• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Courtship Of Mr Lyon and Wolf Alice Comparison Essay

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Extract: The Courtship of Mr Lyon from 'the voice that seemed to issue from a care full of echoes' to 'he went on all fours'. Using this extract as your starting point and this reference to one other story of your choice, you should: -Explore Carter's manipulation of language to develop the voice of the lion and the reaction of the girl to it. -Examine how Carter exploits the voices of her characters in both stories to comment on attitudes towards characters that are different. The Courtship of Mr Lyon loosely refers to the main storyline presented with the fairytale; The Beauty and The Beast. It is heavily feminine and throughout strives for the equality between men and women, despite their potential 'otherness's'. Combined with Wolf Alice, loosely based on Lewis Carroll's: Alice through the Looking Glass, Carter uses a variety of linguistics and literary techniques in order to communicate a strong sense of voice to the reader. Developing this, then enables Carter to manipulate language to suggest the reactions and relationships between characters within both stories. Throughout the extract, Carter uses a third person omniscient narrative in order to create a sense of separation from events, potentially mimicking the attitudes of society. ...read more.

Middle

The Beast sees the 'absolute sweetness' of Beauty, an ambiguous syntactic parallel, suggesting to the reader that not only the Beast, but Beauty too possesses 'otherness', as her beauty, 'who looked as if she had been carved out of a single pearl' hinders her development, she is treated as a possession, and has very little idea how to interact with humans alongside her in society. Within Wolf Alice, a third person restricted narrative is used to emphasise the central character's sense of 'otherness' within the story. Described as a 'ragged girl', with a 'panting tongue' that 'runs on all fours', Wolf Alice is introduced as different from the rest of the society. The voice of the narrator stating 'her pace is not our pace'. The inclusive audience address of 'our' perhaps suggesting, similar to within The Courtship Of Mr Lyon, that society wishes to separate themselves from people that appear different, or unique, a belief that Carter wishes to challenge, emphasised by the phrase; 'she was lonely enough'. However, the repetition of the lexis 'pace' may suggest similarities between Wolf Alice and the rest of society, even though different, there are similarities also, Wolf Alice is not entirely different. ...read more.

Conclusion

If they had been accepting and nurturing, the Duke may have been able to blossom and progress, yet their harsh, judgemental actions have secluded the Duke, leading him to live a primal life, no conscious present. However, throughout the story, Wolf Alice grows and matures from a child to a woman, gradually developing human-like characteristics, such as the need for hygiene, 'looking for rags to sop the blood up'. After meeting the Duke, Wolf Alice continues to progress and encourages the Duke to do so too. Finally, 'as if brought into being by her soft, moist, gentle tongue... the face of the Duke' appears in the mirror. The ideas of the story concluded, similar to The Courtship Of Mr Lyon, Wolf Alice and the Duke both accept their otherness, and encourage the other to do so. All are able to find happiness and live contently despite the views society may possess. Carter is suggesting that feminism does not mean a dominating sex, but equality between them, as each is equal within creation. In conclusion Carter's use of literary and linguistic techniques successfully portray the sense of voice and the reactions of characters within both stories to the idea of otherness. Her final ideas are concluded well within both stories, creating a clear message which resonates and questions the reader, encouraging them to consider their actions within a modern-day society. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Composition section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Composition essays

  1. Loneliness in The Catcher in The Rye (persuasive essay)

    Holden spends time with Ackley because unlike many others at Pencey, Ackley is at least a genuine person and not a phony. This event creates suspense, because if Ackley did not finally say that Holden could stay, Holden would have stopped talking to Ackley.

  2. Free essay

    Hamlet essay

    figure; "Hercules", then perhaps Hamlet would have had no reason to want to avenge Claudius. In Hamlet's eyes no one can replace his father. Hamlet needed Claudius' affinity as a brother, someone he could relate to, after the death of his father, not someone who would dictate to him.

  1. English Self-Evaluation Essay. I have argued against my mistakes that have presented themselves with ...

    And how I described my personal experience with gender-restrictive language as an aunt"Now that they have inhabited the world long enough to be pressured with the apparent do's and don'ts of manliness, they have been quick to realize that Polly Pocket and Barbie unfortunately do not meat these strict qualifications"

  2. Commentary on Lewis Carroll

    An identical graphology is built so that when one looks at my transformation it looks identical to that of Tobias Smollet's letter. The chapter heading 'Dear Dr. Lewis' is replaced by 'Dear Lorina'- the supposed sister's name and the date '4th May' acquired through careful study of 'Alice in wonderland':

  1. Disability Essay AP

    I believe that what Dubus is saying is true; cripples do not need uplifting events and pity, but the enduring respect from society. Both Mairs and Dubus use antithesis to make their message clear. Dubus states that "seeing the flesh as only a challenge to the spirit is as false

  2. Kaffir Boy Argumentative Essay

    Mathabane's account of the evangelical's arrival shows just this. "I watched the evangelist bring in equipment in mud-covered jeeps, while pondering on what could have possibly made my mother say so positively that my father would take us to the tent to listen to what he called "white man's nonsense and lies."

  1. How do Prospero and two Other Characters of Your Choice Change in the Course ...

    Finally, I will explore how King Alonso's attitude and behaviour changes throughout the play. Alonso is the King of Naples who has a brother, Sebastian and a son, Ferdinand. He plays a part in helping Antonio over-throw Prospero. He is on his way back from his daughters weeding when we

  2. The Pearl by John Steinbeck

    Does this seem a calm and happy family? Yes it seems to be a happy family because Kino and Juana love each other and they have a son that they love too. Once again the Song of the Family can prove to us that it is a peaceful and happy family.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work