comparison of the 'Tipperary Days' and 'A Bitter Taste' sections of the anthology, Up the line to death

Authors Avatar

Comparison of “A Bitter Taste” and “Tipperary Days”

There are similarities and differences in the ideas, attitudes and style of ‘Tipperary Days’ and ‘A Bitter Taste’, including the idea that life carries on during war reflected in both poems and the mention of death.

‘A Bitter Taste’ mentions the idea of deception in the recruitment campaigns; “Lads, you’re wanted, go and help” plays on the idea that going to war is honourable, glorious and that they will have all the girls; that if you are given a feather by the ‘girls with feathers’, you should be ashamed, as you are not defending your country and her pride.

It continues on to talk about how the young men are wanted to ‘help to swell the names in the casualty lists’, not for the glory, merely to become a statistic. The level of danger which the soldiers are in is mentioned, “more poor devils like yourselves/waiting to be killed by you”; it is a matter of life and death, not just honour and glory, as it is mentioned as. The poets also want to tell the reader how the truth should have been told, “and don’t we damned well know/how the message ought to read”, they wanted the public to be told how horrendous it was and the realities of trench life, not simply that it is glorious.

Join now!

However, in ‘Tipperary Days’, this is not mentioned; these poems are not about recruitment and the falseness of those promises, it is about how war changes you, how your expectations of life alter, “and greater than a poet’s fame/a little grave that has no name”; the war brought a chance of greater glory, to redeem yourself and become noble and honourable, all your previous faults and sins will be forgotten. Nevertheless, death is meaningless, “yet many a better one has died before”, spreading the message that you are not as special as you think you are, you will not be ...

This is a preview of the whole essay