• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Expansionary monetary policy is not the main explanation of either the turning point or the extent of the economic recovery in the 1930s Discuss.

Extracts from this document...


"Expansionary monetary policy is not the main explanation of either the turning point or the extent of the economic recovery in the 1930s" Discuss. This essay will argue that monetary policy was important to starting the recovery in the early 1930s, but is by no means the explanation for the extent of the recovery, which relied on fiscal policy and the growth of the manufacturing sector to keep going through the late 1930s. Worswick (1984) wrote that 'spontaneous forces alone will not count for the recovery. Policy made important contributions.' According to Worswick, and in line with much of the literature, the abandonment of gold and the depreciation of sterling were key to economic recovery. After Britain abandoned the gold standard in 1931, a managed floating exchange rate was adopted, in order to give British exports a competitive edge, this being the first way in which monetary policy contributed to recovery. The success of this stimulus to exports, however, was negligible. As sterling fell from �1=$4.86 to a low of �1=$3.24, exports did grow, and finally stabilised in 1932, despite continuing to fall in the continent, but it is estimated to have contributed very little to the recovery. Although exports initially rose by 24% in the last quarter of 1932, thanks to the depreciation of sterling, this was not maintained for the rest of the decade. ...read more.


In turn, Broadberry (1986) allocates about 50% of the rise in housing investment in 1931-1933 to the advent of 'cheap money', and hence monetary policy. Monetary policy, therefore, impacted strongly on residential investment, as well as supporting the recovery of the commercial and industrial sectors, ultimately leading to economic recovery. Therefore, by stimulating the housing sector, monetary policy could be seen as a vital factor in explaining the turning point in the 1930s, when economic recovery finally began. Although monetary policy can be helpful in explaining how the recovery phase began, it does not suffice in explaining the extent of the recovery for several reasons. First of all, by mid 1933, investment in housing slowed down in comparison to other sectors, such as manufacturing and transport, which were growing at an average of 14% throughout 1937. These new manufacturing and transport industries were providing one third of all new jobs by 1937, and thus powering the recovery. Secondly, although rising government spending on goods and services was only a small feature of the recovery in its early stages, it formed a very significant stimulus to recovery from 1935 onwards, with the rapid growth of expenditure on rearmament ensuring that the 1937-1938 recession was of short duration and that the economy was growing rapidly by the eve of the Second World War. ...read more.


As noted by Mowat (1955), "The deflationary phase of the National government's policy was short-lived . . . [their] financial policies made the best of both worlds; they seemed sufficiently deflationary to restore confidence; they were in fact sufficiently inflationary to assist recovery by maintaining the purchasing power of the people." However, had the recovery not commenced, cheap money not been successfully implemented, and fiscal window-dressing not deployed extensively, then the year would almost certainly have closed with a substantial deficit. As it was, a deficit of �32.3m (0.9 per cent of GDP) was posted, but this was not corrosive of confidence in the way that it would have been even 12 months earlier, and by the following year a surplus of almost the same sum was achieved. Thereafter, for the next 3 years, recovery in the public finances tracked recovery in the real economy, providing scope thereby for tax remissions and a resumption of expenditure growth. We can therefore conclude that although expansionary monetary policy helped to start the recovery in the early 1930s, it is by no means the main explanation for the extent of the recovery. Monetary policy stimulated recovery via the housing market in the early 30s, but it was a combination of growth in the manufacturing sector post 1933 and fiscal policy, especially post 1935, which contributed to keeping the recovery on track and speeding up the growth of GDP. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Macroeconomics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Macroeconomics essays

  1. Peer reviewed

    Fiscal and monetary policy - a comparison

    4 star(s)

    Since investment spending results in a larger capital stock, then incomes in the future will also be higher through the impact on LRAS. Fiscal policy expansion An expansion in fiscal policy (i.e. an increase in government spending) adds directly to AD but if financed by higher government borrowing, this may result in higher interest rates and lower investment.

  2. Comparing the effects of immigration on GDP in Malaysia, Japan and South Africa.

    As at July 2004, there are about 1.3 million registered foreign workers, constituting 12% of total employment in the country. (Foreign Workers and the Malaysian Economy, Extracted From The Economic Report 2004/2005, Ministry Of Finance Malaysia) There are approximate of 1.9 million of foreign workers residing in Malaysia in year 2010.

  1. Budget 2004-05 and Economic Analysis of Pakistan

    67560 70108 74806 Workers Profit Participation Tax 3000 3000 4000 Foreign Travel Tax 2500 2088 4216 Petroleum Development Levy 46135 46400 47506 Gas Development Surcharge 15000 14226 15023 Arrears (Surcharges) 0 3774 2777 Airport Tax 925 620 1284 TOTAL 577560 580108 65480 NON TAX REVENUES (Rs.in Million)

  2. To what extent does the government budget/statement reflect current government priorities?

    The government is slowly increasing the amount spent in health and all the time, every year introducing new legislations and targets to make the NHS a more efficient and improved service for everyone within the UK. "We are determined to maintain our disciplined approach, determined not to make the old

  1. Critically examine the hypothesis that economic recovery in the 1930s was based upon the ...

    However, the depreciation can only easily explain the tendency for a rise in exports, and hence economic recovery, until 1936. After 1936, British exports continued to rise, despite remaining stagnant on the Continent, even though sterling appreciated sharply in 1933-1934, as a result of the depreciation of the American dollar.

  2. Greece financial crisis: The main causes of this crisis are? What are ...

    Greece adopted the euro (�) as its currency in January 2002. The adoption of the euro provided Greece (formerly a high inflation risk country under the drachma) with access to competitive loan rates and also to low rates of the Eurobond market.

  1. Governments set economic objectives - Discuss the relative importance of each of these objectives ...

    out of a total managed expenditure of �418 billion compared to �65 billion spent on the NHS. Unemployment, particularly amongst the young, leads to increased crime, violence and vandalism, which destroys the local community. Areas if high unemployment tend to be run down, which would have a knock-on effect to

  2. Fiscal policy is a macroeconomic policy.

    due to the multiplier effect. On the graph, the equilibrium level of income is at 12000, but the economy requires a level of income of 16000 to ensure full employment of resource (Ye) this shortage of demand is call the DEFLATIONARY GAP. To fix this gap, the government could supplement private sector spend with a budget deficit.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work