• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

'Cleopatra is often interpreted as the designing woman who brings down a worthy soldier and ruler, but this view is simplistic.' How do you, in the 21st century, respond to Shakespeare's dramatic presentation of Cleopatra?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

'Cleopatra is often interpreted as the designing woman who brings down a worthy soldier and ruler, but this view is simplistic.' How do you, in the 21st century, respond to Shakespeare's dramatic presentation of Cleopatra? Cleopatra can only be described as 'designing' when her character is examined on an entirely superficial level. Beyond the obvious fluctuations in mood and volatile behaviour she exhibits throughout the play, there lies an intensely vulnerable and accessible woman, more so than ever to a modern audience. She is, in a sense, a woman well ahead of her times, both that of the Imperial Roman Empire and that of James I in which she was originally portrayed. Her volatility, particularly in the early stages of the play, is easily misconstrued as a Machiavellian tendency to manipulate for the satisfaction of her own whims. On first experience of the play, her request of Antony to 'tell me how much' he loves her seems foolish, even embarrassing, a public taunting of an important man. However, on subsequent re-examination, when the depth of her feeling for Antony (particularly in her anguish at his death) has been demonstrated, her 'taunting' gains another dimension. This question is more than trivial to her, however she might behave; she needs his reassurance. ...read more.

Middle

There is a sense of the hindsight granted by age and the comparison between relationships current and former, the latter seeming now like a mistake. It is principally in this way that I believe Cleopatra is more relevant to modern audiences than to Jacobean society. The idea of a female leader would be, after the reign of Elizabeth I, relatively unsurprising; however, women were still regarded as the property of men. It is not hard to see why a modern career woman, having gone through several relationships of her own, would find more to relate to in Cleopatra than would a Jacobean housewife. Women in the 21st century hold a much more three dimensional position than those of Shakespeare's time. They were considered then unsuitable for the stage, replaced instead by 'some squeaking Cleopatra boy' playing Cleopatra 'i'th'posture of a whore'. Female sexuality in Jacobean times was considered, as written by Penny Gay, to be 'voraciously overwhelming', and since Cleopatra embodies that idea to the core, she would have seemed a dangerous character indeed to her first audiences. Then, she was a strange, exotic creature and an unknown quantity, but her character inspires altogether more empathy in more modern performances. In her portrayal by Judi Dench at the National Theatre in 1987, her suicide represented a 'grand resignation' as opposed to a dark, frenzied retreat; her attachment to Anthony was 'pathetically touching'. ...read more.

Conclusion

Together, Antony and Cleopatra rise above pragmatism and politics, and it is small wonder that they stun even Octavius, or that he should be moved by 'a pair so famous'. I think it would be a dire injustice to call Cleopatra 'designing' and blame her for Antony's political downfall; it reduces her feverish passion, her wild hedonism and the staggering extent of her love to plotting, cunning and cruelty. To me, she represents a woman of enormous courage, in her leadership but also in her refusal to compromise on emotions, however unreasonable or dramatic they might be. She is foolish, yes, but never a coward; her flight from Actium is not desertion but evidence of military inexperience and genuine fear. Her love for Antony is beyond the ordinary, it is beyond Caesar and Octavia, and how could the play be so poignant a 'tragedy' were that not so? The very sadness of Antony & Cleopatra is in the fact that the two lovers can only triumph beyond the grave, in the death of love for the pursuit of politics; an unworthy substitution if ever there was one. Cleopatra is no Iago, she has none of his manipulative malice; she is nothing more or less than a woman passionately and shamelessly in love. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Antony and Cleopatra section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Here's what a teacher thought of this essay

5 star(s)

It is evident here how a thoughtful title can help to give an essay structure and direction. The writer has given a lively and sophisticated response to a well-phrased question. The particular strengths of the essay lie in its sense of personal engagement with the text, and its ability to mount a persuasive argument, effectively backed up by textual reference. Perhaps the essay loses its focus at one point, and it would benefit from more extensive use of quotation, but overall this is excellent work.
*****

Marked by teacher Val Shore 25/02/2012

Here's what a star student thought of this essay

5 star(s)

Response to the question

This is an excellent and technical essay with a very strong understanding of alternative interpretations and a good grasp of context, and it only needs minor improvements to its style and tone. The quote in the question contains the phrase ...

Read full review

Response to the question

This is an excellent and technical essay with a very strong understanding of alternative interpretations and a good grasp of context, and it only needs minor improvements to its style and tone. The quote in the question contains the phrase "often interpreted", which means the student needs to address alternative interpretations of Cleopatra. The student goes on to do this well: by saying things such as "This could quite easily be seen as...", they are showing that they understand that nothing is certain when interpreting a text. (In this particular play, it is a good idea to pick up on what this student is arguing here, which is that several things Cleopatra says could be seen as melodramatic, or alternatively could be seen as genuine. When studying this play, I found that this set of opposing interpretations were applicable to many things Cleopatra says. Are her emotional outbursts attention-seeking, or is true sensitivity shining through?)

The student takes this further by using quotes from other people who have written about the text - for example, "as written by Penny Gay..." - which is excellent, as it not only shows a developed understanding of the need for alternative interpretations, but it shows that the student has read widely around the subject. Furthermore, references to different portrayals of Cleopatra - such as "of Janet Suzman" - show that the student understands how different interpretations can affect audience reactions. The student's response to the question is enhanced even more by the way they quote words from the question in their answer: for example, "There is no 'design' to her" shows that the student has engaged so well with the question that they can answer specific parts of it as well as on the whole.

Level of analysis

The student's use of technical vocabulary - "hyperbolic", for example - is excellent because it shows they have a strong understanding of what is used to create a text, rather than a vague idea. "Hyperbolic" in particular sounds better because it is a word that is largely specific to literature - it is better than "exaggerated", which means the same thing, because that is a word not specific to this subject. The judgements made in the essay are excellent: "...see his decision to value Cleopatra's love over Roman politics as an ascent rather than a fall" is very good because it shows the student fully understands the text and can use that understanding to make a decision on their opinion of a character. This is sustained throughout and leads to a conclusion that is strong because it ultimately answers the question posed, showing the student is on task and is writing about what they were asked, not what they wished they were asked.

The context used in this essay is excellent. The student shows that they have read other works of Shakespeare - such as "Cleopatra is no Iago", a reference to a cunning antagonist in Othello - which is good as it shows a developed understanding of the influences behind the text. References to the historical context - the "Jacobean" period - are excellent for the same reason. However, it is particularly relevant here only because the question specifically asks for it: it is best to be careful and check with your teacher which parts of the exam require context, because different exam boards require different things for each question.

Quality of writing

The spelling, punctuation and grammar in this essay is excellent, which means the examiner is not left working out what the student means, and the essay has a logical flow that makes the argument easy to follow. However, the student has a tendency to exaggerate things while analysing, by using words and phrases such as "incredibly" and "dire injustice", which creates an informal tone that is not appropriate for an A Level essay that is analysing a serious piece of literature. Furthermore, starting a paragraph with "But what of Antony?" is too informal for an essay. It would also be better for the student to avoid using phrases such as "I think..." because "I" makes the essay sound like a personal interpretation, when the aim is to address several interpretations. Nonetheless, these are small criticisms that do not stop this essay being of excellent, 5 star quality.


Did you find this review helpful? Join our team of reviewers and help other students learn

Reviewed by lordharvey 01/07/2012

Read less
Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Antony and Cleopatra essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Explore the ways Shakespeare presents the concept of authority in Antony and Cleopatra

    4 star(s)

    "Antony: I am / Antony yet. Take hence the jack and whip him!" This is an interesting juxtaposition to the previous scene where Caesar has received Antony's ambassador most courteously, even ensuring he returns safely back to his master, "Caesar: Bring him through the bands."

  2. Explore how Shakespeare presents the relationship between Antony and Cleopatra.

    There is a natural, earthly link between food and sexuality, as when Cleopatra says she was a "morsel for a monarch". Cleopatra also uses the image of feeding on 'delicious poison' to express the mixture of pain and pleasure she experiences when thinking about the absent Antony.

  1. Who is to blame for the tragedy of Antony and Cleopatra? Antony bears the ...

    The roughest berry on the rudest hedge;yea,like the stag, when snow the pasture sheets, The barks of trees thou brows'd" This portrait shows Antony as a ruggish character who could stand any obstacle or conflict in order to succeed at war.

  2. Antony & Cleopatra - language

    His language is slightly submissive and furthermore he is constantly being cut off by Cleopatra which the reader can from that deduce Cleopatra has the most power and control in the relationship yet contrastingly, it appears she is more reliant on him.

  1. Antony is often talked of as a tragic hero, a great and admiral man ...

    This is Cleopatra saying that even though Antony was the greatest soldier in the world, he has now become the greatest liar. This statement is very important as it claims that Antony has another fault. It now says he is a liar as well.

  2. Examine the Strengths and Weaknesses of Antony and Cleopatra's relationship and the significance love ...

    Cleopatra used reverse psychology to keep a grip on their love. Antony also expresses his great love for Cleopatra through his speech "such a mutual pair / And such a twain can do't, in which I bind, / On pain of punishment, the world to weet / We stand up

  1. How much does Antony's love for Cleopatra contribute to his downfall?

    is seen as a role model to all young Roman men due to his previous acheivments;"Antony...when thou once was beaten from Modena, where thou slew'st Hirtius and Pansa." Caesar making such fond remarks of Antony would almost shock the audience because it is so unexpected from him.

  2. Explore the presentation and effects of love in Antony and Cleopatra.

    This use of hyperbole adds humor to the play as the reader identifies the exaggeration and knows that Antony is mortal. This description enables us to see the vivid change in Antony's judgement. As the play progresses the audience can further observe the deterioration of Antony's greatness mainly because of awful decisions made by his affected judgement.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work