• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Analyse and comment on the differences and similarities of the ways in which the two movie versions of "of mice and men" portray the events and characters.

Extracts from this document...


"Of Mice And Men" Media Coursework By Bernard Prelec Analyse and comment on the differences and similarities of the ways in which the two movie versions of "of mice and men" portray the events and characters. When we watch a film we are caught up in the story that it is telling and accept everything that happens on the screen as natural. In fact everything that we see has been carefully chosen and edited on the screen and within the actual storyline to have an effect on the watching audience. The camera is moved and people and objects are positioned in the frame; what people wear is carefully chosen and the settings are selected and prepared. Because of our experiences of films seen at the cinema or on television we have some expectations about what happens in the film, we expect to know what happens next, we expect a climax and an ending. The filmmaker also shapes what we think is going to happen by the opening sequence. The filmmaker has a number of ways to help the film such as costumes lighting cameras and props the audiences position in the film will depend on the way the filmmaker tells us the story In this assignment I am going to analyse and comment on the two movie versions of "Of mice and men". ...read more.


An example is when Carlson shoots Candy's old dog, and Candy lies down on the bed and tosses and turns in pain. In the movie, I actually felt sympathetic for Curley's wife since she seemed to always be the victim. This is something I had not felt in the book. Also, the very last scene when George shoots Lennie and then he starts to cry. In many ways the movie is very similar to the book. Right from the beginning of the movie you can see that Lennie has a mental illness, and George is taking care of him like a father. Also, you can tell that George gets impatient with Lennie numerous times and that he gets frustrated very easily. George and Lennie hide in the cornfield during this version of the film when they are escaping from the posse of men on horses with dogs, which are hunting them down. Also in the first movie George leaves unlike the novel we see Lennie being left behind and looking lonely, after George walks around he comes back to where he left Lennie. In the modern movie it starts off with George and Lennie being chased by the pose with horses and dogs, while this is happening while dramatic music is ...read more.


I thought this also and thought it was symbolism of how things don't change. As he finds Lennie the tension builds up and we are reminded what has happened, that Lennie is in a lot of trouble. As George approaches we can hear the posse just like the start and we think they are about to run away. But when George shoots Lennie while he is looking away we are very shocked as we didn't see him get a gun, and only just realised now what has to be done which is better than in the old movie which lacks suspense and drama. This suspense is what the film director is trying to bring to us, the audience, unlike the book an audience watching a film will enjoy it more if every scene is a surprise. In the movie versions the storyline is shortened and only the necessary scenes are added to the film including the most dramatic scenes, which capture the mood of the film, this is a carefully edited sequence, which has been planned in detail over time to get the point across and generate a genuine effect on the audience. This is done because unlike a book a movie only has approximately 15 min to attract the viewer rather than a book which could take 50 pages. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level John Steinbeck section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level John Steinbeck essays

  1. Peer reviewed

    'Of Mice and Men' - The killing of candy's old dog foreshadowed Lennie's death. ...

    3 star(s)

    In my opinion it was the most human way, as he never really felt any pain.

  2. Of Mice and Men - The differences between the book and the film.

    The scene with Curley's wife and George is inserted into the film. This works because we learn more about George's character. He has never had a girlfriend because of his job, relating to the migrant worker myth. George appears to be attracted to Curley's wife, which opens up the story further and makes her death more tragic.

  1. Of Mice and Men: Alternative ending for the final chapter.

    "What if Curley..." "What if Curley what?" "What if he got jumpy and whacked one of us?" "Again, a risk we gotta take, now enough of the what if's lets do this thing," said George. "Yeah! Lets do it," they all said in unison.

  2. Of Mice and Men diary entry

    Just as I walked out onto the dusty road, just as I had given up all hope of a job and settling down with a nice piece of land, the peaceful afternoon was shattered by a loud dull thud. My reflex reaction was to turn towards the noise at once,

  1. Do you think that the ending to 'Of Mice and Men' is satisfactory?

    None of them have anyone, this is a real problem of the times. The people on the ranch are all jealous of George and Lennie. They are firstly suspicious that George is taking Lennies pay cheque but then they envy the bond between them.

  2. The Killing of Candy’s Old Dog For Foreshadowed Lennie’s death. Describe the two killings ...

    Candy found Curley's wife dead and told George first. George told Candy to tell the rest of the ranch guys. Curley was the most furious to find his wife dead and went to kill Lennie with the rest of the ranch guys. Carlson told the ranch people that Lennie stole his lugar but they didn't now it was George.

  1. Of Mice and Men - Full Summary and Analysis

    George retains hope for a middle-class life; the speech that he recites to Lennie about owning a small farm together remains palpable for George, despite the hard circumstances that he now faces. Lennie, in contrast, demonstrates none of the despair and rationality that marks George, partially because his mental disability

  2. Steinbeck uses many techniques to present the characters of Lennie and George in Of ...

    George who shot him in an act of compassion showed mercy and care. The tension Steinbeck builds in the last chapter, shows how troubled and vulnerable George became and eased Lennie of torture and pain to come. ?George shivered and looked at the gun? as the tough impression of George

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work