• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Comparing And Contrasting The Poems The Trees by Phillip Larkin and The Trees Are Down By Charlotte Mew

Extracts from this document...


´╗┐Comparing and contrasting poems The Trees and The Trees are Down The poems The Trees by Philip Larkin and The Trees are Down by Charlotte Mew are works that share a number of similarities and differences. While the seemingly positive and negative approaches to the subject are conflicting, there is more value to be found by comparing and contrasting the two pieces on a deeper level. In The Trees, Larkin uses metaphor and in The Trees are Down, Mew uses tone and allusion, but both poets utilize symbolism, format, meter and repetition to evoke contrasting messages; Larkin?s being that the cycle of life is set and cannot be changed while Mew?s emphasizes the message that the destruction of nature can be prevented. In the poem The Trees, Larkin uses metaphor to help express a deeper meaning behind the use of trees as his subject. He metaphorically uses the trees in order to represent people and the cycle of life. The process of growing up, who you are, the reputation you create for yourself and the lasting memory of it when one reaches death. ...read more.


Mew is trying to defend and protect the life of the trees; the purpose of this allusion is to help this objective. It also relates back to the defensive tone of the poem. Both poets use symbolism as well as repetition in the relation to springtime. In The Trees, Larkin discusses the springtime as a time of new life, where everything is at its fullest and most beautiful, but also a time to leave the past behind and begin ?afresh? (8). Just as the trees shed their leaves in the fall, they?re leaving behind the old and welcoming the new. With the arrival of spring, the new leaves come and everything is fresh. Larkin reinforces the spring with emphasis on the word ?afresh?(8) in the last line of the last stanza ?Begin afresh, afresh, afresh? (8). What Larkin is referring to is the time of year where life is new and the start of the cycle of life is at its peak with new life taking form again. ...read more.


These set restrictions to the format of the poem follow Larkin?s theme of the cycle of life. That like the format, its set and cannot be changed. The Trees are Down follows a different format. She uses a free verse form and structure. This format reinforces Mews protest that the trees should be left alone to live freely. It also represents the unpredictability of nature and how even though we can try and stop death and whatever comes in one?s way, there?s no stopping the future. Larkin and Mew both utilize similar tools to display different topics and different outlooks on the cycle of life. It is clear by understanding both of the poems that the poets appreciate nature for it natural beauty. Larkin uses metaphor and Mew uses tone, but both poets utilize symbolism, repetition, format and meter to stress the importance of the overall message of their poems, though they may contrast. For Larkin his belief is that what happens to nature and in life shall happen as it?s supposed to happen. Whereas, Mew believes that the cycle of life should not be disrupted and if it?s being threatened, harm can be prevented. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Comparative Essays section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Comparative Essays essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Compare and contrast 'MCMXIV' by Philip Larkin and 'Six Young Men' by Ted Hughes.

    3 star(s)

    Like Larkin's poem, Hughes's poem compares fragile human existence with the endlessness of Nature and puts us in the glade with an image that the reader can almost hear and see ("you hear the water of seven streams fall"). Hughes ends this stanza with another hard-hitting line, "though their faces

  2. "The Poplar Field" by William Cowper "Binsey Poplars felled 1879" by Gerard Manley Hopkins ...

    In the first stanza of Hopkins' "Binsey Poplars" it reflects the cutting down of the trees, "not spared, not one", giving us an example of man's mistreatment of nature. In the first stanza he also includes the most wonderful use of alliteration: "wind-wandering weed- winding bank".

  1. Compare the way Larkin and Plath present human relationships in their poems.

    These words also suggest that it doesn't matter if you are alone or in a couple, death is inevitable and will eventually bring life to an end. Words with negative connotations are used such as the afternoons being described as 'hollows'.

  2. Compare 'Mr Bleaney' (by Philip Larkin) & 'In Memory of My Grandfather' (by Edward ...

    To aggregate this all up there is an exceedingly diminutive amount of similarities in terms of language and imagery, but the difference always varies in various ways. We know what style the versifier used, but we have no idea of the poets feeling and attitude.

  1. Poetry Comparison - Charlottle Mew

    This poem is set in the present tense. However in the second stanza is a flashback in which she recalls, "finding a large dead rat in the mud of the drive". I think that this flashback is suggesting that if a dead rat can 'unmake the spring, then how much more destruction will the felling of the trees make?

  2. By comparing 'School for Scandal' and 'Rape of the Lock' explore the difference between ...

    suns shall set, as set they must, \ And all those tresses shall be laid in dust;\ This Lock, the Muse shall consecrate to fame, \ And midst the stars inscribe Belinda's name."

  1. How do the poets of "half-caste" and "search for my tongue" feel about their ...

    We would say "yourself" and "what" and "you" this adds to John Agard's style of the poem. John Agard also used a lack of punctuation. But John Agard reads the poem slow. However Sujata Bhatt has just spaced her poem on the page in a line.

  2. Women are dismissed as insignificant in both the poetry of Larkin and Eliot. How ...

    nature, although it is an unrealistic view, as only a small minority have truly felt love, and the majority in which he includes himself lead tragic and meaningless lives; ?As all they might have done had they been loved.? Eliot and Larkin both use women as a symbol of the superficiality and the obscene consumerist nature of society.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work