• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

COMPARE AND CONTRAST TWO THEORIES OF CHILD DEVELOPMENT

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

COMPARE AND CONTRAST TWO THEORIES OF DEVELOPMENT Psychologists have differing opinions in their explanations for the development of a child, there are various approaches and this essay aims to compare and contrast Chomsky's rationalist approach and Skinner's behaviourist approach to child development. Particular attention will be given to the development of language in children, highlighting the similarities and differences in both theories. To begin with language can be defined as a "symbolisation of thought. It is a learned, code or a system of rules that enable us to communicate ideas and express words and needs" (Paivo. & Begg: Psychology of Language 1981). Language communication consists of two main processes; the production of language e.g. speaking and writing, and the reception of language e.g. understanding the speech or writing. Consequently how does a child acquire this level of language, what processes do they undergo? Research has identified biological elements accountable for the production of language, e.g. Broca's area of the brain is responsible for the construction of speech. Therefore biology inevitably plays a role in the acquisition of language. The behaviourists approach views language acquisition as a result of the child's interaction with the environment. Skinner's explanation of language was "Any acquisition was due to a learning process involving the shaping of grammar into a correct form by the reinforcement of other stimulus, where correct grammar is positively reinforced and will be used in the future and incorrect grammar is negatively reinforced and will not be used again" (Chomsky vs. ...read more.

Middle

By the age of 3 the child can construct 3 word sentences, and by the age of 6 years the child's grammar becomes more complex and continues to grow until they reach adult level. During this whole process Chomsky claims that the child is mastering its predisposed rules and transforming them progressively. Hence the "task for young language learners is to discover which particular language community they are in and apply the universal rules of language to that particular version" (Lee and Das Gupta, 1995). Therefore according to Chomsky language development is instantaneous, where the grammatical structures of an adult exists at birth, and that these structures develop and mature like physical growth. When considering the acquisition of vocabulary, Skinner suggests that the child individually learns words and receives reinforcements for the use of these words. This is supported by Clarke and Stewart 1973 (Clarke-Stewart A (1973) "Interactions between mothers and their young children: characteristics and consequences.") who found that children's, whose mothers communicated with them regularly, had a much larger vocabulary than children's whose mothers rarely communicated with them. Chomsky to a certain extent agrees with this idea, as he did propose that a child does attain most of their language from the environment. However he claims that the child may hear words from the environment but the rules from his innate universal grammar helps him/her to transform these newly acquired words and apply it to different contexts. ...read more.

Conclusion

The acquisition of language is a very complex process, and cannot be explained merely in terms of the innate principles of universal grammar or to the operant conditioning of parents as there are many factors involved. Chomsky for instance claims that the child from birth possesses an "instantaneous emergence of mature grammar" (Crain. W., Theories of Development), it can be argued that this is too specific as Chomsky it seems is regarding the infants as "miniature adults" where language is concerned. (Crain. W., Theories of Development). Similarly Skinner can be criticised for placing too much emphasis on the environment "linguistic data-however transparent-will never be sufficient for language development" (Harris. M., Language Experience and Early Language Development 1993). Therefore both theories can be criticised for being too specific in their ideas. However on a more positive note both theories have expanded and encouraged the understanding of language development. Subsequently it may be more ideal to adopt an interactionist perspective which would claim that "the course of development will be the outcome of an interaction between the child's own processing abilities and experience" (Harris. M., Language Experience and Early Language Development 1993). Considering the substantial amount of evidence linked to Chomsky's research it can be concluded that the concept of innateness plays a more significant role in the acquisition of language than the idea of learning language via operant conditioning. Therefore for this reason the idea of an innate language system is more favourable, but only with the addition of some input from the linguistic environment. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Language: Context, Genre & Frameworks section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Language: Context, Genre & Frameworks essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Investigating how language has changed in children's literature; in relation to interaction between ...

    5 star(s)

    This is due to the setting of the plot, much of the 'wizarding world' is still what many would today find old fashioned, and the authoritative figure is also rather old himself. Taking this into account however, the lead characters language still leaves enough to be a comparison, as "Harry" is a 'modern child'.

  2. Theories Of Language Development - Chomsky and Skinner

    Chomsky called these individual rule surface structures. And believed that all languages have the same underlying rules or structures and these deep structures are something that babies are born to recognise. The nature-nurture debate on language is inconclusive. In my opinion it seems likely that learning language has elements of both nature and nurture.

  1. What are the consequences of societal multilingualism?

    It has also been discovered that the further one travels into the countryside the more monolingual speakers of Guarani are found. The use of formal speech in Paraguay is Spanish and is used in formal occasions in business situations, in conversation with strangers that are well dressed and that are of a high social status and also with foreigners.

  2. Innatist and Interactionist theories and their teaching implications

    Hatch (1992) and Michael Long (1983) believe that much second language acquisition takes place through conversational interaction. Long agrees with Krashen that input at a right level is important for language acquisition. Despite of this similarity with the innatist theory, interactionist focuses more on analyzing the input given in order to acquire is successfully.

  1. Critically evaluate one theory of language development. Chomsky argues that language is a formal ...

    Chomsky believed it was the Language Acquisition Device (or LAD) that held the innate ability for people to learn language. The LAD perceives similarities in language, it then generates a hypothesis' about these similarities (i.e. to make a word plural add 's')

  2. An exploration of the extent in which childrens TV presenters accommodate to the participants ...

    which adds to the light-hearted fun genre of the programme. The target audience and participants of the show are around the same as Best of Friends (11-13) which is maybe why the game rules are explained similarly to Best of Friends.

  1. Investigation into Gender Differences in the Language of Personal Profiles on Dating Websites

    with the tv on or listening to music last read: Dan Browns... cant remember what it's called. The one where americas security is at risk due to an unbreakable code. That one About my life and what I'm looking for Lets see..

  2. Semantic Processing in Advertising

    Words On List Number Recalled Significance? Table Males = 3/8 Females = 8/10 Significantly higher female recall (primary effect), first word on list. Sun Males = 2/8 Females = 4/10 Nearly half the females recalled this word, this could be down to primary effect, lack of recall could be down to visual processing.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work