• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Discuss whether the privatisation of British Rail has been successful. Evaluate whether the new structure is likely to be a more effective and efficient way if managing a national rail network.

Extracts from this document...


Elizabeth Wood Discuss whether the privatisation of British Rail has been successful. Evaluate whether the new structure is likely to be a more effective and efficient way if managing a national rail network. [40] Privatisation was developed by Mrs. Thatcher's government as a way to re-introduce the profit motive to many of the industries that had been nationalised in the past. The poor performance of the nationalised industries meant that they were a heavy drain on the public finances. The government were looking for a way to restore the profit motive and make them more efficient. Privatisation - returning the companies to the private sector - was the method that was developed. As with many of the later privatisations, British Rail was privatised in a way, which separated the natural monopoly from the potentially competitive parts of the industry. The track and signalling are unavoidable monopoly that has been privatised as a separate company known as Rail Track. This company was heavily regulated to prevent it exploiting its market position. The operation of rail services on the monopoly track can be arranged in a more competitive way. ...read more.


British Rail's privatisation was ultimately a failure, demonstrated by the collapse of Railtrack. There was hope of improved customer service and opening the market up to competition. The collapse of Railtrack was not only a disappointment to the government, but also brought immense embarrassment. As for the shareholders of Railtrack, the announcement of it being put into administration was a tragedy after the faith and financial backing they had all placed in the company, bearing a huge financial loss to many. Now it is openly acknowledged that the fragmentation of the industry into a myriad of contractors all attempting to maximise shareholder value would inevitably create an incentive structure in which the name of the game was to pass the buck, cut costs indiscriminately and take risks with safety and service. The initial structure of the privatized British Rail was for Railtrack to take over British Rail's infrastructure; i.e. the track, signaling, the stations and extensive land and property assets. It is responsible for the operating timetable, and determines charges for train operating companies and raises capital for future investment. Twenty-five Train operating companies (TOCs) ...read more.


This is an opportunity to improve the control and management of the railways.. Any moves towards giving the regions an opportunity to direct their own destiny would be strengthened by greater transport powers. The transport secretary's proposals for speeding up planning are also expected to enhance regional power. The reform of the railways could democratize railways while, at the same time, improving them. The method by which the rail industry was fragmented made it difficult for Railtrack to be a success. It was inefficient, monolithic and hidebound by tradition. The skeleton of the advanced passenger train at Crewe is a monument to the problems that the public sector had in introducing new technology. British Rail's culture stifled the good management potential that was locked inside. Standards of service have yet to return to pre-Hatfield levels. However, an improvement in the efficiency of the railways is sure to occur due to a company being limited by guarantee but with public-interest objectives and no shareholders, allowing the rail industry to go forward removing dome of the inbuilt contradictions that have trapped it until now. Yet the main driving forces - increasing use of the railways, economic growth, rising road traffic congestion and regulated fares - remain in place. With step-by-step reform, the long-term prospects for Britain's railways are bright. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Markets & Managing the Economy section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Markets & Managing the Economy essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Comment on the statement that only carbon trading is likely to be an effective ...

    3 star(s)

    We also need to look at the efficiency of carbon trading, this is whether it produces Allocative and productive efficiency.If any of these methods are economically efficient, then they should produce at the Social Optimum Output.

  2. "Discuss and evaluate the proposition that perfect competition is a more efficient market structure ...

    The diagram below shows the short term equilibrium of a firm and the market in a perfect competitive market. The Representative firm The market As long as the ATC curve is underneath the price line (P) there would be an economic profit as shown in the diagram.

  1. The Rail Industry.

    This focus resulted in the closure of many minor routes and reduced the size of the railways by about 2,000 miles and the closure of more than 2,000 small stations. 1.2 The UK Railways Since Privatisation The main premise of the 1993 Railways Act was to privatise the BRB.

  2. To make a decision whether to work or not a rational individual has to ...

    just to renew the wardrobe keeping in mind the necessity to follow corporate dress code. Again prices vary greatly, among other factors there is a difference in prices of clothes for ladies and young gentlemen. This part of estimating costs of working appears to be the most difficult.

  1. The Scottish Smoking ban

    As stated in the BBC news website after the ban was introduced in Dublin "7,000 people stopped smoking" resulting in cigarette sales decreasing by 16%. It is thought that the same thing is to happen in Scotland. Below is the supply and demand graph.

  2. What are the reasons for governments to own business and assets? Why has ...

    It is in fact inconsistent with the socialists' ideology for maintaining social equity and equality. The only possible way is for the government to own and run the industry. Even if the government makes some profits, they belong to public rather than the organization itself.

  1. What Are The Effects Of Tescos Oligopolistic Market Structure, On Both Consumers And Producers?

    This graph can be seen below, Figure 9. The entire data are for Tesco's financial years, which run for 52 or 53 week periods to late February. Up to the 27 February 2007 period end, the numbers include non-UK and Ireland results for the calendar year ended on 31 December 2006 in the accounting year.

  2. Did the privatisation of British Rail lead to an efficient outcome?

    In the diagram, at the (profit-maximised) output, the price they sold (where AR cuts quantity output) is higher that average cost at that quantity output, generating Super Normal Profits. As a result, the market will fail to achieve allocative efficiency (equilibrium price is higher than marginal cost).

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work