• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Comparing the poems, Salome, Hitcher, On My First Sonne and The Man He Killed.

Extracts from this document...


Comparing Poems The poems, Salome, Hitcher, On My First Sonne and The Man He Killed all have similar themes. The menacing and threatening ideas that the poets used are all based around death. However, each poem has a different perspective on the word with different motives and emotions. The Man He Killed is about a man who talks of the experience he had of shooting someone and the regrets he has for it. He feels guilty, as he has no conceivable explanation for shooting the man. He talks of the similarities he and his foe had such as 'He thought he'd 'list, perhaps, Off hand like - just as I.' The use of hesitation and repetition show the threatening side of the story. It is almost as if he himself is trying to construct an image in his mind as not to make himself look or feel guilty or censurable. ...read more.


The last he sees of the hiker, he is "bouncing off the kerb, then disappearing down the verge" - we do not know if he is dead or just badly injured. The driver does not appear to care. Simon Armitage uses the technique of writing in first person and colloquial speaking. He writes about violence in a very relaxed manner just as the person would have thought "without a care in the world". On My First Sonne is about a Father grieving for the death of his first Son. He believes he has sinned and that his sin is that he loved his Son too much. This menacing in a way as it is a confusing or immoral as it is strange too think a man could believe his Son died because he loved him too much. In the poem Salome, it appears that Salome has become a serial remover of heads. ...read more.


The differences are that Salome had pre meditated the act whereas the man in the Hitcher committed the act on the spot. Both of the poems are confusing and surreal as Hitcher is about the idea of jealousness compared to Salome, which is about the idea of hatred. Both The Man He Killed and On My First Sonne are menacing in a different way. They both are about guilt and empathy. The Man he Killed is a dramatic monologue of a man confessing to murder whereas On My First Sonne is an elegy to his Son. In On My First Sonne the man is desperate for the reason why his son was taken and feels pain and rage. When compared to The Man He Killed, he is looking for the reason for why he shot him but feels neither pain nor anger. All the poems show menacing and threatening ideas but are not all based around violence. The poets use technical methods to hide a story. They do this by using repetition of words, hesitations and enjambment. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Simon Armitage section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Simon Armitage essays

  1. Explore Armitage`s presentation of his relationship with his parents in the poems: "Mother, any ...

    son any credit for making the decision and blames it on peer pressure. On line five, he says "you should've had it through your nose instead" this is direct speaking again, it is also a opinion on what the father thinks about it and saying that the son is silly

  2. How does the poetry by Simon Armitage make the ordinary seem extraordinary?

    simile symbolises death "a rolled-up note of explanation planted there like a spray carnation". These two similes are to do with two very different things even though 'Cataract operation' and 'About his person' are very similar poems; they both have rhyming couplets inside them and are both 20 lines wrong,

  1. Comparative essay on poems from the 'Book of matches'.

    And at the end of the poem, he repeats this, 'but not the pendulum, the ticker/leave that where it stops or hangs' he does not say why he does not want his heart to be used again, maybe it is because it is the part of him that keeps him

  2. Kid - The poem is a dramatic monologue by Robin the Boy Wonder, the ...

    This emphasises how 'ordinary' his body is. * repairs: fillings and stitches and wounds (line5). This body is not perfect - it has been repaired as and where necessary and the scars still show. * a clock: the whole of the last six lines of the poem develop an extended metaphor of the heart being a clock.

  1. Simon Armitage - poetry

    Simon Armitage asks: "How can you judge this person? Here's somebody who for three-quarters of his life, or for three lines in every quatrain, did something good and then he did something bad and in one case, something that would be seen as unforgivable; so how do we judge him in the end?

  2. A Critical Appreciation of 'Cataract Operation', a Poem by Simon Armitage.

    The next line in the poem- 'the cancan of a ra ra skirt'- is just as vibrant a desription. What is really happening is that a skirt, on the washing line, is caught in the breeze and as it waves back and forth it resembles the movements of the skirt of a cancan dancer.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work