• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Shakespeare is unable to present women other than as passive victims or deceivers of men With reference to the characters of Ophelia and Gertrude explore to what extent you agree with this statement.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

'Shakespeare is unable to present women other than as passive victims or deceivers of men" With reference to the characters of Ophelia and Gertrude explore to what extent you agree with this statement. It could be argued that Shakespeare constructs both Ophelia and Gertrude as weak, powerless and vulnerable in contrast to the powerful men around them. At the same time however, he is also reflecting women's social position at the time through these characters, so his view is something that would be traditional for the audience. In the actual play, their roles are minor compared to those of Hamlet, Claudius or Polonius. Throughout the play, Shakespeare uses Hamlet to undermine their position in society. For example, he says 'Frailty thy name is woman' 1, thus equating womankind with the attribute of frailty. Both Gertrude and Ophelia are overshadowed by the male characters, with no voice of their own, as Shakespeare uses them to recreate the position of women in Elizabethan times, which was basically that of a 'maid, wife, or widow, with whores alone outside of the stereotype.'2 Hamlet not only treats both his mother and Ophelia as inferior human beings, but also introduces another stereotype of 'whore' when talking about his mother, making him a complete misogynist. Women in Elizabethan times were seen as inferior in comparison to men and this is shown in 'Hamlet' through Ophelia and Gertrude. ...read more.

Middle

This shows that Polonius considers his daughter's love story with Hamlet to be of a commercial, materialistic nature and not of true loving feelings. Again, this shows the lack of consideration towards his daughter's feelings. Further on in the play, in Act 3, Scene 1, Hamlet carries on insulting Ophelia but she is unable to answer back with anything other than monosyllabic, obedient phrases, like 'At home, my Lord'13. Shakespeare's construction of Ophelia's language, through end-stopped lines and monosyllabic words is a reflection of her position at the time and shows just how little she is allowed to say. End-stopped lines suggest that she is constantly being cut short by Hamlet who does not give her the chance to speak properly. Shakespeare presents Hamlet as a misogynist, as he criticizes Ophelia strongly, calling her a 'breeder of sinners'14. Shakespeare uses a crude choice of words when Hamlet starts 'ranting' at her, but Ophelia on the other side is shown to really care for Hamlet, believing his 'antic disposition'. This is shown by the use of prose for when he speaks instead of blank verse, and it leads her to thinking that he has gone insane, as we see when she constantly pleads for help for him, 'O heavenly powers, restore him'15 However, although in my opinion Ophelia is shown to be weak and powerless, as she is not allowed to have a voice of her own, it could be said that her short, obedient responses in Act 1, Scene 3 are actually sarcastic and witty remarks. ...read more.

Conclusion

It is ironic that the one time she disobeys a man, unexpected in those days, it leads to her death, showing perhaps that women making their own decisions could lead to tragic consequences. Gertrude is also shown to be emotional and delicate when dealing with tragic situations, unlike Claudius who is shown to be unable to deal with Hamlet's 'antic disposition'. She describes Ophelia's suicide in a poetic and lyrical way, where images are used to enrich emotional force and intensify the poignancy, 'glassy stream...fantastic garlands... mermaid-like...melodious lay'22. This shows Gertrude in a different light, the complete opposite to what the 'combatants' in the play -the ghost, Hamlet and Claudius- see her as: a malleable, submissive sexual object. Overall, Shakespeare does present both Ophelia and Gertrude as weak and dependant on men, as neither of them have the chance to express their own voice. However, this was the common view of women at the time, so this presentation, which at first strikes a modern audience as misogynist, could simply be a reflection of women's position during the Elizabethan era. Ophelia, who is initially constructed as pure and virginal has to then suffer due to Hamlet's stereotyping towards his mother, considering her a whore and a prostitute for her behaviour after her husband's death. Ophelia's reputation is tarnished due to Gertrude's apparent incestuous attitude and in consequence, her position is undermined even more, leading to her descent into madness and eventual suicide. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Hamlet section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Hamlet essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Explore the "loving mother-son" relationship between Gertrude and Hamlet, with focus on language.

    4 star(s)

    ...O speak to me no more; these words like daggars enter my ears; No more, sweet Hamlet! (III.iv.94-6) The 's' sound here stresses on Gertrude's sorrow and her shame at what she has unknowingly done. In the closet scene where Hamlet finally confronts his mother, we gain a new insight

  2. Marked by a teacher

    Explore the way Shakespeare presents the relationships between Hamlet and his Mother, Gertrude, making ...

    4 star(s)

    is 'Old' Hamlet, and that the queen has offended him, obviously through the marrying of Claudius and sleeping with him too. The Queen had summoned Hamlet to scold him, but on her own territory he deliberately mocks the rhythm and the word of her reprimands, turning the finger of accusation from his own behaviour to his mothers!

  1. Examine Hamlet's Relationship with Gertrude & Ophelia in light of the comment 'Frailty thy ...

    within these two hours', and speaks of 'country matters' crudely to Ophelia. Hamlet is thinking about the way his mother has acted and as he cannot confront her he offends Ophelia. Even though it is not suggested that Gertrude connived at her husband's murder, but by marrying Claudius she is

  2. Scene by Scene - Hamlet.

    I can't make sense out of this in the present context.) In our world, even being beautiful drives people to be dishonest. Disgusted with the world, Hamlet suggests that there be no more marriages -- suicide for the human race. Ophelia thinks Hamlet, who she admired so much, is crazy.

  1. Hamlet - One student said she sympathised most with Gertrude and Ophelia because they ...

    "I shall obey, my lord." This shows just how overpowered Ophelia is by the men in her life. Throughout the play we learn nothing of Ophelia's feelings towards Hamlet and she is very compromising towards her brother and father. In Act three scene one Ophelia meets Hamlet and tries to return gifts that Hamlet had previously given her.

  2. Free essay

    'Frailty Thy Name is Woman' How does Shakespeare present women and sex in Hamlet?

    Hamlet stated 'Frailty, thy name is woman,' he refers to by his mother, Gertrude, being a woman, she displays moral frailty in being vulnerable to the act of seduction by Claudius. This provides the audience with a model of women's infidelity in Hamlet.

  1. 'Hamlet has been read by critics as dramatically presenting a misfit in a politically ...

    He uses human bait to tempt Hamlet and capture him like an animal. In my reading, Hamlet's conclusion, 'But break, my heart, for I must hold my tongue' signifies Hamlet's isolation within the court and one can sympathise with his situation as one can imagine and see in Hamlet's confusion the emotional impact upon him.

  2. A consideration of the extent to which, in Hamlet's soliloquies, Hamlet is presented by ...

    However, Hamlet's duty to the monarchy and his role in society are in direct conflict with his duty as a son. Hamlet's duty to the monarchy is to protect the King and his role in society as a Prince is to ensure stability in the kingdom.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work