• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Comment critically on comparative advantage as a basis for international trade.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Daniel Colton Comparative advantage was an idea proposed by David Ricardo in 1817, and is an idea which can be used on a variety of scales, but is most often used when analysing international trade. Ricardo used the idea of wool produced in England at a lower opportunity cost than wool is produced in Portugal relative to wine, while in Portugal wine is produced at a lower opportunity cost than wine is produced in Britain relative to the wool. This means that in Portugal it is less costly to produce wine in terms of what is the next best use of the resources involved. The reasons that this occurs could be for any number of reasons: weather, technology, productivity of workers in that industry and so on. This idea is one that all countries can benefit from, as even a tiny country will have a comparative advantage in a good relative to another good, even when trading with a world superpower. Comparative advantage is often used to look at just two countries and two goods, which is not necessarily a pitfall as the model can be applied to multiple countries and multiple goods, it is just for simplicity. ...read more.

Middle

The government would have to spend a huge amount on supply side policies such as very efficient schemes of education or perhaps low taxation (Thatcherite) to be able to transfer skills that quickly, and shift the long run aggregate supply curve to the right, thus reducing unemployment: Because the government realises just how unlikely and difficult it is to transfer resources, it actively discourages the failure of an industry, as shown by the EU's enormous subsidies of the farmers in this country, most notably the Common Agricultural Policy. It is therefore acting against the theory of comparative advantage, as this would dictate that the farmers move into the service sector, where Britain is very productive. This shows how politics has a great affect on trade once the industry has been established, though comparative advantage may well have dictated what industries were originally started and how they grew, even if politics has a greater effect today. The fact that politics makes a big difference in the effect of comparative advantage demonstrates another shortcoming of the theory. ...read more.

Conclusion

It is at no stage a random process as to what goods are traded, and there are good reasons for why bananas aren't grown in England and sheep aren't reared in the West Indies. The productivity of a country in producing a good dictates what it will trade, and a country that is very inefficient in producing a good will move onto something to which it is more suited. There are of course cases where this is overridden by the factors mentioned, but ultimately comparative advantage theory does form a 'basis' as the title suggests, to almost all international trade. For the trade to occur, the terms of trade are laid out, which is simplified to compromising between the opportunity cost ratios of the two countries. Once again, this is not exactly how it works, as politics and economics merge to create something slightly different, but it is highly likely to be something close to what comparative advantage suggests it should be. It is inevitable that the model does not fit the real world, but there is not a single economic theory that can be applied directly to an economy with no assumptions being made. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level UK, European & Global Economics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level UK, European & Global Economics essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    ESSAY: Fair trade or free trade?

    5 star(s)

    More than half of the least developed country members (81 millions people) which are in the WTO are not represented in Geneva. Those who are represented have only one person while the USA has more than 250 experts in negotiation. As a consequence there are more and more unbalanced agreements.

  2. International entrepreneurship in Europe

    So there are a lot of evidence and cases to support the author's standpoint. 2.8 MARIAN, V. (2001) First Steps In Internationalization Concepts And Evidence From A Sample Of Small High-Technology Firms. International Management, 7(3), pp.191-210. The author argue that the first major steps in a firm's internationalization process are

  1. CRITICALLY EVALUATE THE THEORIES OF ABSOLUTE ADVANTAGE (ADAM SMITH MODEL) AND COMPARATIVE ADVANTAGE (DAVID ...

    A country has an absolute advantage in the production of a good relative to another country if it can produce the good at a lower cost or with higher productivity. Absolute advantage compares industry productivities across countries. Opportunity cost is defined generally as the value of the next best opportunity.

  2. Flower Industry in Netherlands

    * When evaluating the pros and cons of a proposal or making a final decision, very few opinions should be given based on your subjective feelings, unless these are considered critical to consumers as well. * Use empirical or objective data to support your idea or products.

  1. This paper investigates an evidence to support the HOV model by carrying out a ...

    The last fifteen years have seen wide swings in trade economists' views of models of the factor content of trade. Pioneer studies were made by Leamer (1980 and 1984), Bowen, Leamer and Sveikauskas (1987) and Maskus (1985). It was not so easy to see that this represented only a phase in the development of the literature of the trade theory.

  2. The world trade organisation has stated that everyone gains by a world increasingly organised ...

    As they have no incentive to become efficient and produce goods that consumers want to buy at the keenest prices. Such industries are unlikely ever to develop into strong industries capable of conquering export markets. Freer trade on the other hand; forces firms to become efficient and competitive or else they go bankrupt.

  1. Are recessions inevitable?

    You could ask a survey of economists and people, whether they think the economy is in recession, although this is very subjective. The chart below illustrates different ways to judge the severity of the economic slowdown since the start of the credit crunch in August 2007.

  2. The Benefits of Trade

    These organizations base their view on the fact that all countries will benefit from the unrestricted flow of cross-border trade. The GATT, established in 1947, is central to trade negotiations and is based on two major principles. The first is non- discrimination between member states.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work