• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

'Compare the ways that Marlowe and Chaucer present the theme of sin in 'Dr Faustus' and 'The Pardoner's Tale'.'

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Compare the ways that the two writers present the theme of sin in 'Doctor Faustus' and 'The Pardoner's Tale' Both 'Dr Faustus' and 'The Pardoner's Tale' seek to offer comprehensive views on both Christianity and its moral values. A particular emphasis in both texts is placed upon sin, and both the two eponymous characters, as well as the societies in which they live, seem to be incapable of halting their sins, or indeed redeeming them. Both Chaucer and Marlowe explore the theme of sin through several passages, one of which they have in common being their title characters. In 'The Pardoner's Tale', the Pardoner is shown immediately to be a dishonest character with very few moral values whatsoever. Chaucer's use of somewhat grotesque simile in his mere description makes us feel uneasy, with his hair 'as yellow as wax' hanging down 'like flax'. Later, when we are introduced to the principal aspects of his character, we find that he is dishonest, scheming and self-obsessed to the core. Moreover, he commits what the medieval world thought the greatest sin of all in that he is so proud of it. He tells us quite openly that his intentions are 'nought but to win [money], and nothing for correction of sin', and delights in recounting to the pilgrims how he is able to dupe his congregations into buying his pardons. ...read more.

Middle

The Pardoner, on the other hand, is far from oblivious of his sin, but sin itself is portrayed in a rather different way by Chaucer. Rather than have the sins parade to him, the Pardoner details personally what he considers to be the worldly sins to the pilgrims. This creates the additional irony when the audience discovers that the Pardoner himself is guilty of all of them. Were 'The Pardoner's Tale' simply a sermon, an audience would perhaps not take it seriously, given that the Pardoner's hypocrisy makes his words lack any true conviction or seriousness. However, the part-Parabolic nature of the tale itself brings a new element of meaning into the sins of 'The Pardoner's Tale'. The characters in the tale are described simply as 'three rioters', and the tale is clearly one of morality: The Pardoner does not focus on their deaths at the end of the tale, simply skating over the fact that 'they had him slain, and that anon', not getting drawn into the violent details but keeping the overall message of morality going. We know the Pardoner is only doing this in an attempt to make the pilgrims 'meekly receive' his pardon and bag him a profit, but nonetheless the tale can be taken a lot more seriously than the Pardoner's sermon given its uncanny resemblance to one of Jesus' Parables. ...read more.

Conclusion

In most of the play, good and evil are kept very distinct, with Faustus' 'Good Angel' and 'Bad Angel' consciences. However here, they become merged, and therefore it becomes more difficult to measure Faustus' sins. In 'The Pardoner's Tale', we do not suffer this problem. The Pardoner's hypocrisy actually clarifies good and evil all the more because he is so outrageous that we can spot the irony that the 'good' path of life he forwards is not the one he takes. Chaucer also attempts a satire at the Church system, because the Pope and cardinals are in on the Pardoner's game. The Pardoner has 'come from the Court of Rome' and he later tells us that he has been given pardons 'by the Pope's hand'. This gives us the impression that the Church, as well as the Pardoner, is using people's fear of their own sins and retribution to make money. Human sin is a key strand of thought throughout both texts, and both authors present it in ways that invoke entirely different emotional responses from their audiences: Marlowe's invitation of empathy and sorrow is entirely contrasted by Chaucer's effect of comedy and farce. However, both in their own ways still leave a message of morality, and their different presentations of sin both contribute heavily to the audience's need for self-reflection after seeing or hearing the text. Jack Harrison 1 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Christopher Marlowe section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Christopher Marlowe essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Explore the presentation of Faustus in the opening scenes.

    3 star(s)

    This quotation is from the first book of John and Faustus does no continue with the following line, which states our sins will be forgiven if we repent. This is a concept Faustus continually denies throughout the play leading to his fall.

  2. "An impressive opening, a marvellous ending, an indifferent middle". Does this twentieth century comment ...

    The speech he makes is a rhapsodic love poem, which is stunning when we consider the harsh theatrical contrast between Faustus' words (e.g. "O, thou art fairer than the evening air clad in the beauty of a thousand stars") and the sight of the old mans flesh being torn to pieces on stage.

  1. Comment on the relationship between the comic and serious material in Dr Faustus.

    Wagner then offers to teach the clown shape-shifting tricks "I will teach thee to turn thy self to a dog.." which draws great parallels with the next scene in which Mephastophilis responds to Faustus' question of " But may I raise up spirits when I please" with " Ay Faustus, and do greater things than these".

  2. In what ways and with what effects does 'Dr. Faustus' question the acquisition and ...

    Ride him over hedge or ditch, or where thou wilt, but not into the water' 6 (x. 14-6). He uses repetition here to stress the importance of the warning, however the horse-courser 'like a vent'rous youth' 7 (x.

  1. Faustus epitomises the dangers of knowledge without morality. Do you agree?

    It is due to his sacrilegious aspirations to be more than a man, to 'gain a deity,' that Faustus decides to discard his earthly studies, turning instead to 'conjuring' as a new challenge to his abilities. Believing that 'a sound magician is a mighty god,' he desires the power and

  2. Would You Consider Doctor Faustus to be a Medieval Morality Play or a Renaissance ...

    Earlier in the play, when Faustus queries Mephastophilis about the nature of the world, Faustus sees his desire for knowledge reach a dead end at God, whose power he denies in favour of Lucifer. He is given the gift of knowledge, and Mephastophilis willingly tells him all the secrets of

  1. How far would you say that the novel is not so much about Brighton ...

    In every case (Prewitt's, Frank's, Nelson Place) Brighton is associated with unhappiness and failure but also with a prison-like quality. As the reader, we wonder why Pinkie does not simply leave the town and his troubled life behind: the answer being, as Prewitt's Mestophanes quote suggests, that he cannot leave.

  2. What does the play show us about attitudes to sin and damnation?

    The conceptions are quite grand and it doesn't seem too bad when Valdes says, "Faustus, these books, thy wit, and our experience Shall make all nations to canonize us." Valdes is suggesting that by taking up necromancy they would be made saints, even though they are going against God and religion.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work