• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Discuss Hares use of Sir Peter as a criticism of societys legal system in Act 1 Scene 2 and in 'Murmuring Judges' as a whole.

Extracts from this document...


Re-read Act 1 Scene 2 of Murmuring Judges (p3-9). Discuss Hare's use of Sir Peter as a criticism of society's legal system in this extract and in the play as a whole. In Act 1 Scene 2, and in the whole of Murmuring Judges, Sir Peter is used by Hare to represent the negative side of the legal system; namely, that lawyers are only concerned with upholding their own wellbeing and reputation. In this scene, Sir Peter's arrogant character conveys that lawyers at the top of the judiciary system have an impersonal, non-compassionate view towards the individuals they are supposed to be defending. For example, the fact that Sir Peter "smiles, unruffled" when challenged about losing a case reflects his lack of care for the suspect he poorly defended, therefore he is inconsiderate about how his failure has had a detrimental effect on the suspect. The audience perceives this due to his salient facial expression, therefore receiving Hare's intended message that the system at the time was self-absorbed and incapable of sympathy. ...read more.


The fact that Hare uses the adverb 'fatally' to depict Sir Peter's hesitation portrays him as fallible, a quality which Sir Peter attempts to hide through the bravado in his subsequent statement regarding the tickets' cost, so the audience understands that he is purely concerned with his own reputation in the eyes of others. In the focus scene, Sir Peter's attitudes are depicted as being out-dated, and these function as a microcosm for the obsolescence of various aspects of the legal system. His egotism leads him to forming the inaccurate notion that "Everyone listens to Desert Island Discs, thus the audience becomes aware of his out-dated views which have no basis on the interests of the modern public. Irina is a symbol of contemporary values in society due to her being a female ethnic minority in a traditionally Caucasian, male-dominated institution, therefore her visual response, to "[look] down, impassive" is received positively by the audience, who consequently bear disdain towards Sir Peter for his views which are incompatible with modern ones. ...read more.


This prejudice still exists today, so Hare's social message about the self-absorbed ideas of the courts are still applicable, the courts attitudes having not adapted to modern views. Likewise, Sir Peter's lack of interest in the statistics ostensibly circulated to him by the Home Secretary appertaining Germany and Sweden is another example of his nonchalance regarding contemporary attitudes, because Germany and Sweden were and still are considered two of the most liberal, 'modern' nations in the world and so their methods of tackling crime would likely involve modern points of view, ones which Sir Peter takes no interest in because they are not of immediate relevance to the way the courts are run in this country. Hare is thus portraying Sir Peter as somewhat xenophobic and nationalistic, traits which, in the rapidly increasingly liberal British society of the early 1990's, were being minimised, so the audience perceives Sir Peter, and the courts in general as a consequence, as incompatible with modern Britain. ?? ?? ?? ?? By James Day ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Other Play Writes section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Other Play Writes essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Re-read Act 2 Scene 6 of Murmuring Judges. Discuss Hares presentation of the position ...

    3 star(s)

    In addition, the power possessed by the women is augmented by Hare's use of setting: the women are granted power due to their physical oversight of the city; "Below her, London is laid out." Their being above the city emphasises their righteousness as they seek to restore some of Gerard's

  2. Re-read Act 1 Scene 7 of Murmuring Judges. Discuss the effects of Hare's use ...

    Mozart in this scene in order to, primarily, rouse the audience and incite in them an enhanced, emotionally-charged state in which they are thus more attentive to the play and more receptive to Hare's social messages, particularly those appertaining racial prejudice and social injustice.

  1. David Hare's criticism of the Legal System in Scene 1 Acts 1 - 4

    By making us feel sympathy for Gerard, Hare is criticising the prison induction system on its poor service and lack of attention to the prisoners. He also begins to build up our dislikes towards the justice system, as the audience begin to feel Gerard has been falsely imprisoned.

  2. With detailed reference to at least three of the monologues, discuss how the narrators ...

    It is clear from the start that she doesn't want to go into a nursing home from what she talks about what Zulema threatens her with.

  1. Explore the ways R.C. Sherriff presents the attitudes of key characters in 'Journey's ...

    much more sentimental when it comes to remembering their opposite sex, as opposed to the substantially more light-hearted men of Saint Quentin, who talk about women mainly as a distraction.

  2. Murmuring Judges

    But we can see in this exchange with Woody her uneasiness with this collusion when she answers ironically, 'Yes, I must remember. It's all a big joke.' When Sir Peter appears unloading his papers and clothes onto Woody, as if he was a 'manservant' the first thing he says is

  1. Discuss the view that Tony Lumpkin in "She Stoops to Conquer"is nothing more than ...

    Goldsmith uses a cyclical structure to further highlight how Tony is trapped in his unambitious, mundane life. In the final lines of the play, Goldsmith identifies that Tony is ?his own man again?, the use of the word ?again? reflects the lack of development in Tony?s character, nothing has improved

  2. The Presentation of the Legal Establishment in "Murmuring Judges" by David Hare.

    doesn?t have very nice connotations with it as a dreary and impassive place seems very hard to work in; which could explain the characters of the play and I guess we could say it reflects some of their personalities. The legal establishment is also portrayed to be very well-educated and qualified.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work