• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

A comparison of Wordsworth's 'I wandered lonely as a cloud' and Clarkes 'Miracle on Saint David's Day'.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

A comparison of Wordsworth's 'Iwandered lonely as a cloud' and Clarkes 'Miracle on Saint David's Day'. The title 'I wandered lonely as a cloud,' says a lot about the poem, especially as it is also the first line. It immediately starts off the poem with a sense of inner disharmony, shown by the words 'wandered', 'lonely' and 'cloud'. 'Wandered' gives the impression of being purposeless and 'lonely' shows that he longs for some sort of relationship. The word 'cloud' also relates to the loneliness and distance between him and civilisation. It could also mean that the poet is comfortable with his loneliness and wandering, just as a cloud seems comfortable alone. It also starts off a comparison between man and nature, an idea illustrated throughout both poems. The title of the second poem 'miracle on Saint David's day' starts straight off with a religious theme. Though this is not particularly shown through either poem, the fact a 'miracle' is a revelation is. In the first poem it is shown by the words 'when all at once' and shown in the second poem by 'he is suddenly staring'. ...read more.

Middle

It also seems that because he is so passionate he exaggerates every fact showing his enthusiasm. In the second poem the beautiful rhythmatic group of words is stopped abruptly with the technicality of the word 'schizophrenic'. Going back to the welsh culture, the words 'as many buckets of coal,' seems ironic as the welsh coal industry closed down, leaving no more coal. In poem 2 the fact that the mental patients feel trapped and 'caged' reflects Wordsworth's agony of loneliness. In the first poem Wordsworth uses old fashioned language, 'gay' and 'jocund'. In both poems they seem to focus on the wealth of memories and natural happiness and less concerned with currency. In Clarke's poem all the patients seem to be extremes, one absent, one absorbed. The mental patients in her poem seem to be like cattle, led to where there supposed to be, then a revelation happens which leads to a rebel among the flock. This might symbolise the mans grasp on sanity. As he is a labouring man the fact he doesn't speak might be a sign of stupidity, but that is stricken. When he repeats the poem, it reminds me of the phrase, 'just because I don't, doesn't mean I can't'. ...read more.

Conclusion

Again back to welsh culture, Clarke's poem seems to go into the music of speech and the welsh cultural identity is centred around music and dancing, making his words a performance. It seems that Clarke has a view that the welsh cultural voice is being lost and they need to regain it. This is shown by the last line of the poem, 'and the daffodils are flame'. The 'flame; is the revolution and that's what Clarke's edging towards. They need to break free from the chains of money and voice there opinions on the world. It seems although both poems are written in a different time and style they both have a strong theme that money does not create happiness, and mostly leads to misery. Clarkes poem was written in response to wordsworths one and has merely built on the idea from a different perspective. Wordsworth seems to have been written in a fluent, nursery rhyme style while as clarkes style seems to be focusing on a hard, difficult and shocking structure. Its as if Clarke is trying to voice wordsworths ideas, but make them more eventful. Altogether it seems that the poems are both evaluating the same ideas but interperating them in different styles. Anne-Marie Waterworth 10df ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level William Wordsworth section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level William Wordsworth essays

  1. I wandered lonely as a cloud - William Wordsworth - review.

    This helps to show the love and interest in nature, which was common in the Romantic Age. The Romantic Age showed a new found respect for the imagination rather then intelligence; this is shown during the poem. Wordsworth describes how he stopped and "gazed and gazed but little thought", this

  2. Miracle on St David's Day by Gillian Clarke

    Therefore Gillian Clarke is saying that the man was not properly alive until the music in his life was restored. He is reciting poetry because what he has heard from the nurses in the institution has restored his memory and he has remembered a poem that he had learnt as a child at school.

  1. Discuss Wordsworth's and Coleridge's attitudes to nature in Their poetry with particular reference to ...

    Resolution and Independence (The Leech Gatherer) by Wordsworth relates directly to nature. The poem has been given to titles, what it seem a more superior one (Resolution and Independence) and a lesser one (The Leech Gatherer). I believe this is because the poem has two depths.

  2. How do poems 'Daffodils' by William Wordsworth and 'Miracle on St. David's Day' by ...

    Yet now in comparison to the first verse he is now content while alone, "bliss of solitude", he is reflecting on the past which holds good memories for him. Wordsworth has split his poem into 4 stanzas, each one 6 lines long, with the majority of the lines including 8 syllables.

  1. In William Wordsworth's "We Are Seven," perception plays an important role in the relationship ...

    She sings to them, spends time with them as if they were still living. To her they have just "gone away" (Wordsworth, L 52). To the speaker, her siblings are dead. The speaker can only see the situation through his own perception and thus cannot grasp why the girl feels the way she does.

  2. In your opinion, how successfully does Lyrical Ballads capture the hour of feeling?

    'The Old Man Travelling' is criticised for the same, unpatriotic feeling. As for the 'Last of the Flock' Burney concludes that it is a "gloomy" poem, and that "No oppression is pointed out" implying that it was the shepherd's own fault.

  1. Comparison with 'The Thought-Fox' and 'I Wandered Lonely as a Cloud'

    Outside the night is starless, silent, and totally black. But the poet senses a presence which disturbs him, there is 'a fox's nose' touching a 'twig' then 'leaf'. The fox 'sets neat prints into the snow' as the writer is printing the poem but this all disappears as the poem ends with the fox entering the dark hole of

  2. Compare the theme of loneliness in the 'The daffodils or the inward eye' and ...

    "In a cage of first march sun a woman sits not listening, not seeing, not feeling." By combining these two words it has made us realise how painful and horrific loneliness really is for the patients in 'miracle o.s.day'.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work