• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare and Contrast the Two Video Versions of the opening scenes of “Macbeth” with the beginning of the actual Text.

Extracts from this document...


Macbeth Compare and Contrast the Two Video Versions of the opening scenes of "Macbeth" with the beginning of the actual Text. You Should Look At: Purpose Setting/ Background Actors- Appearance Delivery of Lines Movement-facial expressions Use of Camera The Play "Macbeth" is about a man whose life is dramatically changed by a meeting with three witches. This meeting changes his life. They corrupt him and turn him into an evil blood thirsty man. He was able to kill anyone that got in the way of himself becoming King of Scotland, and anyone that stood in the way of his happiness as King. Macbeth even has the courage to kill his best friend, Banquo. As Macbeth knew that Banquo posed as a threat as he was the only other person to know about the meeting with the witches. The Purpose of this assignment is to study the differences between the two film versions of the play, to the original text. We can see from the very start of each film version that each director (Polanski and Freeston) have different interpretations of the original text. The Original Text of Macbeth opens with the three witches talking about when they will meet next. The Polanski version shows this, but before this is seen, Polanski added in the witches casting an evil spell on a deserted beach with heavy clouds above them. ...read more.


But this seen is completely skipped out by Freeston. I can't think of a reason why this is. This is the same scene at which King Duncan announces the death of the Thane of Cawdor, and also announces Macbeth to be the new Thane. We have not studied any further than the meeting with the witches in the Freeston version, so I am not sure on how Freeston shows how Macbeth was told the news of him being the new Thane of Cawdor. After that scene, the book tells of the witches discussing their treatment of the sea Captain. But this is not mentioned in either of the films. The conversation may have been left out as it may have seemed irrelevant to both directors. Once this discussion is over, according to the original text, Macbeth and Banquo come along and so the first meeting between the witches and Macbeth takes place. This is shown in both films, mainly because it is one of the most important scenes in the play, the first meeting with the witches. This scene is where Macbeth receives his first predictions. These predictions tell Macbeth of how is to become Thane of Cawdor and King of Scotland. At this time, Macbeth does not take these predictions seriously. As is to be expected as they seemed very far fetched. ...read more.


Polanski believed that Macbeth meant that the day was fair because they won the battle against the rebels, and that it was a foul day because there was such bad weather. Freeston believed that Macbeth meant the opposite, e.g. that the day was fair because of the weather, and that it was foul because of the battle. This leads us to believe that Freeston believed that Macbeth did not enjoy battles, but he knew that he was forced to fight in them. Polanski must have believed that Macbeth was already a blood thirsty warrior before the witches interfered in his life. So again, we see the differences in the interpretations of the words spoken by the characters from the original text and the movements of the characters etc. I think that the appearance of Macbeth in the Freeston version is more accurate as I believed that it showed what Macbeth was likely to look like, considering the time period that the play is set in. I also believe that the witches in the Freeston version are a lot better as they go against the stereotypical look of the witches, which is the look that Polanski chose for the witches in his version. The younger witch in the Freeston version looks very modern as she is wearing make up but always looks as if she is in a sort of trance as her eyes do not move in most scenes, when she talks. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Macbeth section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Macbeth essays

  1. Compare and contrast the opening scenes of two or three plays you have studied ...

    However, to closely examine these characters, the third scene of Act I is also taken into consideration. The witches make reference to Macbeth from the start. The opening scene is filled with antithesis. The witches speak seemingly contradictory phrases such as "When the battle's lost and won", which in the end hold true enough.

  2. This essay will thoroughly canvass the main themes of Hamlet and Macbeth, and will ...

    In my opinion, I believe that what Shakespeare wanted to do is to use the three witches as a cure to Macbeth's curiosity which corrupts his character. This is a little bit recondite and opinions on this vary from reader to reader.

  1. 'Macbeth is full of highly dramatic scenes. Choose two scenes and explore how Shakespeare ...

    Macbeth's first phrase in the play immediately links him to the witches and could make him seem connected to them in a supernatural way. He says 'So foul and fair a day I have not seen.' This is similar to the phrase initially chanted by all the witches, 'Fair is

  2. The Film Versions of Macbeth

    We listen to the three beings who have met on a desert heath. Thunder and lightening accompany them and produce an evil eerie effect. The first witch asks '"when shall we three meet again?" The reply from the second "when the battles lost and won" does not help our understanding as this seem contradictory.

  1. To What Extent Do Feel That Roman Polanski's Interpretation Of The Witches Is In ...

    This shows how they can twist and manipulate situations. They then disappear; Polanski has them walking off into the distances then vanishing in a cloud of fog. Polanksi captures this first scene excellently and keeps the same effect we gain from reading the play when you watch the film, of the scene being very unsettling and unnatural.

  2. Show the importance, to the play, of the opening scene and the two scenes ...

    Shakespeare's underlying concern is introduced in the fourth line of the play, "When the battles lost and won". It is impossible for the same battle to be both lost and won, it is a contradictory verse. But the witches were not talking about just one battle, they meant that Macbeth

  1. How do the first three scenes foretell the tragedy of Macbeth?

    An oxy-moron has been used in Act 1 scene 1; the witches say "When the battle's lost and won." This shows that the witches have prophesied what is going to happen to Macbeth. This is because the witches could be suggesting when they said this that Macbeth will lose many

  2. Macbeth Comparison - the contrast between Macbeth and Banquo

    The theme of the corruptive powers of unchecked ambition is brought to our attention through the fact that it is Macbeth who first thinks of murder, not the witches. This shows the strength of his ambition and that he is willing to sacrifice all morality and nobility to achieve it.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work