• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Discuss Yeats presentation of how Ireland has changed in September 1913

Extracts from this document...


Discuss Yeats? presentation of how Ireland has changed in ?September 1913?. In your answer, explore the effects of language, imagery and verse form and consider how this poem relates to other poems by Yeats ?September 1913? reflects upon Yeats? distaste at the modern state of Ireland; the poet discusses his outrage at the fact that the Irish society has become one that is self-absorbed, and Yeats condemns the fact that Irish culture and art is no longer in the prime focus of society, instead lost to materialism and mundane routine. Yeats? initial gripe is revealed in the first line of the poem, where he questions Irish society ?What need you, being come to sense?; he sees the new modern society as one full of disappointment, and an apparent lack of purpose. He presents his views of disgust at the fact that society has being stagnated and its life force drained from it, ?you have dried the marrow from the bone?. Significantly Yeats puts the blame on the Irish themselves ? the first stanza takes on an accusatory tone in that the poet directly and repetitively refers to the people as ?You?. ...read more.


The ending lines end with the refrain ?Romantic Ireland?s dead and gone?, pointing at the apparent destruction of Irish culture. This is also portrayed in ?The Fisherman?, where Yeats similarly criticises ?the commonest ear? for ?[beating] down? Ireland?s ?great Art?. The poem also expresses Yeats? dismay at the fact that the new modern Ireland has failed to bring about any greater change; he can only allude to ?they? who ?were of a different kind?, in reference to the historical Irish nationalist figures who Yeats believes in this line to be more well-learned, especially in comparison to the current Irish nationalists such as in ?Easter 1916?, where he criticises Con Markievicz for staying ?in ignorant good will?. Yeats repetitively accuses modern society of failing to meet their grandeur, even though they had ?stilled? (their) childish play?; these great characters held influence previously and Yeats is dismayed that they no longer do so despite in his opinion deserving larger recognition from modern Ireland. Yeats contrasts these characters with the modern Ireland, noting that these figures had ?little time?to pray?, in comparison to the modern society who would offer ?prayer? to aid Ireland?s identity, yet lacking any real action. ...read more.


He alludes to ?the wild geese [spreading]?, a metaphor for Ireland?s previous will to intervene and fight in other countries for Irish interests, expressing remorse for the fact that Ireland has now become too self-absorbed; the final stanza assumes that modern Irish society would simply view these significant figures as being ?maddened? by ?some woman?s yellow hair?, in reference to their obsession with Irish culture. In this sense Yeats is critical that modern Ireland sees these important historical figures in this way, and responds curtly with ?let them be, they?re dead and gone?, in remorse of their sacrifice. The final refrain describes their passion as ?with O?Leary in the grave?, a finality which Yeats is deeply disappointed with, and Yeats? ?The Second Coming? also describes ?anarchy loosed? in society, and modern Ireland similar destroyed in this way. The mixed half rhyme scheme of the entire poem details Yeats? view that Ireland?s culture has been shattered and left in a confusing mess. Yeats describes his cynicism and disappointment with the new modern Ireland which he views as being too focused on the material aspect of life, failing to understand the significance of Irish culture and art form. Yeats criticises this very society as being responsible for the changes, the ?marrow? as the life force of Irish culture ?dried?. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level W.B. Yeats section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level W.B. Yeats essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    By close examination of "An Irish Airman Forsees his Death" and one other appropriately ...

    3 star(s)

    I guard I do not love" Yeats' use of antithesis emphasises Gregory's ambivalence with regard to the cause for which he fights.

  2. 'An Irish airman foresees his death' and 'Wild swans at Coole'

    This verse shows real unhappiness and sadness in the stanza as it shows that the poet knows the swans will one day fly off and leave him alone again and companionless as the swans remind him of happier times and what used to be instead of what is.

  1. Which Party was more successful in dealing with the Irish question between 1885 and ...

    A new proposed Bill was discussed by Gladstone and his party, who talked to Irish Nationalists who were both Parnellite and anti-Parnellite. The outcome of the discussions was a draft much the same of that of 1886, however some alterations were made to make it more digestible for the Liberals who had voted previously against Home Rule.

  2. How effective is W.B Yeats in cautioning the modern reader on the melancholic, the ...

    For example, what is the turning, what is the old era, and what is the new era the speaker is looking for, etc. They leave a question mark in the minds of the readers. Overall all the methods used in the poem can only provide some hint for it.

  1. Love is a common theme in poetry and it has been written about for ...

    This is an indication of how Maud Gonne when she is old may sit by the fire and read a book by Yeats and realise how much she really meant to him. Nature again is mentioned giving images of, "Mountains overhead" and "Amid a crowd of stars."

  2. William Butler Yeats' poem "The Second Coming" is filled with metaphoric imagery that reflects ...

    "The Second Coming" was written during the midst of the Irish civil war fought in 1921. The war fought over the conditions of the peace treaty that had come at the end of the Anglo-Irish war which last from 1919 to 1921.

  1. "Irish nationalism was a propaganda concept" - Discuss, with reference to the sources.

    The source itself is not very helpful in discerning an answer for this because it does not explain Markievicz's reasons for joining the side of the Irish. The other two sources, both recruitment posters of a sort, are definitely propaganda, and show all the signs of propaganda.

  2. Focusing on Wild Swans at Coole, discuss the theme of time and change in ...

    In the second stanza, Yeats remembers how, that first time, before he had quite finished counting them, he saw the swans 'All suddenly mount/ And scatter wheeling in great broken rings'; an image of great strength and majesty. He describes the sound of their beating wings as 'clamorous'; perhaps a

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work