• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

A review of James Berardinellis review of Chinatown

Extracts from this document...


´╗┐CHINATOWN. A REVIEW OF A REVIEW. BY BELLA SCOTT Preoccupied with genre, style and film history, James Berardinelli?s review of Chinatown fails to provide a meaningful analysis of the core structural elements of the film ? it?s themes and premise. Where his viewpoint is accurate he fails to support his claims with a convincing argument or adequate facts to substantiate it, resulting in an unconvincing and unpersuasive critique. Berardinelli fails to identify the key themes, barely acknowledging any of them at all. Briefly touching on corruption, he neglects to mention additional dominant themes regarding power, the search for truth, and human sexuality. The film explores the themes of corruption and power through the character of Noah Cross and his manipulation of authority and ultimately, an entire community. Cross? power is so all-pervasive and his corruption so complete that he is able to descend to the depths of sexual depravity without fear of consequence or care for ethicality. Largely neglected by Berardinelli is the search for truth - a recurring motif and theme throughout the film. ...read more.


The private investigator?s calm acceptance and casual air regarding the distress this causes one of his clients - ?don?t touch the Venetian blinds, I only got them in last week?, suggests there is a level of human frailty that he is un-phased by however, where he does draw the line is at deeper corruption. When he feels that he?s touched on the darker elements of human nature, the ?old cop? in him is provoked into action against injustice. Berardinelli does acknowledge that this aspect of Gittes? character is what ?separates him from the rest of the hard-boiled detectives?. What he doesn?t acknowledge is Gittes? journey, from profiting from common yet illicit behaviour to the unveiling of some of the darkest elements in human sexuality - rape and incest. According to writer of the screenplay, Robert Towne, rape is one of the major motifs in thefilm. And yet Berardinelli leaves this undiscussed. For Towne, ?incest was the subplot?, and not only does Cross rape his daughter, but he also commits the acts of ?raping the future?, and ?raping the land?. ...read more.


The ending of Chinatown feels fake and overly theatrical. With the full cast assembled for the final scene in an awkward and unbelievable mix of crass, contrived coincidences, it?s here that Polanski?s complete control and mastery of his craft descends into a dictatorial diatribe that reflects more on the nature of the man than on the harsher realities of life that he alluded to so artfully until this final act. It is a scene that is fatal for the heroine, for Gittes? hope for a more just world, and for the audience?s total abandonment to an otherwise sublimely immersive story. Despite these flaws, the conclusion is effective in cementing Polanski?s bleak, pessimistic vision of a world where the powerful will always prevail through their preparedness to break all the rules of decency that dictate how most of the hapless masses behave. In his statement regarding the conclusion, ?involving events that have nothing to do with the big picture?, Berardinelli couldn?t be further from the truth, nor further from expressing it eloquently. He acknowledges that the film ?works as both a mystery and an exploration of a deeper, more personal tragedy? but appears to miss it?s true meaning entirely. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Criticism & Comparison section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Criticism & Comparison essays

  1. Claudio in Much Ado About Nothing A Character Study of the Impulsive Lover in ...

    Claudio only saw Hero for a brief moment upon returning from the war, and immediately desires her. In the play, The only conversation Claudio and Hero had was at their wedding when he denounced her and made public her accusation of promiscuity.

  2. Compare the ways in which Philip Larkin and Carol Ann Duffy present the theme ...

    The verisimilitude of the ordinary urban scene also grants death a recognisable status, but at the same, Larkin demonstrates how death is inscrutable via the symbol of the ambulance: ?giving back none of the glances they absorb?, presenting the ambulance, and therefore, death as a mystery which provides no answers.

  1. Cold War Literature - the particular ways of thinking present throughout the Cold War ...

    Satire is used by George throughout the meetings of ?big bomb diplomacy? as leaders from East and West throw around moral questions of whether there is a difference in killing ?thirty millions or sixty millions?.

  2. In King Lear Shakespeare creates a morally chaotic world. How far and in what ...

    When required to bargain her love for rights over the kingdom, she comments ?I cannot heave my heart into my mouth?, portraying her honest nature. The idiom ?heart in your mouth?, which suggests nervousness or fear, demonstrates that Cordelia does not see any reason to fear losing the land, emphasising her lack of materialism and strong moral compass.

  1. "The Wave" book review

    Ben Ross knew he couldn't give them a good answer to that so he decides to show them, and plans an experiment. He starts to teach them dicipline introducing some rules, and seeing that his class react well to this he decides to take the experiment further.

  2. The exploration of Ghosts and Absence in Thomas Hardy's The Voice and The Haunted

    The bleak outlook onto life at this stage is continued in the final stanza with the use of ?leaves around me falling?. The sense of loss and absence with the rest of existence, or absense, is actualized to the reader of the poem by Hardy through pathetic fallacy.

  1. Shakespeares Hamlet, I would like to make a few remarks regarding the existential and ...

    He himself returns to Denmark, where an angry Laertes, the son of Polonius, meets him. Laertes challenges Hamlet to a duel to the death and decides to poison the tip of his rapier. Claudius ensures the outcome of the duel by poisoning the cup that Hamlet will fortify himself with during the fight.

  2. A well-known movie is Minority Report, which uses several themes from Oedipus the King.

    John Anderton is even blinded by his self-righteousness. The theme of blindness is evident in both these works, because it gives hint that the protagonist does not see how murder affects their lives. A second major theme in both works is prophecy. In these works, the protagonist receives prophecies about their futures.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work