• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare how Celie and Jeanette deal with the influence of Mr.____ and Mother in 'The Color Purple' and 'Oranges Are Not the Only Fruit'. Refer to the way structure and language demonstrates their resilience.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Compare how Celie and Jeanette deal with the influence of Mr.____ and Mother in 'The Color Purple' and 'Oranges Are Not the Only Fruit'. Refer to the way structure and language demonstrates their resilience. Both protagonists seek others for the comfort they are lacking from Mr.___ and Mother, yet neither Shug nor Melanie or Katy are able to truly compensate for what they have lost. Shug's abandonment of Celie appears to hurt her more than Mr.____'s physical abuse ever did: "My heart broke. Shug love somebody else." Celie does not need to be well educated, and Walker's language does not need to be sophisticated to show the pain that Celie is feeling. These two short sentences create enormous impact, particularly as they open one of the letters/prayers. It also evokes more sympathy here from the reader because of how much Shug means to Celie, "My life...stop with Mr. ___ ...but start up again with Shug." Celie, like Jeanette, loses little when her primary caregiver is insensitive, yet loses everything when her soul mate is, "I feel my heart begin to cramp...I cover it with my hand." This gesture is so achingly poignant because of its simplicity, and because it is so child-like; Celie has not been taught any other way to cope. Winterson's description, though more detailed, describes a strikingly similar reaction to loss from Jeanette: "We cried each other to sleep...sweating and crying with mixed up bodies and swollen faces." ...read more.

Middle

It also reflects a certain maturity at being able to assess a situation, and walk away if it cannot be resolved. Her explanation of Pastor Finch's whereabouts even shows wit at such a young age: "playing with the fuzzy felt", adding this embarrassing detail purely to show her maturity and eye for humour over the Pastor. The use of first person narrative allows us to clearly see how Jeanette and Celie are finding ways of coping. Surprisingly, there is almost no use of denial by either protagonist: a typical coping technique. They are both very honest, and this narrative structure allows the reader to see their genuine feelings, with no reason to hide anything. Jeanette's reaction to Pastor Finch is not truthful; she does not tell him that she was "just beginning to enjoy a rewrite of Daniel in the lions' den", but instead acts as if it was a mistake, "putting on my best, blessed face". The adjective "best" could even suggest that she is so used to these situations that she has been practising, and now knows which one is the most effective. She is used to the behaviour of the adults in her life, and has learnt that protesting will only get her into more trouble. One key contrast between Celie and Jeanette is their self-confidence. Jeanette, although defeatist at times, does seem to realise her potential, and is rarely self-pitying: "I cannot recall a time when I did not know that I was special". ...read more.

Conclusion

It seems to be saying that despite this very Christian idea of hell, telling young children about it is wrong for fear it might corrupt them. The phrase, "young minds" implies this, in the way that they could be moulded, perhaps suggesting a fear of Satanism within society, which is certainly reflected throughout the novel: "Parents, watch your children for the signs". This is also ironic in that a religious idea is not fit for exposure to a young, pure, mind, and contrasts with so much of Mother's behaviour, "Whatever it is, it's not holy." There is the sense, with both novels, that society plays a major part in Celie and Jeanette's lack of freedom: "All my life I had to fight". The two protagonists are not the only ones experiencing this kind of oppression, nor are Mr. and Mother the only ones enforcing it. In Jeanette's case, it is her religion's boundaries that restrict her, and with Celie, it is the social ones. Mother and Mr.____ are merely representative of the figures in society that are so controlling, and are certainly not rare. This explains, in part, why there is so little abhorrence felt by the protagonists towards Mr.___ and Mother. They are not used to being treated any differently, and so ultimately, instead of trying to physically escape, both characters learn to be resilient: "I'm pore, I'm black, I may be ugly...but I'm here." 2419 words. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Other Criticism & Comparison section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Other Criticism & Comparison essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    The English Patient

    5 star(s)

    While he was carrying Katharine's injured body from the plane to the cave, they had a few moments to talk. She told him that he killed everything in her during their separation. She said that she left him not only because her husband was mad, but because she knew she could never change him.

  2. comparsion of jane eyre and wuthering heights

    novel, it even causes Mr Lockwood to declare, "Together they would brave Satan and all his legions." The union between the two young lovers at the end of the novel gives a sense of happiness and a fresh start, as it also does in 'Jane Eyre'.

  1. Compare the extent to which the sexuality of Jeanette and Celie is portrayed in ...

    South had a strong social hierarchy, with women and black people at the bottom. Men were seen as the dominant sex, and it was acceptable for men to beat their wives, and even children, as a way to assert authority and possession, which can be seen when Mr.

  2. Compare and contrast the presentation of sex and sexuality in The Color Purple by ...

    A contrast can be made to Jeanette, as she also has a struggle relating to sex and sexuality, but this is focused more on her homosexuality. This is indicated through mainly her mother. It is explained that "she had never heard of mixed feelings" and that "sex (in its many forms)"

  1. `Compare and Contrast the Presentation of Family Relationships in Atonement (TM)and(TM) Oranges Are Not ...

    love God and I loved the church, but I began to see that as more and more complicated.' at this point Jeanette understands that the church is not as stable as her Mother has brought her up to believe, therefore her mother has complicated her.

  2. Comparision. The Protagonist in "The bluest eye" is Pecola and the protagonist in "The ...

    Although this social hierarchy did exist the northern states of America there was less seclusion as is evident in the Bluest eye which is set in Ohio however there was still a longing to conform to the ideology of the time which was that white girls, specifically the cliché of blonde hair and blue eyes (hence the books name)

  1. Discuss the presentation of disturbed minds in Hamlet, The Bell Jar and Oranges are ...

    However for Ophelia, it is the death of her father, Polonius that is the initial trigger for her downfall. Another theme presented by Jeanette's love for Melanie is that of rejection. As Jeanette is rejected from the church for her lesbianism, she loses everything she was brought up to believe in.

  2. Compare the ways in which The Colour Purple and What Maisie Knew portray inequality. ...

    Like Celie?s father, Maisie?s father, Mr Farange is portrayed as economically superior to her mother, having been ?destined in his youth for diplomacy? and so could travel the world, the abstract noun ?diplomacy? depicting Mr Farange?s economic independence, a glaring contrast to Ida for whom there is no mention of

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work