• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare the persuasive techniques and the development of the argument in 'Old Major's speech' and Jonathan Swift's A Modest Proposal.

Extracts from this document...


Compare the persuasive techniques and the development of the argument in 'Old Major's speech' and Jonathan Swift's 'A Modest Proposal'. Although 'Animal Farm' and 'A Modest Proposal' were written over two hundred years apart, and one is non-fiction and the other is not, there are distinct similarities between the two. Both of the pieces are political, with 'Animal Farm' based on the Russian Revolution, and 'A Modest Proposal' based on the situation of homelessness in Ireland. Also, both of the pieces are satirical. Animal Farm ridicules the ordinary Russian people for being gullible, and 'A Modest Proposal' mocks politicians who ignore sensible suggestions and come up with extreme ones. In the build up to his speech, Old Major first clears his throat, to gain all of the animals' attention. The fact that all he has to do is clear his throat to do this, gives the impression that he is authoritative, and in control. We are given the idea that the other animals respect him. In the following paragraph, Old Major mentions a dream, but he says "I will come to the dream later". The dream is the whole reason the meeting has been called, and by saying that he will talk about it later holds all of the animals in suspense. They are willing to listen to what he has to say, to hear about the dream. He also mentions his imminent death, which will gain the audience's sympathy, and again make them listen. To guarantee that the animals are going to listen to him, he says that he will "pass onto to you such wisdom as I have acquired". ...read more.


In the next few paragraphs he hints even more at the solution, by saying that instead of the babies needing food, clothing and nourishment, they shall "contribute to the feeding, and partly clothing of many thousands." This is similar to Old Major, who hints early on in his speech at the answer to the animals' problems. He again uses more formal language, like "computation" and "solar year" to make himself sound clever. In contrast to this he uses emotive language to rouse personal emotions in the reader: "That horrid practice of women murdering their bastard children." He also uses statistics to back up his claims about the situation in Ireland: "There may be about two-hundred thousand couples whose wives are breeders." All the time that Swift is talking, he is backing up his arguments and showing that he has researched the problem: "I am assured by our merchants." This is in contrast to Old Major's Speech, as he doesn't back up his argument with facts and figures, but just relies on the audience believing what he is saying. Swift backs up his argument, by dismissing other ideas about how to deal with the problem: "We can neither employ them...they can seldom pick up a lively hood by stealing." Swift finally outlines his proposal, saying that some children should be kept for breeding, and the others should be eaten: "A child will make two dishes at an entertainment for friends." Although his proposal is very shocking, he has calm tone of voice, and even begins to offer recipes: "Seasoned with a little pepper or salt." ...read more.


and then answers them for them. It is an indirect way of telling them what to think. Jonathan Swift asks "The question, therefore, is how this number shall be reared and provided for?" This is the only question that Swift asks his audience though. Questions draw the reader in, and make them feel like they are involved. Swift is telling people that he is right, so he does not want people to think other things. Old Major is only suggesting things, but his questions are hinting to the audience that he is right. By using exclamations, Old Major makes his speech seem dramatic; "No comrades! A thousand times no!" He can make certain parts of his speech seem more important, and make people listen by using exclamations. Jonathan Swift also does this in 'A Modest Proposal': "...murdering their bastard children; alas!" Again though, Swift uses a lot less exclamation marks than Old Major. This is mainly because his piece is meant to be formal. Both Old Major and Swift use alliteration in the pieces to make themselves sound stylish and eloquent. In one part of his speech, Old Major says "... as sure as I see this straw ..." The repetition of the 's' makes certain words in that sentence stand out, making his message more clear. Swift says "Four females". Although Old Major's speech and 'A Modest Proposal' were written over two hundred years apart, they both use very similar techniques and development of their argument to get their point across. Both of the pieces are politically based and satirical, both use formal and emotive language, differing sentence types and structures and in sparse amounts, alliteration. This makes their arguments fairly similar. Tim Barber 11/1 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Jonathan Swift section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Jonathan Swift essays

  1. Human Nature in Gulliver's Travels

    Next we have the two gentlemen who, after graciously accompanying Gulliver to Glubbdubbdrib, "were so generous and Kind as to furnish me with Provisions, and see me on board" to Luggnagg.

  2. Consider some of the ways Jonathan Swift satirises England of the 1720's.

    This satire is still the monarchy are criticised for the ridiculous amount of money they waste on things that can be cheaper. The monarchy are also criticised about the fact that they don't have much involvement with the population of the country.

  1. A Modest Proposal.

    A Modest Proposal is set in the 18th century. It presents a rationally argued, economic argument which considers the elimination of all poor children or babies which would provide a solution to the problems of poverty and homelessness. The proposal is to prevent the children of the poor people from

  2. "A Modest Proposal" - Swift.

    Lastly, this system will produce a better cultural environment for Ireland as a whole, encouraging marriage and the charms of the tavern due to the bonuses of bearing children. Swift defends his intentions in offering such a proposal, explaining that he has no personal advantages which will be derived from

  1. Satire and Colonialism in the eighteenth century: 'A Modest Proposal' and 'Gulliver's Travels'

    In the text Sift is satirising the English ruling class and the way that English government treated the Irish Catholics. In the text Swift is suggesting that Irish babies should be eaten because there are too many poor people and the poor people can sell their children.

  2. Based On Your Reading Of Gulliver's Travels, To What Extent Do You Agree That ...

    This is misanthropic because it is Swift saying exactly what he thinks of the human race. The third voyage is to Laputa, Glubbdubdrib and Luggnag. In Laputa, Swift is satirising scientists and intellectuals. The people in Laputa live on a floating island and use this fact to exploit those below them.

  1. Swift's A Modest Proposal is famous as an example of Satire. In what ways, ...

    animals, the humans are so needy that they aren't even human in some of the landlord's views. Here the cruelty of the rich is exposed and they would realise their wrong doings of exploiting the poor. The Persona seems to have his remedy well thought out he has even conjured up careful calculations, showing thorough details of his thoughts.

  2. Guillivers Travels. In this essay I will discuss all 4 voyages in which ...

    He finds the giants grotesque ?they would often strip me naked from top to toe? wherewith I was much disgusted; because to say the truth, a very offensive smell came from their skin? (Jonathon Swift 1726 5:87)

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work