• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

CHINA: To What Extent Did The Three Missions (Macartney, Amherst and Naipier) Fail?

Extracts from this document...


To What Extent Did The Three Missions (Macartney, Amherst and Naipier) Fail? The Orthodox view of the Macartney (1793), Amherst (1816) and Napier (1834) missions to China is that the missions ended in failure. And indeed, if failure is defined by the success of the missions to reach their goals, then they were. However, this essay will argue that stipulate that, if failure of the missions is defined as the total absence of any benefit to the British occurring, then the missions can not be said to have failed to the full extent. The lessons that the British learned about the Chinese from their respective missions were beneficial to them as they helped to demonstrate the course of action required to rectify their grievances with the state of trade in China. The Maccartney mission in China had goals which were to be reflected in the other missions to bei jing. They were to change the framework of trade in china from the inhospitable Canton system to something more suitable to British interests, and to establish some form of treaty defining the changes. ...read more.


Therefore, it can be argued that the mission was not a failure to a full extent, as it was successful in bringing the British further knowledge. The Amherst mission, 23 years later, while better prepared, did not have more success in the achievement of its diplomatic goals. The mission was expelled from Bei Jing without an audience when it was learned that Amherst refused to Kowtow. The new emperor Jia Qing's edict to the King addressed the ambassador's disrespectful ignorance of ettiquette and stated that 'if you remain sincerely loyal to us, your ambassadors need not come to court.' Therefore, it can be seen that the Amherst mission was also a failure in the respect that it did not achieve its diplomatic goals, and even served to further confirm the Chinese views that the British were inconsequential barbarians. However, as with the Macartney mission, the Amherst mission was not a failure to a full extent. The noted historian Robert Vohra states that while to the Chinese the envoy was somewhat inconsequential, in England 'more and more people were coming to the conclusion that since all attempts to establish fair relations with China only resulted in insults to Britain, China would have to be dealt with in a more forceful fashion.' ...read more.


They were misled and deluded (understandably so) into thinking that their world view was correct and that they could persist in treating foreign countries as tributary state, and the foreigners as useless barbarians. This precedent can be seen as beneficial to the British as it meant that the Chinese were totally unprepared for their successful performance in the first opium war, which allowed them to sign the treaty of Nanking. In conclusion, the extent to which the missions of macartney, Amherst and Naipier in china failed cannot be judged simply by their lack of short term gain. The long term effects the missions had upon the British views of China must be taken into account. If these two different aspects are looked at, it can be seen that the missions were not failures to the full extent, because of the invaluable knowledge they brought to the British, and also because of the precedent they set to the Chinese (which encouraged them to underestimate the strength of the British desires for trade). ?? ?? ?? ?? 10/05/2007 Isabel Marden ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level UK, European & Global Economics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level UK, European & Global Economics essays

  1. A study of Patent system in India in the light of Patent Cooperation Treaty.

    the applications abroad, * fees structure which includes the transmittal fees, search fee etc * possibly some hidden fees which can be come out only at the time of transactions, * regarding the amendment in the claims and their procedure, * Impact of ISA, what is the guarantee of the search report and so on and so forth.

  2. Comprehensive Anatomy of China

    Northwest China includes, administratively, a significant portion of the Xinjiang Uygur Autonomous Region, small sections of the Gansu Province and Inner Mongolia Autonomous Region. Xinjiang is quickly becoming China's main source of cotton and hops, of which 33 percent and 80 percent of the country's supply was respectively reported for in 2001.

  1. Where does the World Trade Organisation fit in the overall scheme of international public ...

    Trade sanctions could then be used to enforce compliance with MEAs. This may make sense for some MEAs, but not for others. The second part of the Ministerial Declaration on trade and environment instructs the Committee on Trade and Environment to work on the following: 1)

  2. To What Extent Did Imperial Concerns Guide British Foreign Policy Between 1890- 1907?

    Its colonies were focused mainly on South Africa. Germany a young, immature country was keen to possess an outward display of its power, in the form of an empire, which it regarded as a sign of power. In contrast to Germans empire Britain possessed a total of fifty-five colonies across all continents by 1914.

  1. Outline the issues under discussion at Cancún - Why did talks fail?

    Revenue duties collected in the US are the same from Bangladesh as they are from France. The affects that these tariffs and subsidies are having are very detrimental to the developing countries. Firstly this is shown below with the effect of a subsidy diagram in fig 1.1.

  2. "Strategies Applied in Organization in Big Chinese Society"

    profitable progress over the last two decades but even with that many are in still in doubt if China can find solutions to the great difficulties and challenges it is facing. In the State of the Union Address of President George Bush in 1999, he proudly stated that "Today, America is the most dynamic, competitive, job-creating economy in history."

  1. Why did the embassies of Lord McCartney in 1793 and Lord Amherst in 1816 ...

    The thing is utterly impracticable. How can our dynasty alter its whole procedure and system of etiquette, established for more than a century, in order to meet your individual view?" To make the matter worse, Emperor Chia-ch'ing, the son of Emperor Ch'ien-lung, was reserved and did not even receive foreign envoys unlike his father.

  2. Peoples' republic of China

    Generally, the Administration (first Bush and then Clinton) favored extension of most favored nation status for the PRC, while strong opposition to that designation for the PRC existed in the Congress. Through early-1996, the Administration position has generally prevailed, although to reach accommodation with the Congress, some governmental restrictions on US-China trade continue (Brauchli & Chang, 1996, p.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work