• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

By looking at 'Birches' and 'Out, Out-' by Robert Frost, compare and contrast the ways in which the poet conveys the theme of childhood.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Robert Frost spent most of his life living in the countryside of New England in America and had personal experience in the rural lifestyle. In the poems "Out, Out-" and "Birches", we are given insights to two very different aspects of childhood in the rural countryside - the harsh, burdened, laborious side in one and the carefree, joyful, exultant side in the other. We are also made aware of the universal brevity of childhood and life in general. In "Out, Out-", the speaker seems omniscient and detached from the other characters in the poem. He narrates the tragic story of a poor boy whose childhood is deprived of the freedom and carelessness he ought to have. We can see how much the boy longs for freedom from the lines "To please the boy by giving him the half hour That a boy counts so much when saved from work." - he knows how precious those carefree moments are and appreciates them but cannot have them. The narrative way in which the poem is told shows the reader how unfortunate other people's childhood can be. ...read more.

Middle

- and that ended it." There is the grim reality of life going on and the family in the poem also realizes this and so "...turned to their affairs." The vulnerability of childhood is clearly portrayed and the forced acceptance evokes sympathy for both the boy and the family. In "Birches" it is a more light-hearted acceptance of the fact that childhood will always end and there is no going back, but the speaker doesn't regret it as he had lived it to the full. The whole poem has a tone of reminiscence as the speaker is telling his own childhood memories with a sense of fondness. The difference in the tones present to us the different ways people experience childhood. Frost uses simple, mostly monosyllabic language in both poems. This gives us a feel of the innocence and simplicity of childhood. The use of colloquial language also enables us to understand the universality of childhood experiences. Enjambments give a sense of the continuous and cyclical nature of life and is used both poems alongside caesural pauses which serve different purposes. ...read more.

Conclusion

In "Birches" it can signify the child's rhythmic swinging from the birch trees and gives a sense of freedom. This simple rhythm parallels also with the simplicity of the language and therefore echoes the universal straightforwardness and naivety of childhood, no matter whether it's burdened with work or careless and full of play. The poems are all dramatic monologues. The speaker tells the story by himself but it's very different in that in "Out, Out-" he is telling the story of another boy but in "Birches" he is remembering his own childhood. In "Out, Out-" this allows the reader to conjure up their own feelings and emotions and the lack of the boy's own point of view gives us a sense of his helplessness. In "Birches" the monologue helps the reader to understand and relate to themselves the wonders of childhood since the speaker is talking about his own experiences - "...I once myself a swinger of birches" - and we can easily conjure up memories of our own. These two poems give two completely contrasting aspects of childhood. It's difficult to compare them as the contents are so different but I think that "Birches" is a much more enjoyable read with its vibrant imagery and more positive tone. ?? ?? ?? ?? Chuer Zhang ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Robert Frost section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Robert Frost essays

  1. Write a Critical Appreciation of 'Birches'.

    The double alliteration and heavy vowel sounds in the phrase: 'So low for so long', creates a further depressing outlook.

  2. The Relationship Between Man and Nature in the poems of Robert Frost and R.S. ...

    Don't just dream about it." The Evacuee - R. S. Thomas. This poem is about a young girl that has been evacuated from her home during the war, as it was too dangerous for her to stay there. She wakes up in the morning, and is frightened.

  1. How does Robert Frost use rural imagery to suggest life's journey?

    as yellow is a bright colour but also indecisive which maintains his idea of uncertainty with the problem he is faced. In line 3 he tells us 'long I stood' showing he spends along time contemplating on which route to take it isn't a spontaneous decision also, if the road

  2. Poets often use nature imagery to comment on the relationship between humans and the ...

    (Frost 410) The birches are representative of the childhood innocence that is conveyed by the speaker. Frost's trees are white, a colour that is traditionally associated with purity and youth and they also serve as a metaphor for the aging process.

  1. Analyse The Woodpile and compare the language and themes to other Frosts poems.

    Secondly, the reader can see that the man made objects-the stake and the prop that were originally put there to support the woodpile are falling over, and that nature is supporting the woodpile now, firstly from a plant wrapped

  2. Free essay

    Fros's peorty is more about people than nature. Discuss

    overwhelming sense of duty, and perhaps guilt, He would prefer to watch the snow falling in the woods, even with his horse's impatience, but he has "promises to keep," and obligations that he cannot ignore even though temporarily he expresses his desire to so.

  1. Compare and contrast 2 or more anthologies. Consider the principles and preferences which ...

    It is a positive book that is written to put a smile on the readers face. I believe that it can be read when feeling down and can be there to cheer the reader up.

  2. Closely analyse the poems 'Sacifice' by Taufiq Rafat and 'Out, Out' by Robert Frost. ...

    I think that the explanation mark at the end shows the shock and the response of the poet. When the poet writes 'The movement is a little unsteady' this stands out for me because as well as him being nervous I would be too if I had to kill any animal.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work