• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare and Contrast James Joyce & Charles Dickens

Extracts from this document...


LO 2.2 Where Two or More Extracts/Poems are Analysed, Critically Compare the Effects of Forms and Literary Language. Charles Dickens Great Expectations and James Joyce Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man, both wrote their novels using a semi-autobiographical style, the second written in a bildungsroman style. The first mentioned being introduced in the first-person aspect, Pip who is the main protagonist is attempting to identify his parentage and outlines briefly his childhood background from a adult perspective, in contrast James Joyce's novel is written in the omniscient third-person narrator style which is describing Stephen's developmental experiences and eludes to his coisted upbringing, where as Philip Pirrip didn't know his parents. The theme of death is prevalent, suffering, gratitude and social mobility is also apparent throughout the chapter one of Great Expectations, the structure is a coherent narrative, flowing and descriptive, in comparison chapter one of James Joyce's novel contains such themes as social mobility and the development of individual consciousness. The structure and is one of a fragmented stream of consciousness. Both chapters within their novels share a generalised functional statement, one of social mobility and off childhood experiences, Joyce's novel highlights. Joyce's novel introduces "baby tuckoo" or Stephen whom is close to "moocow" his father and mother who live in a middle/upper class lifestyle, a boy who has become harmed by pampering. ...read more.


Pip has also been educated throughout his later life as he uses etymology such as "childish conclusion" and "stone lozenges" finally "sacred" this isn't language of the illiterate of the age. An attitude of sympathy can be garnered from both authors perhaps. Joyce would be one of abandonment through choice and Dickens abandonment through enforcement. Stephen being abandoned after his early years by his loving parents to boarding school where he is unprepared for the harsh realities of life, the differential children with their "fathers and mothers and different clothes and voices" whom are like an alien race to him, Stephen is almost xenophobic. Then Pip in turn has had his situation enforced upon him by mother-nature, death of all of his family members in this case. This situation isn't so foreign to him, as he has had time to adapt as he is now an adult, when comparing to Stephen. Conveyance of Joyce's chapter one shows an omniscient narrator fragmented tone, which helps to suggest a discontented childhood being project from the stream of consciousness. As the chapter opens with the child-like references and then is interrupted by song and a memory of experience when he "wet the bed", the story continues and introduces his other family member, life at school and the suffering he is enduring mentally within it. ...read more.


Stephen is a child and the language uses says that way, as before highlight upon the childish names "baby tuckoo" for himself, and "moocow" project this, when he "wet the bed" his mother change the linen and put a "oilsheet" down. The continual repetition of rhymes "Tralala lala, Tralala tralaladdy" you can almost imagine a child dancing around in circle humming this to them self. As previously mentioned the way Stephen is alluded to as small compared to the other boys in the playground, help form a image of a cowering little boy who is last to be picked for football. Finally the closeness of the family, his father telling him a story, the singing and dancing around his mother and uncle as the "clapped". Stephen's mother telling him not to speak with "rough boys" he thinks "Nice mother", and then he thought on the day they said goodbye to him as "her nose and eyes were red". Both sections of their respective novels clearly have a statement of intent, both commenting upon social mobility, both looking from a child's perspective and finally both looking at separation from loved ones, whether enforced or not. Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man could be seen to be much harder to decipher than the structure flowing Great Expectations, however both apply moral but also social issues of the era, which is why they are both lauded. ?? ?? ?? ?? Stuart West Eng Lit - LO 2.2 11/05/2009 stuart.west7@ntlworld.com Page 1 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Other Poets section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Other Poets essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Understanding Place and Language in Olive Senior's "Gardening in the Tropics"

    5 star(s)

    Interestingly, Senior allows the language of the speaker to tell the story as there is very little of the poet's own voice. In absolute frustration, the speaker proclaims: "I've been slaving in the cane rows for your sugar I've been ripening coffee beans for you morning break I've been dallying

  2. No More Hiroshimas - James Kirkup

    Similarly life does not seem to be as it should. He writes in stanza three: "a kind of life goes on" This imagery of lifelessness is used throughout the poem such as when he comments on his hotel room being like "an overheated morgue" or visiting the park of peace in "this dying afternoon".

  1. The Bay - James K Baxter

    Time seems to be moving slowly as "A thousand times an hour is torn across/ And burned for the sake of living." This last part of the line could suggest his unwillingness to live as he finds no meaning in his life anymore.

  2. Social and literary background to Mirza Ghalib's works. Mirza Asadullah Beg Khan known ...

    'Outside there is no loyalty'." Ghalib's experiences taught him something he never forgot. It showed him how different were the values which respectable men professed from those which they practiced when it came to the test. It convinced him that those few who, like himself, really practiced the standards of

  1. "All The major Romantics...were engaged...in the rediscovery of nature, the assertion of the one-ness ...

    It has also been suggested that "Despite his insistence on the separation between the mind and the world, Coleridge nevertheless continues to find metaphors for his own feelings in nature"2 thus showing that he is still unconsciously unifying himself with nature.

  2. Rabindranath Tagore. Tagore being an active politician of his age has written numerous ...

    Tagore affirms that a homeland is the creation of the mind and that is why the soul realizes itself on its own experience in the motherland (as the King does not attend the council house or the streets of his kingdom he does not experience and see the devastating conditions of his country).

  1. Reasons why I would invite Michael Longley to speak to my class.

    In another poem, "ceasefire", Longley provides us with the situation faced by many Northern Irish families during the conflict, when bodies of their loved ones were lost in the fighting and never returned to them to be buried and mourned.

  2. How do the authors convey their attitude about ageing in Childhood and My Parents?

    My Parents has got three stanzas while Childhood has only got one. In Spender's poem the reader can get, through its three stanzas that the boy seems to long for more than to offer forgiveness. Moreover, the use of tightly structured stanzas is a device the writer uses in order

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work