina takes 11%, with almost half going to South America. * The Asian market is rising. Japan currently leads the field with 5% 3.0 Brazil's Foreign Trade Environment Brazil's foreign trade environment divides into internal environment and external environment.

  2. International Accounting Harmonization

    conforming IT products and create an even greater incentive for manufacturers to develop accessible products" (Stuckert, 2005).

  1. Discuss The Various Forms Of Non-Tariff Barriers Used By Countries To Limit The Free ...

    The diagram below shows the effect of a quota2: 1.2 Voluntary Export Restraints - VER's VER's were developed as a response to pressure for protection from import sensitive industries. Under agreements as such, sometimes, low cost exporters 'voluntarily' restrict sales to countries where their goods were threatening industry and employment.

  2. Evaluate the view that 'unfair terms of trade' are the primary cause of poverty ...

    Foreign Investment Investing particularly in agriculture and mining projects. Aid Assisting less developed parts of the world for motives, ranging from 'doing good' to 'being greedy'. Doing good is illustrated in the work of the missionaries, and being greedy is by granting high interest or tied loans.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work