• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Discuss these two views and consider any other response of your own, as regards the behaviour and character of Hamlet.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

'Even with his death, Hamlet has achieved nothing.' - O'Toole 'Finally, He has not failed.' - Granville Barker Discuss these two views and consider any other response of your own, as regards the behaviour and character of Hamlet. Johann Chipol The play 'Hamlet' contains some of the most debatable choices ever written. Allegedly inspired by 'The Spanish Tragedy' by Thomas Kyd, It emphasizes on a hero's emotional dilemma. Many of these decisions were acted by the character Hamlet who is a man filled with contracting thoughts. Because of his state of mind, the majority of his acts ended with frustration and fatal consequences. This raises an important question, should the audience feel sympathetic towards him or should they see him as failure for his lack of motivation. In order to understand Hamlet's character and his reasons for his actions, one needs to understand the manner in which he pursues his revenge mission, and the different interpretations of these views. Hamlet's desire for revenge is continually manipulated by the actions of the other characters as well as developments of his situation. A definite feature is how he procrastinates almost every important act needed to avenge his father's death. This mental act has created various theories from critics. Harbage suggests that Hamlet suffers from a 'lymphatic temperament', who is a type of person who lacks the 'energizing temperament to act'. This very physical view is a very far-fetched theory which is later proven wrong in the final scene of the play. ...read more.

Middle

This may sound far-fetched through our modern standards but this is the beliefs of the Elizabethan Era. Delay was one of the conventions of revenge tragedy that Shakespeare inherited. Thomas Hanmer makes a practical point that if the Prince carried out his father's instructions straight away 'there wouldn't be a play'. Yet other critics have found that the delay was Shakespeare's attempt to investigate the psychological point of the human mind. However, this psychological perspective has raised the question as to how successful Hamlet was in his task. Was his procrastination able to help him accomplish his goals or did it help him fail to perform the perfect assassination? The last scene see Hamlet finally taking advantage of his situation without any hesitation, stabs the King with the poisoned tipped sword. This attack splits the views of the audience. The audience could either celebrate the fact that Hamlet has been able to kill Claudius or question if all this tragic waste could have been avoided. It is quite ironical that he finally gets all the evidence as well as the confidence to kill his nemesis when he is on the verge of dying. Critics are very mixed in the views of whether or not Hamlet has gained any success in his mission for vengeance. Even though the task was completed, Hamlet's unorthodox approach has created more and more problems for him as the play progressed. ...read more.

Conclusion

He has gain self-satisfaction and has lived up to his so called heroic reputation. Yet his achievements in this mission are all selfish. Even though he has overcome depression, it seems that his victory has not helped any of the other characters. This win has created fatal consequences that has made dramatic changes through out the play. This is where critics would believe that Hamlet has failed in his attempts to outsmart and kill Claudius. Because of his 'fatal flaw' he has been the direct or indirect cause of the deaths of Polonius, Ophelia, Queen Gertrude, Laertes, Rosencrantz and Guildenstern. Many of Shakespeare's tragedies has a character with a fatal flaw. Macbeth's flaw was ambition and Othello's was jealously. Hamlet's fatal flaw was his intelligence and mental stability. This has given him the advantage of sympathy and the disadvantage of frustration. Hamlet's victory is both a success and an unsuccessful. He is unsuccessful as his procrastination and ways of trying to outwit King Claudius has resulted in mass deaths yet he has been able to achieve his goal of overcoming his fears. His reputation hasn't been tarnished because of this which was one of Hamlet's main concerns. At that point, he decided to finally let fate control his destiny and has now died a proud man. Lines 369 - 372 'If thou didst ever hold me in thy heart, Absent thee from felicity awhile, And in this harsh world thy breath in pain, To tell my story. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Hamlet section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Hamlet essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Polonius has sometimes been presented as an essentially comic character and sometimes as a ...

    4 star(s)

    When speaking to Ophelia, for example, Polonius advises her on her relationship with Hamlet 'Do not believe his vows, for they are brokers' [Act 1 sc.3 line 127]; in Kenneth Branagh's production of the play, Ophelia has already slept with Hamlet, and Branagh makes use of flashbacks in Ophelia's mind

  2. Scene by Scene - Hamlet.

    how the murderer gets the love of [the murdered man]'s wife", the king stands up, shouts "Give me some light! Away!", Polonius calls for torches ("Somebody get the lights..."), and everybody runs out. It seems to me that the entire Danish court realizes (or will soon realize)

  1. Some critics have seen Gertrude as innocent, others as central to the evil in ...

    Once Gertrude has tasted the lavish life of a queen is it possible that she can go back to not being a royal? The marriage shows us that she is completely selfish and emotionless. In Victorian times mourning would go on for months possibly even years.

  2. Hamlet's soliloquies are embarrassingly outdated and unnecessary" "The soliloquies are what make the play. ...

    These references could make the soliloquies seem outdated as they are ancient, mythological characters and may not have much relevance to the audience of the time. The second critic takes the opposing view and claims that the soliloquies 'make the play' and 'bring the audience closer to Hamlet and offer profound observations on humanity.'

  1. In Act two, everyone notices a change in Hamlet because he has began his ...

    is led to believe. Having failed in his efforts to have Hamlet executed in England, the King is now playing on Laertes to seek revenge. Hamlet seems to acknowledge the vengeful feelings of Laertes but does not appear to feel responsible for murder.

  2. Hamlet’s dilemma.

    he has not yet done the deed To fully understand Hamlet's inaction, it is important to look at revenge. Revenge is not exacted until the evil deeds of the offender are revealed and the public knows the truth. Only then does the thought of death come into revenge.

  1. "Hamlet is better at talking about delay than he is at doing it. Consider ...

    However, towards the end of the play he begins to voice the opinion that after death there is nothing. "Alexander died, Alexander was buried, Alexander returneth to dust; the dust is earth..." This shows the influences of Montaigne. Montaigne was a French writer who died whilst Shakespeare was in his late twenties, whose works leant towards Epicureanism.

  2. Criticism on Hamlet

    With the single exception of "Cymbeline," they either place before us at one glance both the past and the future in some effect, which implies the continuance and full agency of its cause, as in the feuds and party-spirit of the servants of the two houses in the first scene

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work