• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Analysing the representation of speech: Texts A and B are both similar texts in that they have the same purpose to try and change peoples views on animal rights.

Extracts from this document...


AS English Language and Literature Assignment 5 ? Analysing the representation of speech: comparison Texts A and B are both similar texts in that they have the same purpose ? to try and change peoples? views on animal rights. However, the ideas are conveyed in two different styles. In text A, Brigitte Bardot demonstrates the reality of how many animals are treated these days. The text is written in a serious manner and the author gets straight to the point by using very strong, vivid vocabulary which is shown in the first sentence: ?Who has given Man (a word which has tragically lost all its humanity) the right to exterminate, to dismember, to cut up, to slaughter, to hunt, to chase, to trap, to lock up, to martyr, to enslave and to torture the animals?? Here she uses a continuation of descriptive verbs which attracts the readers attention and shows them just a few of the many ways animals are treated. Brigitte Bardot is fighting for equality between humans and animals so that the earth is no longer a place ?where men rule?, but ?a shared Paradise.? The middle paragraphs in this text all end in ?(for our survival ?)?. ...read more.


She is asking for people?s help ?to act, high time? and ?to regain the dignity the animals have never lost?. Text B is written as a conversation between two individuals, with the use of slang language. The text has been made to show not only the grammar and vocabulary that the people use, but also the way in which they speak (pauses, elongation, etc.). This gives the reader an idea of the age of these two individuals ? they are possibly quite young adults. ?R? and ?J? have two very different opinions on animal rights: ?J? believes that being vegetarian will help to stop the ?industrialised butchery that cows an sheep an chickens have to endure?. However ?R? thinks that you being vegetarian won?t help anything ? if you eat free range meat it?s fine. He believes that meat is what we were born to eat: ?our teeth are designed to rip an check meat an all that?. He uses very visual language here to get his point across. He does believe though, that the animals shouldn?t have to endure such horrid conditions. ...read more.


He is a young person who doesn?t come across as having an awfully strong personality. I can see people really responding to Brigitte Bardot?s speech as it will have certainly got them thinking, and anyone who cares about the animals will want to assist her in solving the problems which they face. This is a strong piece of work. GOOD POINTS: Clear and sustained focus on the question with a strong comparative element. You clearly identify similarities in content but contrasts in style. A good overview at the opening of an answer is very reassuring to an examiner. You embed your quotations clearly so that they support your argument. Remember quotations should be as short and therefore as focussed as possible. Each needs to be integrated into the flow of your argument. You correctly identify and more importantly analyse key patterns of language use and their effects in representing the authors' points of view. You clearly represent and evidence your conclusions on the charaters behind the voices and their social and political motivations. Your work is concise, fluent and economical without being brief. All are excellent examination qualities. Therefore, apart from some minutiae eg Para 3 'number' for 'amount' I have very little to correct. Annabel Pomeroy Student Number SS126208 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Language: Context, Genre & Frameworks section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Language: Context, Genre & Frameworks essays

  1. Peer reviewed

    Investigation into the Judgements of Slang

    4 star(s)

    However, an interesting question is whether the specific lexical items used have a direct relationship with the judgments made. If we look back to the previous analysis of the speakers' vocabulary, and assume that specific lexical items do have a relationship with the judgements made, we would be led to

  2. A one to one interaction with an elderly woman Aunty Emily to try through ...

    EFFECTIVENESS OF INTERACTION WEAKNESSES AND HOW I COULD IMPROVE IT QUESTIONING: I felt like the questions I asked even though most were opened questions didn't lead to exactly what my mission was such as trying to persuade her to help and fix in a hot tap.

  1. Examine the representation of WAGs in a range of Newspaper articles.

    If they are in the same category, this suggests that they share the same representation. In text A, wags were represented as gold-diggers who were inferior to everyone else, so WOWs could now share this representation. The subordinate embedded clause "Wives Of Wimbledon" is used to elaborate what a WOW is.

  2. Investigation into representation of gender through speech

    minimal response * self-repair Limitations of the investigation * Small sample size: it would be more accurate if there were more groups sampled (not larger groups, as the participants would have fewer opportunities to speak) * Sometimes the participants needed prompting which of course distorts the course of the conversation,

  1. Creative writing and commentary. It was the year 2015 and Earth was exploring ...

    They went up the travelator leading to the door of the shuttle and walked inside, it was nothing like they had ever seen before. It was about four times the size of an aeroplane; the seats were large leather reclining chairs with plenty of leg space in front of them

  2. Society, the Press and the Medias Views on Todays Youth

    Also, when alcohol is mentioned, a result of the crime is usually said shortly after - "driver drunk," "deadly," "boozy bash," "jail time," "underage thinking." The tone of the article is depressing as the death of youth is compared to a party - a huge contrast: "On their way back to the party...

  1. Analysis of 3 texts on Childhood

    In contrast, the father?s steadfast refusal of his son?s request is seen in the negative adverbs (?no?, ?not?, ?neither?), while his annoyance at his son can be seen in his expression ?for God?s sake?. In terms of syntax, text A as transcribed speech is organised in adjacency pairs, with question and answer pairs (?d?you wanna cup of coffee erm (.)

  2. Analysis of 3 texts on Family

    her grandparents? view of her father and their approval of him, showing the easy relationship present between them. Because A is an autobiographical speech, Louise?s utterances are predominantly in the declarative form (?I am from er mixed race background?, ?He pretty much taught ma mum to to cook?).

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work