• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Arthur Miller has been praised for his realistic dialogue. How realistic do you think All My Sons(TM) is?

Extracts from this document...


Arthur Miller has been praised for his realistic dialogue. How realistic do you think 'All My Sons' is? Throughout the play 'All My Sons' Arthur Miller does create a fairly realistic dialogue on which to base the play. There is nothing that could be argued to be completely out of the ordinary about the play and to a certain extent all of the content is believable due to the fact that the play itself is wholly about a family that, to begin with seems to be the typical 'happy' family and as the play continues the audience sees them digress, and many secrets are revealed that show them to not be the happy family that was first seen as there are many cracks that appear in their relationships between one another. There is nothing unrealistic about this idea as it is like many families that keep secrets and perhaps are not completely successful in hiding them, and one day they come back to cause a fatal downfall to the family in question. ...read more.


Throughout the play there are various references to the relationships between the family members, for example, how Chris feels towards his father before and after he finds out what Keller did during the war. The reaction of Chris is that of a realistic one. This is because, all through the play Chris is described as having a 'star of one's honesty' and when he finds out about Keller's actions he does not want to be disloyal to his father as he is described, from the very beginning of the play to have 'immense affection and loyalty', however, Chris also knows that the right thing to do is to turn his father in so that Keller's partner can be released from jail. This is a realistic dilemma that any son would face in this situation, after being so close to their father, and then having to decide between their welfare or that of another innocent man. ...read more.


This could be taken as a fairly melodramatic thing to say, Chris knew that Keller had a business and needed to work and produce to get money for his family, and for Chris to say this to him, could be taken as perhaps a fairly childish thing to say. Another perhaps unrealistic idea within the play is the suicide that occurs, Larry, Keller and the possibility that perhaps Chris may also want to kill himself, the is suggested when he goes out for a drive and does not return for a while and his mother begins to worry. This all seems very dramatic as even in the situation, suicide seems perhaps slightly over the top, thus causing it to be slightly unrealistic. In conclusion, although there are a few over dramatic and slightly unrealistic things about the dialogue in 'All My Sons' Arthur Miller does manage to produce a relatively realistic play as there are only small amounts that could be criticised to be unlikely and therefore, to state that, 'Arthur Miller has been praised for his realistic dialogue' would be a correct admiration to make. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Arthur Miller section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Arthur Miller essays

  1. Chris' Character - Father-Son Relationship - All My Sons is considered Miller's most famous ...

    to his mother and Ann that his idealism had left him and that he has now become a practical man who does not have the courage to force his father to face the consequences of his guilt. He further affirms them that he is no longer "human" and that his now like every body else.

  2. Joe Keller is a tragic hero

    For example, in Miller's "The Shadow of Gods", Miller expressly refers to the father son conflict: "I think now it was because of the father son conflict, but something more. It is always probing beyond its particular scenes and characters for the hidden laws, for the place where the gods

  1. How Does Arthur Miller create dramatic tension in A View from the Bridge(TM)?

    It is important that this makes Eddie feel powerless. Marco's character appears passive for a large amount of the play but we can see that he is neutral as long as Eddie does not interfere with his family or their in America. Only at these occasions does Marco stand up against Eddie, we see an explosion of Marco's stress towards Eddie when they are taken by the immigration officers.

  2. Quotes from All My Sons

    The boy is coming. Be smart" p126 Repetion-Shows that she wants to manipulate George "(frightened at the thought you can't say that to her)" p99 Shows she is a difficult character to understand and is neurotic as even her husband and son don't know how she's going to react "He

  1. Which character in All My Sons(TM) suffers the most?

    When Chris recounts his experiences in the war to Ann, he delivers one of the most striking and engaging speeches 'All My Sons' offers. Since he has come back from the war he feels that it felt wrong to live his comfortable life because there is "blood" on everything he

  2. Analyse the dramatic effectiveness of the opening to ‘Death of a Salesman’ by Arthur ...

    Confuting this, Willy had an affair with a woman he met on a business trip and was caught by Biff. This reveals Willy's character to be unfaithful, back stabbing and untrustworthy. Despite this Linda puts all this behind her. Willy is a failure who doesn't achieve the 'American Dream' and disbelieves his sons are failures too.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work