• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare and Contrast 'The Happy Warrior' by William Wordsworth with 'The Happy Warrior' by Herbert Read.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Suzi Bowen Compare and Contrast 'The Happy Warrior' by William Wordsworth with 'The Happy Warrior' by Herbert Read. Although these two war poems both have the same name, the two poets have very different ideas and the poems are extremely different. Wordsworth and Read have managed to write two exceedingly different war poems both with the same name, yet with almost opposite ideas. William Wordsworth had written a long and detailed description on his view of an ideal soldier and all the characteristics he would have. Although this poem is long, it is not that complicated and the point Wordsworth is making is quite obvious. Herbert Read, however, has written a very short poem, yet it is incredibly complicated and could be interpreted in many different ways. One way, and maybe the more obvious way, in which you could interpret it, is that the title is in fact sarcastic and you can't actually have a 'happy warrior'. ...read more.

Middle

This describes a soldier killing a German soldier, a German soldier that could potentially have killed the soldier- the 'happy warrior'. It then goes on to say: "This is the happy warrior" The 'happy warrior' is perhaps happy, because although he has been through all the pain, he has not been killed and is still alive. He was the one watching someone being killed and not the one being killed, for that, he is happy. Yet another way in which Read's poem could be read, is that the 'happy warrior' is a warrior that enjoys seeing people-the enemy- being killed. Most of the adjectives are unpleasant, and could be reflecting his character. Yet when you read the poem again and search for other meanings, it must also be noted that as well as showing how awful it is, there are also adjectives that are maybe describing the excitement of living on the edge; "Wild heart beat" and "Wide eyes search". ...read more.

Conclusion

Who is he That every man in the arms should wish to be?" Even from the first two lines, you can tell that this poem has a calm peaceful nature. The mood in which Herbert Read's version of The Happy Warrior is written in is again completely different! It is bleak, dismal and miserable, and being short and snappy, using depressing, unpleasant words and being inconsistent and not flowing shows this. "His wild heart beat with painful sobs" Again, from the first line you can tell the nature of this poem, you can tell that it is going to be gloomy and forlorn. These two poems both share the same title, but they are very different. They don't even have the same ideas for what the 'happy warrior' is. This shows that a title/phrase etc can have many different meanings if you look at it in different ways. Suzi Bowen ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level William Wordsworth section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level William Wordsworth essays

  1. Compare and Contrast Hopkins' and Longfellows' attitude to the natural world in

    Both poems acknowledge existence and power of a creator. In "Pied Beauty" a song of praise is presented in the first line of the poem's triumphant, alliterative opening stanza, as "Glory be to God..." immediately places Hopkins' appreciation of the beauty of the natural world in a religious context.

  2. Compare two poems of William Wordsworth.

    The effects of the two poems are very different on the reader, in Boat Stealing Episode the poem makes me think about what is wrong and what is right !

  1. Form and meaning of The Daffodils by W.Wordsworth and Miracle on St.David’s Day by ...

    By doing this Wordsworth indicates the end of the description of the daffodils. There is also a metaphor in this stanza, "what wealth to me the show had brought". The "wealth" in this stanza is a metaphor for the lasting measure of the experience gained by the sight of the daffodils and the emotions that they brought.

  2. In your opinion, how successfully does Lyrical Ballads capture the hour of feeling?

    Nature is personified here. Wordsworth brings the poem and the book to a close with a personal message to all the readers "if solitude, or fear, or pain, or grief, should be thy portion, with what healing thoughts of tender joy wilt thou remember me, and these my exhortations!"

  1. Analysing closely three or four poems which we have read, say what seems to ...

    This is actually typical of the poem throughout as 'Then ye are only five' and 'What should it know of death?' are examples of the opposing views which are highlighted by their placement in the structure of the poem. Again, there is repetition, this time of the word 'dead', enforcing the narrator's perception of the Maid's brother and sister.

  2. Differences and Similarities Between Coleridge and Wordsworth Concerning People's Relationship to Nature

    security: " While all the night, through white smoke, glimmered the white Moon-shine". He creates suspense and describes a nature that struggles with men(Holmes 88). Coleridge uses supernatural events, spirits and visions. The world is violent with contrast to Wordsworth who describes nature as serene.

  1. Compare and Contrast Two Poets Opinions On Infant Mortality.

    Jonson doesn't consider the good times that he and his son have shared and still wishes he could "loose all father, now". Jonson's thought then changes and he begins to question why he is unhappy as his son has gone to a better place - heaven.

  2. Demonstrate the persistence of Wordsworthian ideal of country folk, childhood and natural education in ...

    Hers is the good mother, the mother earth in Wordsworth's poems. The respect for her and her kind shines through in the text as it does in the poems, through the voice of the narrator. She is again a considered equal in the narrator's eyes to all who she comes into contact with.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work