• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Comparing Faust and the Pardoner. 'It is only serious writing and tragedy that can successfully convey a moral. Comic writing necessarily fails.' In the light of this statement, explore how two texts use comic and serious effects to convey their moral.

Free essay example:

'It is only serious writing and tragedy that can successfully convey a moral. Comic writing necessarily fails.' In the light of this statement, explore how two texts use comic and serious effects to convey their moral.

Both texts are written in order to convey a moral; Marlowe tells the story of Faustus the “renaissance man who plays the medieval price for being one” as Dawkins puts. He wrote his tragedy in post reformation England during the renaissance period, a time where Renaissance values such as humanism took over the medieval values of the church. Through Faustus, Marlowe wanted to convey that the “reward of sin is death” something that Faustus the renaissance man cannot comprehend as he believes all men are sinful, he does this through a mixing elements of a tragic drama with comedic scenes which mirror the light vs dark themes of the play.

On the other hand, the Pardoner’s tale was written during a time where the church was very socially and economically involved in society. The majority of society was illiterate or could not afford books, for this reason the church would set out its teaching through sermons which had a moral to tell. The Pardoner’s moral theme is “Radix malorum est cupiditas”, however, Chaucer wrote the Pardoner’s tale in order to highlight the hypocrisy shown by the church, the Pardoner’s tale is a didactic satire in which Chaucer uses serious writing and comedy in order to convey that the love of money is the root of all evil.

Both texts have a religious theme to their morals, in which the characters go against god and therefore sin in some form. According to the David Kirkham; Christianity sees sin as “wounding to god” furthermore, the bible says “the wages of sin is death” and in the case of the three rioters they blaspheme and sin until they die. They start with gluttony, swearing and corruption and end with killing, they also go against god as they attempt to find death and kill him, something that in Christian belief can only be done by god.  Faustus also goes against god and this leads to his “damnation”; his sin is his renaissance ambition, he wants to become a “sound magician” and “demi-god”; as Davis puts, Faustus’ “ambitions for rich reward drive him into… ultimately tragic actions”.

Finally the Pardoner seems to be used by Chaucer as a vehicle to convey the corruption of the church, he is openly corrupt and labels himself a “vicious man” however, he also says “a moral tale yet I yow telle kan” he is aware that he’s a hypocrite, but in one respect always talks about the goodness of god, his downfall is ambiguous; he is not directly punished but is also left embarrassed at the end of the poem.

In the context of being a Greek tragedy, the moral of sin leading to death is conveyed through Faustus’ tragic flaw or his hamartia. Marlowe through the form of a tragedy attempts to create pity for the tragic hero, Faustus. He does this through his control of verse in Faustus’ soliloquies; the confident, arrogant Faustus we see in act 1 “A greater subject fitteth Faustus’ wit” contrasts with the scared and repenting Faustus in act 5 “O, spare me, Lucifer!-”  the way Faustus speaks in the 3rd person shows his arrogance, he is an atheist who does not fear god or the devil because he doesn’t believe in them, here we see what Aristotle called  his hubris, a pride that leads to his downfall. Furthermore the rhythm is fluent and in Iambic pentameter which illustrates his self-assured mind. In contrast, in act 5, Marlowe’s use of dashes and commas create an irregular pattern, mirrors the mind of Faustus, furthermore the repetition shown in “See, see where Christ’s blood streams” shows a spontaneous thought and feeling – “the confused mind of a frantic desperate man” as Roy Blatchford puts. Faustus finally fears god, but he is tragically too late.

The Pardoner uses the story of crucifixion in order to convey his moral.  Christians believed that Christ died for the sins of others, the Pardoner makes the point that by sinning the people are submitting Christ to re-crucifcation “Oure blissed Lordes body they totre” here he is very serious, the appalling physical and mental anguish created by the image of Christ adds depth to his point on sin. In addition, like Marlowe, Chaucer uses stylistic devices in order to convey his moral, and make it memorable; for example, the Pardoner uses exclamation and repetition “O cursed sinne of cursenesse!” to underline his point. It is interesting that the Pardoner is openly sinful “by thy myself be guilty in that sinne” yet still conveys the word of god; here he touches on a large theological debate of the time, can an evil man preach? One school of thought is that an evil person cannot know anything, because knowledge is love. However, others argue that the Pardoner does not sin, because his “relikes been they, as wenen they echoon” – The Pardoner’s relics are holy if people think they are, so if he is just trying to make a living, where is the sin? He brings people closer to god through his sermons, even if he is a hypocrite.

Marlowe interweaves comedic scenes within his tragedy in order to convey his moral. Taking inspiration from mystery plays by including a series of separate scenes which pass before the reader, the way Marlowe alternates between tragedy and comedy is a “deliberate structural strategy” as said by crossref-it.info. Marlowe contrasts scenes of serious discussion like A1 S1 “O, what a world of profit and delight” with the farcical exploits of Faustus for comedic effect, who tricks a Horse courser into buying a Horse which turns into a “bottle of hay” when it touches water.  The effect of this is to speed up time and therefore convey the inpending damnation of Faustus, furthermore the comedic scenes are used to show how Faustus’ aspirations deteriate as soon as he recieves the “heavenly” “necromantic books” from Mephosophilis. A Christian reading would indicate that only true power can come from god, and it is because of this Faustus commits more sin through avarice because he believes it will give him the happiness and salvation he craves.

On the otherhand, Chaucer uses comedy, mainly at the end of the poem, in order to show that the Pardoner has failed in his persuasion. The host is from the school of thought that an evil man cannot preech goodness, and is therefore outraged when the Pardoner asks for people to buy his relics, despite admitting they’re fake. Saying the Pardoner would have him “kisse thyn olde breech...swere it a relik of a seint” The Pardoner is left angry and embarassed at the thought of having his “collions” enshrined in “hogges toord”. This paints a vivid image, and therefore conveys the moral of the sermon, by showing how evil the Pardoner is, and how he has been corrupted by all the sins the church is supposedly against.  

The way both authors change between comic and serious tones is not only crucial to the way their stories are told, but also to the way they convey their morals. Without the comedic scene at the end, the Pardoner is left unscathed for all his sin, which would prove a poetic injustice for the reader. The contrast between the comic and tragic is used by Marlowe to show how Faustus aspirations and increasing feelings of regret and despair form the play’s most compelling structure, by the end of the play he is sorry for his sins asking “where is mercy now?” but as seen in the comedic scenes, he wasted his time on earth further blaspheming, instead of repenting, and it because of this that Faustus will “die eternally” illustrating Marlowe’s moral.

Ameer P

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Other Criticism & Comparison section.

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Related AS and A Level English Skills and Knowledge Essays

See our best essays

Related AS and A Level Other Criticism & Comparison essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    The English Patient

    5 star(s)

    Staying close to the patient, they can immerse themselves in his world of the past rather than face the problems of the present. The atomic bombs rip through this silence of isolation, reawakening the characters, especially Kip, to the reality of the outside world pressing in upon them.

  2. Marked by a teacher

    Both A Passage to India and Heart of Darkness can be interpreted as portraying ...

    4 star(s)

    according to their job or characteristics, characters such as The Helmsman, who had been educated by Marlowe's poor predecessor only to perform one task, and that was to steer the boat. Compared to Conrad, Forster might appear tame. Conrad depicts the brutality of imperialism in a shocking way, showing the

  1. The Use of The Four Elements in The Wars

    Authorities were overwhelmed as they tried to rescue the living and count the dead amid the destruction left by the powerful Hurricane Katrina"("Hurricane") This shows what water is capable of when it is not contained. When the manmade dams were overcome by the power of water during the Katrina disaster, the result was death on a massive scale.

  2. Compare Faustus and Everyman

    Everyman is a symbol of the human condition and how it is understood by medieval Catholicism. Whereas in the sixteenth century in which Doctor Faustus was written, saw a shift of Christian ideals. No longer was there only the strict belief in God but also the equal belief in the existence of the devil and the "work of the devil."

  1. Explore the corruption of morality and its consequences within the texts of Othello, The ...

    Through religion, Jed considers that he could manipulate Joe?s feelings through the ?the purpose? [of] Christ that is in you and that is you.? However, in ?The Picture of Dorian Gray?, it could be argued that Henry seems to purposely challenge Victorian values.

  2. Discuss the 'Fallen Woman' as a Familiar Feature of Victorian Writing

    to marry Carson because he was 'rich and prosperous and gay' and did not want Jem because he was a poor mechanic (152). Love in Tess causes the protagonist to 'fall' once more, yet the narrator earlier praises this kind of love: 'Clare knew that she loved him ...

  1. I shall be comparing the original Shakespeares Prospero with the Julie Taymors film adaption ...

    Prospero promises to grant freedom to his loyal helper-spirit and sends him to fetch the Boatswain and mariners from the wrecked ship. Ariel goes. 13. Prospero releases Alonso and his companions from their spell and speaks with them. He forgives Antonio but demands that Antonio return his dukedom.

  2. Shakespeares As You Like It and Khyenstse Norbus Travellers and Magicains are two texts ...

    The couple is also often presented on equal terms embracing each other, caring and showing affection through mid shots. Their connection leads Tashi to exclaim ?If I never left this place, and died right here with you, I would not die unhappy.? Norbu thus effectively supports the idea that meaning

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work