• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

If Justice is relative, depending on personal point of view, how can it be Justice?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

"If Justice is relative, depending on personal point of view, how can it be Justice?" In the light of this comment, how do you find justice presented in 'King Lear'? The fate of the characters in the tragedy 'King Lear' (based on their natures) raises doubts about whether poetic justice or lawful justice is well served. Mostly human justice is flawed by human nature itself, being easily influenced by wealth, power and jealousy, resulting in injustice and evil. Shakespeare portrays in 'King Lear' a strong belief in divine justice. As revealed when Edgar states: "the gods are just, and of our pleasant vices make instruments to plague us" suggesting that the 'pleasant vices' their humanity possesses blocks the path of virtue, so that the evil we cause turns against us. Thus, unless humans choose to live virtuously - given free will - justice will never prevail. This is acceptable though the 'Gods are just' aspect becomes questionable. The misuse of justice is witnessed by those in positions of power asserting their authority which is tainted by the foibles human nature. At the start of the play, King Lear imposes a love test where each daughter has to profess her love in the most elaborate manner in order to receive the largest share of his kingdom: "Which of you shall we say doth love us the most. ...read more.

Middle

Surely the punishment of plucking eyes out is indifferent- as according to the 'form of justice' Gloucester shouldn't have been punished at all. Thus justice appears as a play of custom for such act lays within pleasure vices the powerful take. Gloucester is easily seen as a victim of unjust as he prepared to suffocate for Lear. His honest nature would not let him stand aside and watch "[Regan's] cruel nails / Pluck out [Lear's] poor old eyes". This is shockingly portrayed as Cornwall suggests that their power can alter "form of justice": "yet our power shall do a courtesy to our wrath". The play employs poetic justice to all evil characters in the play. Yet King Lear and Gloucester suffocated more than evildoers as consequence of their misjudgments, which can be seen as harsh justice at work. "Was this a face to be oppressed against warring winds?" laments Cordelia having rescued her father from the vicious storm and wild surviving. Edgar confronts Edmund: "The dark and vicious place where thee he got. Cost him his eyes". This confrontation by both Cordelia and Edgar of their fathers' fate implies that they believe it is harsh form of justice served to them. Their forgiveness, despite rejection from their fathers in the start of the play, reflects their explicit goodness. ...read more.

Conclusion

Lear calls the powerful to "feel what the wretches feel". Both of those characters are exploring their humanity to 'feel for others' rather than self pity in their suffocating survival. In effect they have achieved wisdom though only in extreme suffering had they chosen to realise. Shakespeare thus shows that humans are capable of restoring human justice if they choose to think beyond themselves and particularly when they are free of vices. Cordelia's death can be viewed as a sacrifice to eliminate her father's sins in biblical perspective. Assuming that Shakespeare intended her justice to be served in heaven, poetic justice to most characters portrays that the play employs some justice. However Shakespeare seems to emphasize the effect of choices humans take over their free will. The justice served seems to agree with Edgar's statement: "our pleasant vices make instruments to plague us" as even Gloucester, whom we see as a victim of flawed human justice, had actually committed adultery which reasons to his fate. Lear, Edmund, Cornwall, Oswald, Goneril and Regan who had committed to some form of vice have all served with 'cup of their deserving' referring to Albany's comment. The play could not have absolute justice served due to too many flaws in human justice and brutality. Albany and Edgar become new agents of justice at the end of the play showing that free will can overcome darkness and restore the light. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level King Lear section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level King Lear essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    The influence Act 1 has on the rest of the play in King Lear

    3 star(s)

    The ignorance explored here helps to express the lack of control Lear grows to have, as many times throughout the play we see him lose control, and then very quickly calm himself again:- 'Hear, Nature, hear! Dear Goddess, hear!'; Lear begins to get very angry, and ordering that everyone listens

  2. With particular reference to Act 1, Scene 1, show how Shakespeare presents the character ...

    This shows that Kent can see the truth, and that he knows that Cordelia is the only one that really loves him, even though Lear can't see this. Shakespeare has used Kent here to show that it is Lear who is being irrational and foolish, as it is only he who cannot see beyond Regan and Goneril's speeches.

  1. How does Shakespeare present Edmund in King Lear?

    Edmund perceives himself as a deity in a crumbling Britain, this is reiterated when he is talking about his conception, even before he was brought into the world he was better than the mundane birth of his peers. By being born because of the "lusty stealth of nature" it suggests

  2. To What Extent Can King Lear Be Described as the Tragic Hero of Shakespeares ...

    What is Lear's 'tragic flaw'? Aristotle developed the term hamartia to describe the fall of a noble man due to an error in his behavior. Lear's main flaw is his egotism, everything that happens to him stems from him wanting his daughters to publicly declare their love for him in return for a portion of his land.

  1. King Lear, Femininity and Female Disorder

    which signifies that she is an adulteress who is unfaithful to her conjugal pledge. Fortune is false to the oppressed subjects of England by endowing propitious lots to the undeserving and unfavorable lots to the good. Lady Justice or simply Justice is the Roman goddess of Justice.

  2. Compare and contrast madness: its possible causes; its manifestations; its consequences; and its resolution, ...

    The transformation of Edgar from noble to crazed beggar is a literal symbolization of this, but it is most powerfully observed in Lear, reduced to bestial qualities by suffering. He pleads despairingly to his own daughter ("on my knees I beg")

  1. The Nature of Redemption and the Limits of Pessimism in King Lear

    He now admits that Shakespeare?s universe is full of suffering (and therefore devoid of ?beauty?) and that the only thing capable of attaining goodness is the immaterial soul. While this might not constitute an outright contradiction, it is highly misleading.

  2. How does Shakespeare create a sense of unease in Act 1 Scene 1 of ...

    they appear unreasonable ?tyrants? to, as well as the fact that both do not recognise the true nature of their children. It is in the opening of the play that the recurrent theme of sight and blindness gets mentioned and eventually later goes on to play a significant part of King Lear.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work