• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare the ways Brian Friel presents ideas about divided identity in Making History with Michael Frayn in Spies. How far do you agree that the notion of divided identity is more prominent in Making History?

Extracts from this document...


English Literature ? Drama Coursework Third Draft Compare the ways Brian Friel presents ideas about divided identity in Making History with Michael Frayn in Spies. How far do you agree that the notion of divided identity is more prominent in Making History? Divided identity is shown in both Spies and Making Historyfrom the beginning. Stephen Wheatley has two voices, his older self (Stefan Weitzler) and his younger self, which forms a prominent split in his identity. Hugh O?Neill?s split self is displayed a little subtler in the stage directions. O?Neill is described to speak ?in an upper-class English accent except on those occasions specifically scripted?. The word ?scripted? makes me think of acting and implies O?Neill?s front is a feigned identity he puts on. This could also show that he is perhaps embarrassed by his Irish roots which contradict his betrayal of England later on in the play. This relates to Spies as Stephen Wheatley speaks the English language with an English accent, when he is actually (unknowingly) German. Stephen Wheatley?s father reminds me of O?Neill too as he is betraying his German background by working as an English spy, much like O?Neill working as an Earl for England when he originates from the opposing country Ireland. O?Neill seems to be uninterested in the important events he needs to attend, butmore focused onsuch as the flowers he?s decorating the room with and how he looks in his jacket. ...read more.


digging and dunging, and trimming and pruning, forever undercoating and painting, and wiring and rewiring, forever making perfection yet more perfect?)to present the character?s compulsive attitude. The attention of his gardening tends to be on the roses which could be symbolic in a patriotic way ? roses are a typical English flower ? and the way he is described to be planting them sounds like he?s building a fort to keep out ?enemies? (the German, Wheatley family). The privet flower (a misspelling of ?private? by Keith) signified privacy, but had a suffocating smell; whenever Stephen was in the ?privet? with someone else there was often a stifled atmosphere. I think this smell indicated the uncomfortable stage at the start of puberty, where people start to discover their identities in more detail. The elder trees were outside the safe cul-de-sac, near to Uncle Peter?s hideaway which similarly represented Stephens?s admission into the adult world and puberty. In the first scene, O?Neill presents Mabel with a ring which is symbolic as it was made in London ? the capital of the country Ireland are enemy with ? and the only person to have one is the Queen of England, Elizabeth. This moment is like the initiation of Mabel?s new identity when Mabel changes ?we?re a tough breed the upstarts? to the ?O?Neill?s? being the ?tough breed?. This is similar to Mrs Hayward wearing her cravat to cover her abuse symbolising the initiation of her oppression. ...read more.


O?Neill even tells O?Donnell ?What you see is what I have? showing the loss of all the materialistic things that he had before. For the audience, it is immediately made obvious that Ireland have lost the war and O?Neill is symbolically on his knees as he is writing a letter to Queen Elizabeth begging for forgiveness and his old job. When Harry arrives in the scene, he comes with news of Mabel?s death through blood poisoning, which is representative that she?s been poisoned by O?Neill?s Irish blood. In Spies, there is a recurring theme, just like the blood in Making History, of the train getting closer and closer which builds tension until finally Uncle Peter significantly killed by it.Frayn again uses repetition to create this suspense all throughout the book, from just mentioning the train line to the intimidating ?huge thunder of the train? when he is in the tunnel. My final point is of course about the making of the history itself. It is apparent from the start that Lombard was going to exaggerate in the book, but by the end we know he used O?Neill so Roman Catholics could have an idol. This shows when the grieving (even after many years) and drunken O?Neill is staggering about his room, reading sentences like ?noblest son of noble lineage? and that he grew in ?comeliness and urbanity, tact and eloquence, wisdom and knowledge? that supposedly describe him. Divided identity is the main theme of the play, whereas in Spies it is just one of the many readings of the novel.Why? Alice Morris ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Other Criticism & Comparison section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Other Criticism & Comparison essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    The English Patient

    5 star(s)

    As the second child in his family, and according to the Indian tradition, he would become a doctor, while the elder son would join the British army. Nevertheless, his elder brother is an Indian nationalist and strongly anti-Western, so he rejected to join the military.

  2. 'Spies' - An evaluation of Mrs Hayward

    Stephen compares her to Barbara Berrill, another child. Another way in, which Mrs. H is, childlike is in the way that she, not only rejects responsibility, but the way in which she doesn't think about the consequences of her actions.

  1. There is no room for individual identity in South African literature Discuss.

    Yet, providing a more likely alternative, explanation also is found in the Suppression of Communism Act (1950) which is was in effect the legal gagging of opposition to the apartheid government2. Others such as Herman Bosman, who, in the words of Christopher Heywood possesses a "light touch even when dealing

  2. Explore the presentation of Keith & his importance in the novel Spies, by Michael ...

    Keith in many instances puts Stephen down. Stephen is constantly subservient to Keith, but there is an underlying dependence from Keith for "Someone to be braver than him" Keith makes stephen feel inferior, when they are on their adventures and in general, "He puts a restraining arm on my shoulder"

  1. Compare how Thomas Kyd presents unrequited love in The Spanish Tragedy with Keats Letter ...

    Alternatively, Keats may be hinting that the ?madness? is he loves her but there is a reason they cannot be together; writing in the early 1800?s there is the hint that she may be an upper class lady whom he desires but not being part of that class, he cannot marry her.

  2. 'The Metamorphosis' and 'The Road'The isolation in both texts highlights the despair and nothingness ...

    He concludes that he is unable to kill his son showing the bond between the father and son contradicting the despair and nothingness of isolation and somewhat making the isolation beautiful and complete.

  1. Compare the ways Wilde presents the main female protagonist in The importance of being ...

    ?constructing their fake wilderness..... built a fake hermitage? - the fact that the Hannah views the renovations of the garden as a ?wilderness? suggests that Hannah believes romance is unpredictable and therefore dangerous because it clouds logical judgement which is able to move the world forward.

  2. History is a kind of story-telling. Compare and contrast the ways in which Friel ...

    Lombard remarks that ?now is the time for a hero?, and suggests that ?that?s the stuff of another history for another time? when referring to the true depiction of O?Neill?s character. This is reflective of the late 1500s which saw ideological struggles between the Catholic Church and Protestant Reformism.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work