• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Alice Walkers depiction of men in The Color Purple has been controversial - Explore the opinions of the two critics printed below and explain your own view of the way Walker presents men in The Colour Purple.

Extracts from this document...


Alice Walkers depiction of men in The Color Purple has been controversial. Explore the opinions of the two critics printed below and explain your own view of the way Walker presents men in The Colour Purple. In The Color Purple, Alice Walker's depiction of men has been seen by some as controversial. Walker seems to be attacking black men because of their mistreatment of black women. Although, there is another force at work in this powerful, and emotional, book. That force is the unwitting testimony which Walker cannot control, because it was not deliberately written to be part of her story. Between the lines of her story is the strong message of personal rage: rage which cannot be hidden. The rage can be seen throughout the novel in numerous forms; the words used by Walker, that are strong and emotive; the portrayal of the characters, from innocent, like Celie, to evil, like Mr. Alphonso and the realism in which the characters are brought to life, because of the real anger used to describe them. Therefore, in considering the opinions of the two opposing critics, this circumstance must be borne in mind. The first critic, Tony Brown, wrote an article about The Color Purple for the Carolina Peacemaker. He has many views on the book, and expresses those views confidently. Brown admits in his article that some men have raped their daughters, "...some black men have raped their daughters," However, immediately afterwards, he is stating his defence of black men. ...read more.


In my opinion, the men in The Color Purple presented during anger, Walker's anger when writing. Therefore, the presentation of men is biased. Personally speaking, I think the depiction of men in the novel is true; that is, all aspects of the male personality are represented by Walker's characters, from kindness in Reverend Mr (Samuel) to brutal cruelty, seen in Albert. The way in which Walker writes, with such conviction and passion about her characters makes the depiction true, it cannot be fained. The slightly biased view on the male characters in the novel is so because Walker only shows two good black, male characters; Samuel and Harpo. Harpo cares deeply for his family, and loves them sincerely, but his sensitivity causes him to be dominated over by his wife. Samuel does so much to help Nettie; he takes her in after Albert's assault on her. He educates her, shows her new and exciting places abroad. The marriage between Samuel and Corrine also knows no cruelty, no violence or sexual abuse. This example is compared to several other male characters that are portrayed as raging, unprincipled creatures. An example of a raging, unprincipled creature, as shown by Walker, would be Mr. Alphonso, he rapes his own step-daughter, on more than one occasion, and then when Celie gave birth to two children, he gave them away. This was not the act of a decent human being. The characters can be described as raging, unprincipled creatures for many reasons. ...read more.


Arguably, this may be because the view at the time was that women were only seen as being good for the completion of household work, and were seen as lesser class citizens by men. Some critics have also criticised Celie for being pacifistic, as she doesn't attempt to retaliate to the beatings she receives. In opposition, Maroula Joannou states that, "To criticise her for her passivity is to do so in ignorance of fear which male violence produces in women." Lorraine Gamman concurs, saying that towards the end of the novel, Celie has become, "...empowered to reject the role of passive victim..." Even though the view is biased, I believe that if there were more good characters in the novel, like Samuel, then the message that is in the book would be diluted, and would therefore be of a lesser quality than to what it is. As the anonymous critic argued, the novel is about black women, not about black men; they are but devices in the book which make the plot more substantiated and realistic for the reader. Take for example Harpo, he gives realism to the novel because he shows the reader an image of a man that can be dominated by a woman, even though he tries in vain to be malicious towards Sofia, he just fails, abysmally, and ends up being beaten savagely by Sofia. "...it Harpo and Sofia. They fighting like two mens." Even though the book has caused controversy between both of the sexes, Walker's message has been superbly delivered, in this hard hitting realistic novel that gives a moving account of the struggle that some black women had to endure, yet, happily, triumphed through. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Alice Walker section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Here's what a teacher thought of this essay

4 star(s)

Some excellent and thought-provoking ideas are brought up in this essay, in particular the well researched alternative readings of the critics. These quotes could have been analysed and commented on more deeply and at times the essay is too simplistic in its arguments. Both sides of the argument could have been looked at in more depth.

Marked by teacher Katie Dixon 29/04/2012

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Alice Walker essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Explore Walkers Portrayal of Female Identity - The Color Purple

    4 star(s)

    Mr ___, claims Celie is "nothing at all". Despite this abuse Celie has the courage to carry on and live her life despite its restrictions. Walker uses each character to reflect all the different elements of female identity. Celie is portrayed as weak, Sophia is portrayed as powerful, Nettie educated and Shug leads the glamorous life every women dreams of.

  2. What are the main themes of Pleasantville and how does the director convey them ...

    This is a very striking scene and goes a long way to show how the people of Pleasantville have been liberated as Bud and Margaret laugh and wonder at the petals, as apposed to abstaining from it's beauty. The juxtaposition between black and white here is also significant because it shows how things are changing.

  1. Explore how the Film 'Cool Runnings' Utilises Colour Imagery.

    The contrast between Jamaica and Canada is shown very effectively in juxtaposition. You see the plane take off amidst warm golden earthy colours, and you see it touch down amongst sharp silvery blues. You also see this beautiful palm tree in Jamaica which is replaced by an equally beautiful conifer in Canada.

  2. Gender roles in The Color Purple.

    Many Southern women were left with virtually no chance of succeeding outside of their designated role as the husband's maid. In addition, women who lived on the farm normally had little contact with people outside their families; and therefore, were limited to jobs centered on the farm such as spinning,

  1. "Inconceivable" by Ben Elton - book review.

    He was paid �15 every time he performed his comedy routine, and soon became one of the regular performers. At first his stand-up performances were just to showcase his own work, but from there he wrote and acted in television, wrote novels and plays and now screenplays; while still performing his stand-up comedy.

  2. Examine the author's presentation of men, women and gender roles in 'The Color Purple' ...

    The father works early shifts and has no drastic contribution to her life. This is portrayed through the time the father goes to bed, "my father had already gone to bed because he worked early shifts." Overall, immediately I come to conclude that, both fathers in both the novels are presented negatively, in different ways.

  1. Free essay

    The text The Color Purple, in both the novel by Alice Walker and the ...

    The film, however, begins with direct contrasts to this, with the two sisters laughing and playing clapping games in a beautiful field of purple, Celie's pregnancy not revealed until she steps out to meet 'Pa' in which the light music stops abruptly.

  2. Between Ourselves and Joebell and America The stories are quite different apart from the ...

    I think that Earl Lovelace has written this brilliantly, when I first read it I did not notice it, it was like looking at someone doing something then the next minute you are in that persons brain, the effect of this is emphasised because it is at a extremely crucial

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work