• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Examine the effectiveness of economic sanctions as a tool of statecraft.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Examine the effectiveness of economic sanctions as a tool of statecraft. Introduction Since the end of the cold war the international community has seen the significantly increased use of economic sanctions as a tool of statecraft. Economic sanctions 'appeared to offer the promise of effective Security Council action to resolve conflict and enforce international legal norms without the use of military force' (Cortright and Lopez, 2000, p.2). This report will evaluate if the aims of political leaders, who have increasingly used economic sanctions, have been realised or if they have failed to achieve their intended impact. Measuring Effectiveness It appears that political scientists in this area of study harbour differing views on how the effectiveness of economic sanctions should be measured. Baldwin argues that 'the mere imposition of economic sanctions should automatically qualify as success' (Baldwin, 1985, p.372) therefore if this is to be believed then an economic sanction should be considered a successful just because of its implementation, even if it is ineffective in its goals hoped for by the sender countries government. However most scholars are not so quick to brand economic sanctions a success with Hufbauer, Schott and Elliot agreed that 'in judging the success in sanctions, we confine our examination to changes in the policies and capabilities of the target country' (Elliot, Haufbauer and Schott, 1990, p.3). So the effectiveness of sanctions, if their analysis is to be considered, is ultimately measured by whether the target state changes a certain policy that might stop sanctions, or if its capabilities militarily, economically or politically are hindered. ...read more.

Middle

(Source: UNITED NATIONS FOOD & AGRICULTURE ORGANIZATION'S, 1996) If sanctions are killing thousands of children and they are not reaching their targets in Iraq and other countries, which is evident through Saddam's continuing reign of terror and obvious wealth then sanctions cannot be labelled effective. This pursuit of national interests through sanctions appears to link them with realist political thoughts. The U.S is a prime example of this with it being a 'state forced to help itself and give priority to its own national interest' (Heywood, 1997, P.143). If sanctions are implemented to prevent any kind of hardship or grievance to the sender country, even if it means adverse humanitarian effects then they are part of a realist form of statecraft. * Sanctions have caused humanitarian crisis in the past Bosnian conflict. Seemingly doing the right thing the U.S and her allies imposed an arms embargo on Bosnia so that fighting would be forced to a stop once the ammunition ran out. However 'the arms embargo weakened the Muslims since the Bosnian Serbs and the Croats had larger stores of military supplies and greater access to outside sources' (Haas, 1997, P.77). This shows how sanctions in the past have been very difficult to implement without there being adverse humanitarian consequences, and highlights how in the past sanctions have not been thought through and have proved ineffective. The simple implementation of this sanction as a symbol of U.S opposition to military violence, as taken from Baldwin's perspective, holds no credibility in this case. ...read more.

Conclusion

This greater effectiveness of multilateral sanctions depends on 'two expectations: that greater co-operation will increase the economic punishment on target states and, more critically, that increased punishment will make targets more likely to concede' (Pape, 1997, P.108) so greater co-operation is fruitless if it signals no extra cost to the target country. Overall it is the findings of this paper that 'economic sanctions are ineffective in the aggregate' (Drury, 2000, P.624) and have been over used in the past by states who are reluctant to embark on a military campaign but still want to signal to the world that they will not put up with the behaviour of the target state. Most of the literature supports this with most scholars agreeing that 'sanctions should rather be implemented as part of a broader strategy' (Barber, 1997, P.374) with the threat of military force if sanctions fail. It has often been the case that without the threat of military force behind them, sanctions have failed to convince the rulers of the target states to concede to the sender's demands. Also the humanitarian consequences in the past have been so great that it appears that sanctions have no place in a Liberal Democratic world, even though they have only been used more recently since the consolidation of Liberal Democracy in the majority of the world's politics. The preventing of Humanitarian consequences should be seen as vital in ensuring the future use and effectiveness of economic sanctions. Until all of these problems are resolved and politicians rethink their strategies regarding sanctions we will continue to see, overall, the ineffectiveness of economic sanctions. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level UK, European & Global Economics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level UK, European & Global Economics essays

  1. Where does the World Trade Organisation fit in the overall scheme of international public ...

    property rights and play their part in making domestic structures more flexible in order to facilitate adaptation to external change. With appropriate implementation within national jurisdictions, therefore, international trade rules should be an instrument of domestic constitutional refurbishment - "the second line of national constitutional entrenchment".50 Following Tumlir's thinking, one

  2. What as the impact of China's re-engagement with the international community been on its ...

    At present, six of the 10 leading fish countries are Asian; however, China takes the world's biggest catch (at 12 million tonnes in 1991)and Thailand is the world's biggest fish seller. Hence, in the future, there may be some clashes on fisheries between China and Southeast Asian countries because mostly their fish products are from the South China Sea.

  1. A view from the bridge - Examine the manliness hostility and aggression and the ...

    and if so Eddie would be waiting to see a look of indifference on Rodolpho's face, and maybe even a kiss back. Rodolpho's character has a big impact on the whole family. Catherine and Beatrice seem to see him as funny, lively and attractive with Beatrice saying: "He's a nice

  2. In what ways is the government attempting to increase the willingness to wor

    Along those years inflation reached a trough of just above 0.5% in 2000. Unemployment however has dropped significantly since 1993. Until 1999 unemployment dropped sharply after then it's been quite steady hovering in and around the 3% mark. Low inflation and low unemployment has been mainly due to supply side policies that the government has introduced.

  1. International trade - In this case I choose the country Canada. When doing a ...

    Before trade it produces and consumes 9 units of cloth and 6 units of wine. Total production between the two countries is 17 units of cloth and 11 units of wine. After the trade, Portugal only produce wine and England cloth, the total production is 18 units of cloth (270 � 15 =)

  2. This essay aims to discuss the post-WWI economic disaster, the impacts this had on ...

    agricultural market, the United States in both industrial and agriculture and Japan who had became a major exporter to other Asian countries2. Four years of armed conflict left a range of problems to the international economy, which would never completely be solved.

  1. Islamic terrorism is a serious problem for the United States because of the threat ...

    Tehran conducted 13 assassinations in 1997, the majority of which were carried out in northern Iraq against the regime's main opposition groups. In January of 1997, Iranian agents tried to attack the Baghdad headquarters of Mujahedin-e Khalq using a supermortar.

  2. Dispute Resolution in Ireland

    On January 1, 2001 legislation bringing Irish intellectual property rights (IPR) law into compliance with Ireland's obligations under the WTO Trade-Related Intellectual Property Treaty (TRIPS) came into force giving Ireland one of the most comprehensive systems of IPR protection in Europe (Ireland Country, 2003).

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work