• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Comparing Two Short Stories one pre twentieth century and one twentieth century Compare and Contrast 'Teresa's Wedding' by William Trevor and 'The Three Sisters' by Jan Austen

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Comparing Two Short Stories one pre twentieth century and one twentieth century * Compare and Contrast 'Teresa's Wedding' by William Trevor and 'The Three Sisters' by Jan Austen In this essay, I will be comparing the two short stories - 'Teresa's Wedding' written by William Trevor and 'The three sisters' which was written by Jane Austen. Trevor's story written in the 20th century is set in Ireland while on the other hand; Austen's story was situated pre -twentieth century in the old 19th century England. Although both these stories are based upon marriage and how marriage is reflected within the eyes of the community it can be speculated that each author wants to show the audience a different view point on what they think towards the concept of marriage and the true value of it. For example, William Trevor uses a close and detailed description to create a sense of character and tone. This can be seen at the wedding reception at the bar in 'Teresa's Wedding' where he talks about the confetti: 'it lay thickly on the remains of the wedding cake, on the surface of the bar and the piano, on the table and on the two small chairs that the lounge bar contained' From looking at this we can immediately see that William Trevor is writing in detail and makes the audience read beneath the surface of the passage. ...read more.

Middle

In addition to this, Mary Stanhope seems to be self centred, judgemental and very conscientious compared to her other sisters. She appears to be changing her mind a lot about Mr Watts - 'I hate him' and 'I am the happiest creature in the world'. She is contradicting herself which can also show that she is very judgemental and juvenile. The text and the different moods that Jane Austen has applied to the character of Mary Stanhope is intelligent in some way as she creates humour as we read on. In other words she has very cleverly secreted the irony of the humour within the passage itself, so as a result the reader has to unveil the irony as they read. Furthermore when we look at the attitudes of Mary we can see that the attitudes of women have changed these days. The fact that women these days are not concerned about their social status and being the first girl to marry in the family contrasts with the idea of Mary who is in turn looking for pride, status and independence - Mary is very materialistic. In contrast to this, 'Teresa's Wedding' by William Trevor does not follow the idea of the eldest girl having to be the first girl to marry in the family as to being a triumph, but instead William Trevor wants to show his audience the true meaning of love and its value. ...read more.

Conclusion

kind of marriage together because there was nothing that could be destroyed, no magic' We can see that through William Trevor's eyes he thinks that if love is such a powerful element then it can withstand anything, even deceit. I think that although Jane Austen and William Trevor have different ideas towards love and society they have both accomplished their aims as they present these ideas to audience which makes them understand. For example, the irony both authors employ towards love make the reader unveil the humour which is hidden or secreted within the passages and it is this tool which makes the reader appreciate the true meaning of love and its value. Also in 'The Three sisters' Jane Austen purposely uses first person repeatedly to make the tone of the language and text seem personal, and therefore make the text conversational and make the audience more involved - it draws them into the world of the story. Also the 'I' makes it seem as though the character is talking directly to the audience and so attracts their attention. Furthermore I think William Trevor has produced such a good story as he likes following the character very closing and explains them in detail and therefore allows the reader to pay close attention to what is going on. Amish Patel 11OG ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Jane Austen section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Jane Austen essays

  1. 'Blackout' is a short story by Roger Mais. It is set in Jamaica and ...

    It is a third person narrative. During the story, we actually empathize with the man. Because of his behavior, there is a certain respect built for him and a sense of antagonism grows for the woman. The main themes of this story are, 'racism' and 'intimacy'.

  2. How does Jane Austen present the themes of love and marriage in the novel ...

    Emma can not marry Mr Knightly while her father lives, any marriage would greatly trouble him, and Emma wonders how to give the news to Harriet. Emma gets Harriet invited to stay with Isabella in London, where she would be distracted.

  1. Compare and contrast the short stories "Mr. Loveday's Little outing" by Evelyn Waugh, and ...

    They are going to visit Lord Moping, Angela's father in the County Asylum and again, through the latter's wife's manner of speech we can see that she does not approve of her husband being in an Asylum.

  2. Katherine Mansfield's Presentation of Happiness 'Bliss' and 'The Little Governess' are two short stories ...

    In 'Bliss' Bertha does not know what to do when she discovers that her husband is having an affair. 'Oh what is going to happen now?' she cries at the end of this powerful story. She feels paralysed. Although she describes her husband's smile as a 'hideous grin', which implies

  1. Argue that the theory of common sense structures provides an important and hitherto unappreciated ...

    more familiar varieties of abstract geometry stand to physics in the standard quantitative sense.(7) The Austro-Italian School of Gestalt Theory In some respects parallel to the Berlin Gestalt tradition of K�hler and Wertheimer is the work of the Graz school around Alexius Meinong (under whom Ehrenfels had studied in Vienna).

  2. Charlotte Bronte's Jane Eyre - "love is like playing the piano. First you must ...

    George Knightly in Emma is the critique of Emma's behavior. He is the voice of sound judgment in the novel, pointing out where Emma has gone wrong in actions. Emma is inferior morally to Mr. George Knightly, while Jane is superior in moral values to Mr.

  1. Compare the relationships of the two sets of sisters from Howard’s End by E.M ...

    Again in this story there are many important characters. It too is set around families and brings and joins them all together in the last few chapters of the book, giving it a wonderful and unpredictable ending. The main family in the novel is the Dashwoods. They are introduced right at the beginning of the novel and the whole story follows the sisters Marianne, Elinor and Margaret.

  2. how doe arthur miller create tension in the crucible

    John and Elizabeth's relationship is still getting better however John still thinks of himself as 'a fraud' and a 'no good man'. Elizabeth doesn't want John to think this , this is made clear where she says 'Do as you will, do as you will.'

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work