Compare and Contrast the Different Ways In Which Baz Luhrmann and William Shakespeare Establish ‘Romeo and Juliet’ As a Tragedy.

Authors Avatar

Meera Pithia 11B

COMPARE AND CONTRAST THE DIFFERENT WAYS IN WHICH BAZ LUHRMANN AND WILLIAM SHAKESPEARE ESTABLISH ‘ROMEO AND JULIET’ AS A TRAGEDY

‘Romeo and Juliet’ is one of William Shakespeare’s most popular plays.  It is a very well known tragedy.  ‘Romeo and Juliet’ is found appealing by a young generation of people, as Romeo and Juliet were young and fashionable themselves.  Baz Luhrmann re-created ‘Romeo and Juliet’ with a modern twist.  He has done this very successfully.

Baz Luhrmann used a lot of connotative messages in his film, and this helped us see how different the Capulet’s were from the Montague’s.  The Capulet’s dressed in suits and looked very smart.  The Montague’s were more colourful and more casual.

Parts of the opening scene on the video are very fast moving and a lot of crash zooms are used.  This makes you think that something disastrous is going to happen.  The opera music in the background also adds to this effect.  The use of text on the screen is very effective.  The text appears in flashes on screen, and then it gets faster.  This adds to the effect of tragedy and that something bad is going to happen and that the tension is rising.

William Shakespeare has used a large number of words in the Prologue that identify with tragedy.  He uses the words: death, death-marked, rage, fatal, blood, foes and grudge.  All of these words have a sense of tragedy or doom and they are all very negative.  Romeo and Juliet are in love, which is strange because the play is packed with a lot of negative words.  In the Princes speech there are many words that identify with tragedy. Shakespeare uses the words: an enemy to peace, you beasts, weapons, purple fountains, blood quenches all the rage.  This imagery is very powerful.  The use of the word ‘fountains’ show the extent of the conflict and that those hands are stained permanently.

Join now!

There are a lot of different genres used.  The music used relates to the action genre.  A documentary is used in the news report.  There is also some comedy used.  This is shown with the style of acting, the costumes and the voices used.  This suggests that the target audience is quite young.   There is some light hearted humour in the first scene, but they repetition of the word ‘sir’.  They are joking about something that is so serious.  There is also a touch of spaghetti western.  This is shown through the music and the style of the acting ...

This is a preview of the whole essay