• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare the ways in which the poets express strength of feeling in "Spring" and "Holy Sonnet 10"

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

ENGLISH COURSEWORK Compare the ways in which the poets express strength of feeling in "Spring" and "Holy Sonnet 10" "Spring", written by Gerard Manley-Hopkins, employs the ideas of the beauty of the season. Manley-Hopkins introduces references to his faith, portraying a religious approach. The feelings experienced within the sonnet are very intense, and the reader becomes progressively more engrossed amid the lines of the sonnet, as the poet delves into the peril that spring might be spoiled, and the innocence of youth might be lost. Manley-Hopkins addresses the Lord, in the hope that all sinning might cease forever, and hence the beauty of the season of spring might be maintained eternally. "Holy Sonnet 10", written by John Donne, similarly refers to the poet's faith. The strength of the feeling shown here is colossal, as Donne challenges to address Death as a coward. The sonnet is powerful, as Donne dares to think Death to be weak and feeble. The poet is so confident within his faith of God, and his apparent belief in the afterlife, that he is self assured that no harm will come to him from this one vain beast. Death will eventually be overcome; it is nothing to fear. The poet's feelings are vivid, and dangerous, and the reader is thrown into a reverie of shadows as such immoral thoughts are taken in. "Spring", a Petrarchan sonnet, contains an octave, which sets the scene of the ultimate beauty of spring, followed by a concluding sestet, revealing its real imperfections. Just as Adam and Eve committed original sin, resulting in the Garden of Eden being ruined, Manley-Hopkins declares that spring itself will, in time, be ruined if we continue to sin. With great feeling, the poet begs God to save the innocence of youth, and cease all wrongdoing, to preserve our glorious paradise that is spring. Run-on lines allow the real energy of spring to emerge, forcing the reader to scan their eyes over the words at an increasing acceleration, causing tremendous excitement and rush. ...read more.

Middle

"Look little low heavens", a quotation describing the thrushes' eggs, shows considerable feeling as the poet likens the eggs to something as beautiful and as perfect as heaven. The poet genuinely cares for saving springtime, and is doing his best to convey all of his ideas and views. "Shoot", describing the movement and the growth of plants, shows the energetic development of spring. The anticipation of the poet in the first few lines is phenomenal, as he places every aspect of spring with a brief yet vivid description, down into the depths of his sonnet. The newness of the new season has caused the poet to be overjoyed in awe of such splendour. There is no wonder that the poet wants to keep such beauty forever. Manley-Hopkins addresses Jesus, "Oh maid's child", and with such compassion and emotion. The maid is the Virgin Mary, and her child, of course, is Jesus. The poet desperately wants for an all-powerful figure from above to listen to his pleas. The poet's feelings are deep, and he begs for all sinning to be ceased. The poet begs God to preserve the innocence of youth, the girl and the boy, disallowing them to sin, therefore saving spring. It is as though God is the poet's last hope, as he begs him to make a change. The poet realises the true beauties of spring, and prays that they are not taken from man, as the Garden of Eden was taken from Adam and Eve. Great feeling is employed through the run-on lines, as the sonnet accelerates and becomes increasingly more energetic and fluent. Stressed words allow the reader to fixate on a precise image in their mind of perhaps what the poet was seeing, or how the poet was feeling. Also, at the times when the sonnet is specifically addressed to Jesus, or to the Lord, a more direct and powerful approach is taken, and the reader feels part of something very real, and very important: a decision, and a commitment summoned for to the heavens. ...read more.

Conclusion

Donne is as genuine as he could ever possibly be, and his faith is obviously a massive part of his life. His feelings are conveyed in such a way that the reader is entirely engrossed into the diction of the sonnet. In my opinion, although both sonnets are very successful and portray great strength of genuine feeling, I prefer "Holy Sonnet 10". I love the undeviating approach the sonnet offers, talking directly to Death as if it is merely a person. It is the sonnet that allowed my mind to wander the furthest, and it has opened my mind extensively to a new way of perceiving dying. If I had ever considered Death to be worth fearing, this sonnet has cured me, and proved to me that Death is nothing but a short sleep, before waking eternally. And when I do die, many of my friends and family will be in heaven waiting for me, as will I to the people I leave behind. It shows dying to be something other than the end, but more of a bridge that we all have to cross before we live eternally in peace. Death cannot kill me, and I see that now. Death is not a sad time, and we will all end up together anyway, in the end. John Donne, with his passionate feeling, has forced me to open my eyes, like some will never do, and see the bigger picture. We are all pawns in a game, and God is our master. Death has no real significance at all; it just thinks that it does. It is no real power, and deserves no real fear or respect. We will all, in time, overcome Death, and walk over that bridge into eternal bliss. Although "Spring" was itself, very meaningful, and touching, it does not portray just as much feeling as "Holy Sonnet 10", nor is it as easy to relate to wholly. The strength of feeling in both sonnets, overall, was exceptional. Francesca Selway 1 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Sonnets section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Sonnets essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Poem Analysis: Felix Randall By Gerald Maneley Hopkins.

    3 star(s)

    Second of all, a mould can also be a certain shape, which is used to pour in something and then get the same shape back but in a more solidified way. Hopkins could have used this to tell the reader that the world could be better place if every man was like Felix Randall.

  2. The Sonnet

    "I love thee freely, as men strive for Right; I love thee purely, as they turn from Praise." Elizabeth Barrett Browning uses a capital letter to emphasise the strong words in the sonnet such as Being, Right and Praise. The last six lines however, the sestet, express her true feelings

  1. The History of the Sonnet

    The teacher however does not seem to know that Keats spoke with a Cockney accent. Later in the sonnet, Harrison shows how Wordsworth spoke with an accent that rhymed "matter" with "water". In the first line, he uses the name "Demosthenes".

  2. Compare how the conventions of the sonnet

    By doing this Shakespeare is able to add more emphasis to the sonnets meaning as the reading of the sonnet is made to continuously flow just like his beloved's beauty. In Shakespeare's 'sonnet 73' we see a more conventional argument structure that is very typical of an English sonnet.

  1. Are there any ways in which you consider that experiences conveyed by the sonnets, ...

    The last two lines of the first stanza explain in more detail the way that women play games to encourage men to have feelings for them, but encourage her not to show any feelings for the men. The games that the women play demonstrate a childish approach to an adult

  2. Compare how love is portrayed in Sonnet 18,

    This poem has a typical sonnet form which means that it has 14 lines, each with 10 syllables.

  1. Explore aspects of the sonnet tradition through reference to a range of material you ...

    and this is also true of the repetitive nature in which Browning uses. " I love thee to the depth and breadth and height" (How do I love thee? line 2) In the last few lines she describes her love as fully as possible and pledges her life to him.

  2. Analysis of Sheakespeare's Sonnet 73 "That time of year thou mayst in me behold"

    It is set up almost identically to the first quatrain. The subject, the ?day?, is introduced in line 4, and is described further throughout the stanza. He is describing the twilight of the day, a time after the sun has set and dusk begins to fade into night.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work